Amid the drama engulfing the Vancouver Canucks and their two star players, J.T. Miller and Elias Pettersson, the one person who has had responsibility for managing this team crisis on a daily basis has been coach Rick Tocchet.
In my interview with team president Jim Rutherford this week, one that exploded like a bomb in Canucks nation, he talked about his coach and how he feels he’s managed an absolutely unmanageable situation.
“There is no playbook for this,” Rutherford told me. “So, you don’t know if any of us have done everything we can. I’m satisfied that he [Tocchet] has spent as much time as possible on the situation, meeting after meeting after meeting trying to resolve this.
“Beyond that I’m satisfied with the job that he does. He’s a very good coach who has been dealt a very tough hand this year.”
Lord knows, Tocchet has tried to get through to Pettersson, even working with him one-on-one before practices to help the player rediscover the form that so excited the organization during his first few years in uniform. So far that hasn’t worked. Maybe it’s the burden of the massive contract he signed.
Rutherford told me that he warned Pettersson around the time he signed his US$93-million, eight-year contract extension last March that it would only make things harder for him. He said he told Pettersson he would have to be more prepared, both mentally and physically, as a result.
“And he didn’t get to that level coming right out of his contract and into training camp but now he understands that,” Rutherford told me. “With the talent he has and his understanding now of what it takes [to excel] he’ll get that at some point.”
The team’s mediocre season can’t solely be laid at the feet of their feuding stars. Their franchise goaltender, Thatcher Demko, has not been very good since his return late last year from a knee injury suffered during the first round of the 2024 playoffs. Everyone can see that. The fact the Canucks are even sniffing a playoff spot is due largely to the play of “backup” Kevin Lankinen and captain Quinn Hughes.
Demko’s off-season hasn’t come as a surprise to Rutherford, a former NHL goalie himself. He says players who miss training camp often have an off-season or at least a slow start. And on top of that, they often get injured again. This certainly applies to Demko, who missed games because of back spasms after he returned to action.
“He’ll be okay,” Rutherford said. “He has a lot of talent and it’s still there.”
The same thing can also be said of forward Dakota Joshua, who had a stellar season last year, scoring 18 goals in 63 games and making a strong impression during the playoffs. Then it was revealed during the off-season he’d been diagnosed with testicular cancer, missing the start of this season as a result. When he returned to action late last year, he got injured. He’s been a big missing piece.
Perhaps the biggest issue, however, beyond Pettersson and Miller, has been the defence corps, which has been brutally inconsistent. Rutherford said at least part of their struggles has been the result of the five-man unit on the ice not being as cohesive and structured as it was much of last year.
He acknowledged the team misses Ian Cole and Nikita Zadorov, who said he loved his time in Vancouver and wished he could have stayed. However, he said in published interviews he felt disrespected during the negotiation process, an accusation that mystifies Rutherford.
“At the end, Zadorov was talking close with Tocchet while Patrik [Allvin] was talking to his agent. Tocchet would ask him ‘what’s it going to take to keep you here.’ And Zadorov said he had to get his contract to US$5-million [annually] and then he’d be set. So we got him to US$5-million. But then there was still no deal.
“So, Rick said to him ‘what’s going on?’ And then he said: ‘Well, if I can get to six years then I’ll stay.’ Same process. We said okay. So twice in that process he said give me that one more thing and I’ll stay and then we give it to him and then he goes to Boston.”
Regardless, Rutherford understands that if the Canucks are “going to get back to being a contending team, we’re going to need to make additions to the defence. Those prices are high by the way.”
Right now, it seems inconceivable that the Canucks can forge onward and just ignore all the “noise” that currently surrounds the team. On the other hand, the players are supposed to be professionals, highly paid ones, and they should be able to put these distractions behind them. Lord knows, Hughes has, despite carrying the burden of the captaincy.
In doing his interview with me, Rutherford was answering the call many had for the club to be more transparent about its internal problems. The reality is, it simply was not something that could be ignored forever. His honest assessment of where things are at, as hard as it was for many fans to hear, needed to be acknowledged.
Jim Rutherford didn’t ask for this farce to be handed to him. Some will say he’s responsible for letting the situation get to this point. Doesn’t matter now. It’s now his job to somehow make it all better.