Prospect Info: Caps Top Prospects General Discussion Thread Vol. 2 - 2021-22

[Calicaps]

I'll be bummed if he doesn't stick at center, but if not at least he'll still be our Little Wing.

 

[Hivemind]

I'm gonna go ahead and guess it might be safe to move on to #5. I don't think there will be a comeback in this poll

 

[tenken00]

2021 Caps Top Prospects Rankings

#1 Connor McMichael Hershey Bears / AHL

C | 6' 0" | 183 lb | Age: 19
Draft: 2019 WSH, 1st rd, 25th pk (25th overall)
38 Votes - 88.4%
2020 Ranking - #1

#2 Martin Fehervary Hershey Bears / AHL

LD | 6' 2" | 202 lb | Age: 21
Draft: 2018 WSH, 2nd rd, 15th pk (46th overall)
21 Votes - 44.7%
2020 Ranking - #3

#3 Alexander Alexeyev Hershey Bears / AHL

LD | 6' 4" | 210 lb | Age: 21
Draft: 2018 WSH, 1st rd, 31st pk (31st overall)
15 Votes - 60.0%
2020 Ranking - #4

#4 Hendrix Lapierre Acadie-Bathurst Titan / QMJHL

C | 6' 0" | 178 lb | Age: 19
Draft: 2020 WSH, 1st rd, 22nd pk (22nd overall)
38 Votes - 95.0%
2020 Ranking- #2


Can you please turn the poll over to #5 when you can @Calicaps. Thanks!

 

[Hivemind]

Big tier break at #5, but at least our second tier of prospects are much more promising now than a couple years ago. A lot of this is due to the slow graduation rate, but it’s at least nice to feel like we might actually make it almost close to #10 without resorting to long-shots or guys who max out as fringe players.

Gonna go with Protas at 5, but Iorio or Brent Johnson could also work.

 

[tenken00]

Please vote for #5 guys!

 

[SoulessGingerCapsFan]

Nardella for me. Excelled in the AHL and Sweden

 

[trick9]

Protas.

Hoping for big steps from Leason & Nardella too.

 

[Hivemind]

I like Nardella, but he's already 25, and he's got a ton of competition for a LD spot with Fehervary and AA. If he can put on a really strong camp and leapfrog one of them, he might have a shot. But he doesn't really have a whole lot of time left and no clear path in Washington, so if he does translate to the NHL it seems likely it will be with another organization. Fingers crossed he can either carve out a role for himself in DC or do enough for himself that the Caps can get value for him via trade.

 

[Rayquaza64]

Protas here pretty easily. Nardella is cool and all but idk if he's gonna carve out a nhl role for himself (here at least, we have 5 NHL ready dmen although kempny hasnt played in like 2 years), if he plays well in Hershey we might be able to use him/get decent value out of him. As for Protas, he had a solid year in the KHL and played a lot of games, hopefully he can put together what he's learned so far and breakout in a full time top 9 C spot in Hershey and maybe even top 6

 

[kicksavedave]

Eventually Bear Hughes will win a round and I will do the Billy "White Shoes" Johnson victory celebration!

 

[tenken00]

2021 Caps Top Prospects Rankings

#1 Connor McMichael Hershey Bears / AHL

C | 6' 0" | 183 lb | Age: 19
Draft: 2019 WSH, 1st rd, 25th pk (25th overall)
38 Votes - 88.4%
2020 Ranking - #1

#2 Martin Fehervary Hershey Bears / AHL

LD | 6' 2" | 202 lb | Age: 21
Draft: 2018 WSH, 2nd rd, 15th pk (46th overall)
21 Votes - 44.7%
2020 Ranking - #3

#3 Alexander Alexeyev Hershey Bears / AHL

LD | 6' 4" | 210 lb | Age: 21
Draft: 2018 WSH, 1st rd, 31st pk (31st overall)
15 Votes - 60.0%
2020 Ranking - #4

#4 Hendrix Lapierre Acadie-Bathurst Titan / QMJHL

C | 6' 0" | 178 lb | Age: 19
Draft: 2020 WSH, 1st rd, 22nd pk (22nd overall)
38 Votes - 95.0%
2020 Ranking - #2

#5 Aliaksei Protas Hershey Bears / AHL

C | 6' 6" | 210 lb | Age: 20
Draft: 2019 WSH, 3rd rd, 29th pk (91st overall)
34 Votes - 82.9%
2020 Ranking - #5


@Calicaps next!

 

[Hivemind]

Another string of D up next. Iorio, Johnson, then Nardella for me.

