Toggle sidebar

Celebrini for CALDER

gaucholoco3 said:
My argument to that is that Celebrini’s having the most impressive season since Crosby. The underlying numbers of Celebrini as an 18 year old are unprecedented. If voters only look at stats he will lose. If they watch the games there is no argument Celebrini is having the more impressive season.
Click to expand...

You’re underselling Hutson’s numbers. His points as a rookie d-man are eye-popping
 
Watching Bedard yesterday and comparing him to Celebrini, right now, in the NHL, there’s just no contest. I think they both had whatever games against each other but Celebrini makes an impact all over the ice, so even on a bad day he’s visible. Other than call the ref something terrible, Bedard did nothing.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Chinaski89
gaucholoco3 said:
The years that goalies have won were also in years with no strong skaters. This year 2 skaters are having seasons that would run away with the award most years. I do think Wolf should get consideration but he likely won’t get enough.

It will be fascinating to see the East coast bias clash with the give it to the guy who will have the best career bias.

I think Celebrini will take it by hair.
Click to expand...
its odd, the east coast bias thing exists in most years but the east coast seems more enamoured with celebrini than hutson. theres also wolf to split the canada vote, and michkov would influence the vote as well.

I think a big thing is celebrini likely is ranked 2nd at lowest where the above 4 could be mix-matched.

betting odds still have him at -190, meaning heavy favourite right now
 
KarlssonsGroin said:
its odd, the east coast bias thing exists in most years but the east coast seems more enamoured with celebrini than hutson. theres also wolf to split the canada vote, and michkov would influence the vote as well.

I think a big thing is celebrini likely is ranked 2nd at lowest where the above 4 could be mix-matched.

betting odds still have him at -190, meaning heavy favourite right now
Click to expand...
I think the fact he may not even win the rookie scoring title, let alone to a defenseman (regardless of games missed) almost makes it a forgone conclusion that one of the two playoff players (if they make it) will win.

gaucholoco3 said:
My argument to that is that Celebrini’s having the most impressive season since Crosby. The underlying numbers of Celebrini as an 18 year old are unprecedented. If voters only look at stats he will lose. If they watch the games there is no argument Celebrini is having the more impressive season.
Click to expand...
At the end of the day stats count for 75% if it. 20% goes to the influence on the team’s overall improvement and 5% just on wow factor.
 
CHALUPA said:
You’re underselling Hutson’s numbers. His points as a rookie d-man are eye-popping
Click to expand...
He might accumulate points but they are not from him driving play. Getting secondary assists is not as impressive. He also has infinitely better teammates and easier competition than Celebrini.

So while his numbers are eye popping I’m not impressed
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian
gaucholoco3 said:
He might accumulate points but they are not from him driving play. Getting secondary assists is not as impressive. He also has infinitely better teammates and easier competition than Celebrini.

So while his numbers are eye popping I’m not impressed
Click to expand...

I greatly prefer Macklin as a player, don’t get me wrong. I’m just won’t be surprised if Hutson wins it, because he’s hitting legendary territory for rookie point totals for a defenseman.
 
KarlssonsGroin said:
I think a big thing is celebrini likely is ranked 2nd at lowest where the above 4 could be mix-matched.

betting odds still have him at -190, meaning heavy favourite right now
Click to expand...
I think this is very real and could explain why the betting markets consider him the favorite. I could see Wolf or Hudson 3rd or 4th on some ballots but I find it hard for Celebrini to get any 4th place votes. He will likely be 1 or 2 in most ballots.
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian and Sandisfan
Because of MTL's playoff push, Hutson is in the best position to continue racking up points over the rest of the season, and thus bolster his case. Plus he'll get even more eyes on him as those games will be electric. Celebrini and the Sharks sit in contrast on both fronts, which really hurts his case and is a shame.

If Celebrini is going to win, he's going to have to out produce Hutson AND voters are going to have to watch the games to see everything that doesnt end up on the scoresheet. Hutson gets/will get that benefit
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian
tiburon12 said:
Because of MTL's playoff push, Hutson is in the best position to continue racking up points over the rest of the season, and thus bolster his case. Plus he'll get even more eyes on him as those games will be electric. Celebrini and the Sharks sit in contrast on both fronts, which really hurts his case and is a shame.

If Celebrini is going to win, he's going to have to out produce Hutson AND voters are going to have to watch the games to see everything that doesnt end up on the scoresheet. Hutson gets/will get that benefit
Click to expand...
Then again at least half Hutson's points aren't particularly impressive. They are like, decent plays on the PP that one of their shooters buries or sends cross-crease. The team is clicking.

Celebrini on the other hand has to do all the work and is key to almost all the goals he gets points on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
karltonian said:
Then again at least half Hutson's points aren't particularly impressive. They are like, decent plays on the PP that one of their shooters buries or sends cross-crease. The team is clicking.

Celebrini on the other hand has to do all the work and is key to almost all the goals he gets points on.
Click to expand...
That;s why im saying people will need to watch the games, because points, even if they aren't all impressively earned, will get the shine
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan, landshark and karltonian
knu said:
I really think the fact he's 18 and 2 years younger should mean a hell of a lot. That's just me.
Click to expand...
People in the main thread are trying to deny it but I guarantee if Celebrini wins it, EVERY story about it will mention his age and every interview with a voter will as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sandisfan
I do wonder if Will’s rise recently will actually hurt celebrini’s chances. Ironic since Celebrini is getting points off Will’s hot streak but I wonder if his recent run will take some of the shine away from Celebrini’s season.
 
TheBeard said:
I do wonder if Will’s rise recently will actually hurt celebrini’s chances. Ironic since Celebrini is getting points off Will’s hot streak but I wonder if his recent run will take some of the shine away from Celebrini’s season.
Click to expand...
I kinda doubt will is on anyone's radar and if they watch him they will not notice he is anything special compared to Celebrini.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
adding hide avatars option

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom