I bought the black book. Haven't delved into it yet as I'm going away for a bit and won't have anything else to do after work other than reading it.
One thing that came up as I perused is that HP is very OHL/Ontario-cenntric.
Could it be that you guys have just seen Bo more than others so you like him more?
I love him too. Liked him last year too.
Obviously haven't followed him like you have, but really how big is the gap between Horvat and Lazar?
Both had monster 2nd halfs.
Not trying to call you out. Just wondering if perhaps getting too deep effects your ranking.
I have him in my personal 8-12 group so it's not like I don't have similar views. Just felt like it could be part of the Convo.
Cheers on a great year and I greatly look forward to immersing myself in the black book tomorrow.
We have got criticism in the past because of that. It's primarily due to myself and Mark both living in the OHL region. We have a lot of great scouts from all over the place but with our Owner/Director of Scouting and Head Scout both living in Ontario, I think it's expected that we are given that kind of tag.
It's also because we cover the OHL Drafts every single year that I've been with HP so we know the players really well by the time they come up for the OHL Draft. We covered the QMJHL draft this year, and have covered the WHL draft in the past.
We actually only have 45 OHL players in our top 210 ranking this year, which would probably surprise a lot of people because of that stigma attached to us. I think you'll notice the depth of our European content is much stronger this year. We've seen a lot more international action both as an organization and personally speaking.
As far as Horvat and Lazar, I've actually seen Lazar play live an in person over a half dozen times. I've also watched video of him. I've never felt you can scout from video, but it doesn't hurt when I can talk to one of our guys in the WHL and can discuss things about his game. For example he's very smart without the puck, that's extremely difficult to see on video and can really only be picked up in live viewings. We have three guys out west. One in the Northwest USA, One in British Columbia, and one in Alberta. So it's important for us to trust what they see and put it all together.
I think consistency is a big thing that concerned our scouts. Both had big second halfs and both have similar attributes. They really aren't very far apart at all. We haven't seen the same leadership and consistency which is basically the biggest difference. Some NHL guys I've talked to like Lazar more than Horvat. Some believe they are basically back to back and some agree with where we have them. Ultimately based on conversations we've had with our scouts, he's fallen a little behind Horvat, but he's still a pretty safe bet to be a NHler. Lazar, like Horvat plays an NHL style of game which is key to their success. I think Horvat is more likely to land a regular shift on the second line than Lazar, but both have 2nd line upside, but are pretty safe bets to at least be 3rd liners.
Thanks for your support, it's greatly appreciated.