Brady Tkachuk vs Mitch Marner

[BoHorvat 53]

Good call, Tkachuk and all of his 0 playoff games.

Meh, I'd be really surprised if his game didn't mesh well with playoff hockey.

I'd definitely take a chance on him over this generation's Marleau.

 

[Voight]

Better to go with someone unproven than someone who is proven to be bad.

Hes had his ups (2023) and downs (2024) but 50 points in 57 playoff games is hardly bad.

Yea he could be better, but people here act like hes Rick Nash come playoff time.

 

[Positive Vibes]

Until you learn to make fun of your team and be able to praise your rivals like I do, you'll be called insecure by others... especially if your team isn't world beaters like none of our teams are.

Also, does anyone know how to check your own post history? I'll show you me shutting down other sens fans who were making fun of the Habs by praising them and then shitting on the sens.

I wonder if you've ever done something like that? It would be a start.

idk what your talking about at all tbh,didnt put anybody down? people in your fanbase are talking about the habs?

shows their insecurities though i agree with that

 

[jbeck5]

idk what your talking about at all tbh,didnt put anybody down? people in your fanbase are talking about the habs?

shows their insecurities though i agree with that

Lol yes, and hab fans talk about the sens. If they say negative things about the sens, would you argue with them and say good things about the sens and bad things about the Habs?

No. Because of your insecurities.

 

[Positive Vibes]

Lol yes, and hab fans talk about the sens. If they say negative things about the sens, would you argue with them and say good things about the sens and bad things about the Habs?

No. Because of your insecurities.

Im talking about this specific situation where its a Sens leafs based topic lol


also, talking badly about a team 'rival' isn't being 'insecure' its a rivalry lol which just further proves what ive been saying the entire time.

not sure you have seen the entire conversation and what Ur fellow fans have commented.

you can 'yeah but' all you want.

 

[SpezDispenser]

That’s the “I assume” part, dude seemingly plays a style that transfers to playoffs better. He’s his team’s best player, can’t fault him for a bad lineup, whereas Marner has been the worst part of a talented squad come playoffs.

*third best player on the team.

 

[Xspyrit]

That’s the “I assume” part, dude seemingly plays a style that transfers to playoffs better. He’s his team’s best player, can’t fault him for a bad lineup, whereas Marner has been the worst part of a talented squad come playoffs.

Tkachuk isn't close to being the best player on the Sens, at least not anymore now that Stutzle and Sanderson got a bit older (both 22 y/o)

Chabot is also arguable, when he is healthy and plays with at least a decent partner, he controls games and drives the play like few can. Batherson is also more skilled but people will take Tkachuk over him as he can be quite impactful. There's some games where he can literally carry a team on his shoulders

Giroux would also be considered better if he was a few years younger.

I'm not a big Tkachuk fan but I'd rather have him on my team than not

 

[Chips]

I can only guess, maybe he wouldn’t do shit in the playoffs,


Just regular season Marner, but come playoff time I could see Brady stepping up physically and scoring at least as much

 

[Seras]

the people voting brady are the same people who buy lottery tickets cause you never know you just might have a mitch marner in your pocket

 

[jbeck5]

Im talking about this specific situation where its a Sens leafs based topic lol


also, talking badly about a team 'rival' isn't being 'insecure' its a rivalry lol which just further proves what ive been saying the entire time.

not sure you have seen the entire conversation and what Ur fellow fans have commented.

you can 'yeah but' all you want.

I haven't "yeah but". I've been very clear and consistent.

You show insecurities by not being able to compliment your rivals and not being able to laugh at your own team.

That's it. That shows insecurities.

You're welcome to name 5 good things about the sens and 5 bad things about the Habs to show you're not insecure.

Or you can make some BS excuse and not address my post again....choice is yours.

 

[SpezDispenser]

the people voting brady are the same people who buy lottery tickets cause you never know you just might have a mitch marner in your pocket

Holy shit, I won a Brady Tkachuk!

