Bratt & J. Hughes or B.Tkachuk & Stutzle?

[SeanMoneyHands]

Who would you take?

Click to read more...

 

[Xirik]

Hughes > Stutzle

Bratt = Tkachuk

 

[Imgoingtowork]

A struggle next time but I vote Bratt and Hughes.

 

[Akrapovince]

Hughes is going to cement himself further within the Matthews, Draisatl, etc tier of players next year.

Stu needs to become a more consistent play driver and not be a ghost for the first half of the season.

This would be a closer discussion if Hughes was being paid what he’s worth, but as is I think it’s clear which pairing you go with here.

And that is no insult to either Brady or Stü.

 

[PatrickMcC]

Obviously a big fan of Brady and Timmy but Hughes tips the scales here. He’s on another level. That’s no slight on the Sens duo as they’re still excellent players.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Hughes > Stutzle

Bratt = Tkachuk

Bratt does not equal Tkachuk, he would lose in a poll.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

Bratt does not equal Tkachuk, he would lose in a poll.

That only says hes more popular on HF, not a better player in the league.

 

[Golden_Jet]

That only says hes more popular on HF, not a better player in the league.

Wrong, he’d win because he’s better, and more desirable for teams.

 

[Akrapovince]

I’ll concede to:

Hughes >> Stützle

If we agree that:

Tkachuk > Bratt

 

[Namikaze Minato]

Wrong, he’d win because he’s better, and more desirable for teams.

Thats what's called your opinion and you can pretend that's correct all you want but winning an HF boards poll doesn't mean they are the better player.

Now if you said you believe he is better because of how he performs relative to Bratt on-ice, sure I agree with that but pretending he's better because he would win a poll

 

[Regal]

Hughes is going to cement himself further within the Matthews, Draisatl, etc tier of players next year.

Stu needs to become a more consistent play driver and not be a ghost for the first half of the season.

This would be a closer discussion if Hughes was being paid what he’s worth, but as is I think it’s clear which pairing you go with here.

And that is no insult to either Brady or Stü.

Pretty much. I’d prefer Brady to Bratt but that’s more uniqueness than ability, and I think Hughes is the biggest factor to consider here

 

[Xirik]

I’ll concede to:

Hughes >> Stützle

If we agree that:

Tkachuk > Bratt

Maybe if its

Tkachuk > Bratt

(The sign is smaller font)

 

[Nico Hischier]

Hughes > Tkachuk

Bratt = Stutzle

 

[Bileur]

Hughes is the best player here but I wouldn’t trade the sens duo for the devils duo so I’d take the sens duo.

 

[Leafs87]

Hughes
Tkachuk
Stuzle
Bratt

I take the better duo than the better player so I’d go with the Sens

 

[Golden_Jet]

Thats what's called your opinion and you can pretend that's correct all you want but winning an HF boards poll doesn't mean they are the better player.

Now if you said you believe he is better because of how he performs relative to Bratt on-ice, sure I agree with that but pretending he's better because he would win a poll

That wasn’t the only reason stated in here, and you know that,

Ya just like yours is an opinion lol, Brady is just better than Bratt. Yes being better is because of on-ice,
I said he was a better player AND would win a poll, AND would be more desirable by teams.

Here is the reply to you.

Wrong, he’d win because he’s better, and more desirable for teams.

Hughes
Tkachuk
Stuzle
Bratt

I take the better duo than the better player so I’d go with the Sens

I’d agree with this ranking of the 4, as would most I think.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

That wasn’t the only reason stated in here, and you know that,

Ya just like yours is an opinion lol, Brady is just better than Bratt. Yes being better is because of on-ice,
I said he was a better player AND would win a poll, AND would be more desirable by teams.

Here is the reply to you.



I’d agree with this ranking of the 4, as would most I think.

Can you show your source for Tkachuk being more desirable than Bratt? Or is that just your opinion that you are pretending is a fact again?

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

Hughes > Tkachuk > Stützle > Bratt

Hughes
Tkachuk
Stuzle
Bratt

I take the better duo than the better player so I’d go with the Sens

I agree with the order but the difference between Hughes and Tkachuk is greater than the difference between Srutzke and Bratt if there even is one it’s very small

 

[Video Nasty]

Hughes is going to cement himself further within the Matthews, Draisatl, etc tier of players next year.

Hughes hasn’t even poured the cement yet.

 

[Xirik]

So are we restarting that Devils vs Senators poll thing from two years ago where the Devils won basically every poll?

 

[NyQuil]

So are we restarting that Devils vs Senators poll thing from two years ago where the Devils won basically every poll?

You should put up a banner.

 

[Akrapovince]

So are we restarting that Devils vs Senators poll thing from two years ago where the Devils won basically every poll?

Ok you do the Sanderson vs Nemec/Hughes one and I’ll do the Greig vs Mercer poll and everyone will join in and fill the whole page with Sens vs Devils polls.

 

[Xirik]

You should put up a banner.

You know what that is? I'm shocked

 

[Bileur]

You know what that is? I'm shocked

Yeah we’ve have a Melnyk one hanging in the rafters for a long time now.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Hughes the Norris Winner >> Timmy the Bitch
Brat = Tkachuck but not the better of the two


I have no bias whatsoever btw