 

[Calicaps]

[QUOdTE="tenken00, post: 179822072, member: 97480"]2021 Caps Top Prospects Rankings

#1 Connor McMichael Hershey Bears / AHL

C | 6' 0" | 183 lb | Age: 19
Draft: 2019 WSH, 1st rd, 25th pk (25th overall)
38 Votes - 88.4%
2020 Ranking - #1

#2 Martin Fehervary Hershey Bears / AHL

LD | 6' 2" | 202 lb | Age: 21
Draft: 2018 WSH, 2nd rd, 15th pk (46th overall)
21 Votes - 44.7%
2020 Ranking - #3

#3 Alexander Alexeyev Hershey Bears / AHL

LD | 6' 4" | 210 lb | Age: 21
Draft: 2018 WSH, 1st rd, 31st pk (31st overall)
15 Votes - 60.0%
2020 Ranking - #4

#4 Hendrix Lapierre Acadie-Bathurst Titan / QMJHL

C | 6' 0" | 178 lb | Age: 19
Draft: 2020 WSH, 1st rd, 22nd pk (22nd overall)
38 Votes - 95.0%
2020 Ranking - #2

#5 Aliaksei Protas Hershey Bears / AHL

C | 6' 6" | 210 lb | Age: 20
Draft: 2019 WSH, 3rd rd, 29th pk (91st overall)
34 Votes - 82.9%
2020 Ranking - #5


@Calicaps next!

done

 

[tenken00]

Hmmm. Who do I go with here? One of the newbies? Most likely to make it onto Caps roster? Trade value worth? Bear Hughes?

 

[Holtbyisms]

Bogdan probably has the most potentially game breaking talent left. Leason right around his tier as well. Then some guys like AJF and Malenstyn who project as safe 4th liners. None of the D left are very exciting prospects. Most are going to be lucky to stick as 3rd pairing guys including our first two picks this year.

 

[TheLegendOfPatPeake]

Bogdan probably has the most potentially game breaking talent left. Leason right around his tier as well. Then some guys like AJF and Malenstyn who project as safe 4th liners. None of the D left are very exciting prospects. Most are going to be lucky to stick as 3rd pairing guys including our first two picks this year.

Iorio looked great at the Canada Summer camps. I think he has a lot of potential IMO.

 

[Dr John Carlson]

Went Pilon for proximity-to-NHL reasons.

 

[ArmadilloThumb]

To me the strong play Protas and Leason had playing together in the WHL puts Leason next. Those two are a sum-of-the-parts-greater-than thing.

 

[Hivemind]

Bogdan probably has the most potentially game breaking talent left. Leason right around his tier as well. Then some guys like AJF and Malenstyn who project as safe 4th liners. None of the D left are very exciting prospects. Most are going to be lucky to stick as 3rd pairing guys including our first two picks this year.

I think you’re pretty universally overrating those forward prospects. Trineyev is intriguing, but very much a project player still that may never be able to translate his offensive play to the top levels of professional hockey. His offensive numbers (or lack thereof) in the VHL are excusable for being a teenager on a low scoring men’s team, but it’s not like he was lapping the field in the MHL against his peers.
I don’t see anything game breaking in Leason’s game. He recovered nicely from a rough first professional season, but his only real plus asset at the NHL level is his height. If he continues to improve, he could work his way into being a 3rd liner.
I don’t think AJF or Malentsyn are “safe” beyond being fringe players. Malentsyn gives you the hustle you want if you have a spare energy spot, but he’s unlikely to displace any other player to win that spot. Moreover, he just missed an entire year with an Achilles injury.

Maybe Iorio or Johnson don’t end up being more than 3rd pairing guys, but I don’t think that forward group is particularly safe bets for NHL careers, especially not beyond 4th line or depth duty.

 

[trick9]

Leason, then Johnson.

IMO there is a big drop-off after Protas.

 

[AlexModvechkin8]

Went Bogdan here. There’s something interesting about his game that gives me hope.

 

[twabby]

The TopDownHockey prospect model has Pilon for this next spot. He's the most likely player behind McMichael to become an NHL star in the Capitals' prospect pool, and the 5th most likely to become an NHL regular.

 

[tenken00]

I tend to think Bogdan is a younger version Leason and is very similar. But I also have not really seen Bogdan play at all except for highlight clips posted on here.

Is that a right or wrong assumption?

 

[Capagonia]

Y’all are crazy voting Bogdan here. Went Nardella but Leason and Pilon are in the neighborhood too.

 

[Holtbyisms]