 

[Bileur]

i dont think your reading what im saying or just can't understand it for some reason
again go read the other guys posts to understand why you saying im acting 'insecure' is very ironic

bringing up a guy that isn't being discussed in the thread is insecure because a fan of another team commented on a post is the definition of insecurity. again the irony your post yet again is very ironic.

also theres no timeline on commenting on another posters comment unless theres a rule about it?

I did read his post. I just have the ability to recognize a joke, which appears to be an area for improvement for you.

I agree, if his post demonstrated a sincerely held belief rather than an obviously tongue in cheek quip, it might suggest insecurity. That’s not what happened though.

Of course there’s no rule on timelines. Reviving a buried thread to make that comment nonetheless shows you were triggered.

 

[Positive Vibes]

I haven't "yeah but". I've been very clear and consistent.

You show insecurities by not being able to compliment your rivals and not being able to laugh at your own team.

That's it. That shows insecurities.

You're welcome to name 5 good things about the sens and 5 bad things about the Habs to show you're not insecure.

Or you can make some BS excuse and not address my post again....choice is yours

i haven't said anything negative about the sens? lol
again you seem to be making up stuff at this point for some reason

you seem to be very insecure about this topic

I did read his post. I just have the ability to recognize a joke, which appears to be an area for improvement for you.

again, i said how the Sens fanbase was obsessed and didn't stop talking about Hutson in a thread Not about him which proves my point perfectly.

it was just a fact, thats it.

 

[NyQuil]

again, i said how the Sens fanbase was obsessed and didn't stop talking about Hutson in a thread Not about him which proves my point perfectly.

Now you're the one going on and on about Hutson in a Tkachuk thread.

Obsessed is putting it mildly.

Just let it go.

 

[jbeck5]

i haven't said anything negative about the sens? lol
again you seem to be making up stuff at this point for some reason

you seem to be very insecure about this topic

again, i said how the Sens fanbase was obsessed and didn't stop talking about Hutson in a thread Not about him which proves my point perfectly.

it was just a fact, thats it.

Lol nvm. You're clearly not getting it.

I'm the last person anyone would call insecure. I make fun of myself. I make fun of my team. And I have a good time doing it.

 

[Sens9292]

the people voting brady are the same people who buy lottery tickets cause you never know you just might have a mitch marner in your pocket

I don’t want a Mitch Marner

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

I do not understand how Marner is losing this poll.

Said it before I do not see a legitimate argument for Brady.

He's not better offensively.

He's not better defensively seeing as Marner has been up for the Selke.

And while Marner playoff numbers aren't great Brady doesn't have any because he's never been there.

So if It's not offense, defense or playoff performance what is the LEGITIMATE argument for Brady?

 

[HeadLiceHatty]

Weird thread, I wish this didn’t even exist lol

 

[Xspyrit]

I do not understand how Marner is losing this poll.

Said it before I do not see a legitimate argument for Brady.

He's not better offensively.

He's not better defensively seeing as Marner has been up for the Selke.

And while Marner playoff numbers aren't great Brady doesn't have any because he's never been there.

So if It's not offense, defense or playoff performance what is the LEGITIMATE argument for Brady?

It's not that complicated, since 2022-23 (when the power forward turned 23 y/o and entered his prime), the production has been getting much closer (Brady has more goals, Marner has more PP assists) so people might prefer having the physical specimen over the skilled playmaker.

And before you say something stupid, I voted Marner in this thread because it didn't seem to include contracts or going forward

 

[Positive Vibes]

Lol nvm. You're clearly not getting it.

I'm the last person anyone would call insecure. I make fun of myself. I make fun of my team. And I have a good time doing it.

OK?

i know my team isnt good right now their in a rebuild?
whats that have to do with any of this conversation?

your talking about something different entirely lol.

Now you're the one going on and on about Hutson in a Tkachuk thread.

Obsessed is putting it mildly.

Just let it go.

i wonder who brought him up....