I never said they'd fail miserably.
By "fail miserably" I meant maybe the front office will have failed miserably with the changes they made to try and improve the team. I didn't mean the team would fail miserably.
I'm just stating they got noticeably worse from last year, and the playoff problems are not going to be fixed. I get that salary is an issue but they could have gotten creative- a Gardiner buyout, un-assing Bear on time, etc.
From my understanding, Gardiner was injured and thus ineligible for a buyout. Even so, LTIR is actually a BETTER solution from a cap POV than buying him out. We'd have part of his cap hit on the books with a buyout, we can use the full amount with LTIR. Even if they "un-assed" Bear, with Necas getting a $3M raise, TDA getting a $4M raise, Trocheck getting a $1M raise (Plus 7 years), etc.... it wouldn't have worked and we would have essentially had the same team that failed.
And folks that think that a 33 year old injury prone Patches is just going to magically waltz in at the end of the year after a severed achilles tendon and light it up are high on wombat shit.
This changes made to this lineup were predicated on the theory that old, household name vets who had never won a cup were somehow going to inspire the rest of the team to be playoff winners. I think that is a flawed theory.
I don't think that was the theory at all. I think the theory is that we were missing a scoring winger and needed a guy that they thought could reliably play on the top pairing. They didn't feel TDA was that guy. Remember, they went after Marchment and Tkachuk so they weren't looking for "old guys" to "inspire the team".
Any changes to the roster should have been to get bigger, tougher, and meaner. Not older. Okay, so Tkachuck didn't work out, at least they went after him but maybe find others in that mold.
They went after Marchment and Tkachuk. Weren't a lot of other options that were either young enough, or affordable enough. Don't get me wrong, I'd like to see that to and have commented on it.
On the plus side, a lot of our guys aren't playing well and the team hasn't gelled and are still winning games. I think there's room for improvement as the season goes on and hopefully we'll see it.