Those kinds of show….for me needed some special draw because there are so many to choose from. What was the IT for Banshee? I couldn’t get hooked As a viewer.
It's hard to describe the X factor that a good show has. If you explained Breaking Bad to someone living in a bubble that knew nothing about it, the description couldn't possibly do it justice. It's a combination of a lot of things that make a show work.
The IT for Banshee? For me, I think one element was simply that it was a pay cable show. The overall maturity and level of adult themes was refreshing. I don't need crazy amounts of language/violence/sex in anything I watch, but if you're creating a world that centers around extremely violent people, characters acting the part helps.
It had a unique premise. A hardened criminal with a cowboy's moral compass assumes the identity of a town sheriff to stay close to the woman he protected by going to prison for 15 years. The town has a malevolent Amish kingpin he squares off with for 4 seasons, an uneasy relationship with its local Native population, a cadre of organized white supremacists, and the final season throws in a serial killer for good measure. And the sheriff and his closest confidantes are thieves, so the third season centers around a pretty thrilling heist.
And like I said, that description doesn't really even begin to capture what the show is actually like. Given the content warnings, it's certainly not everyone's cup of tea. But if it sounds at all appealing to you, maybe give it a shot.
Lastly, one thing I can say about Banshee, Justified, and Kingdom is that you can judge them from their pilots. If you like the first episode, you'll like the show. There's none of that "It really heats up in Season 3!" kind of thing. In each case, the pilot sets up the show nicely and while they all get progressively better, it's 100% fair to make up your mind in that first viewing.