Toggle sidebar

Brady Tkachuk vs Mitch Marner

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

Who would you take on your team?

  • Brady Tkachuk

    Votes: 342 45.1%

  • Mitch Marner

    Votes: 416 54.9%
  • Total voters
    758
Status
Not open for further replies.
Golden_Jet said:
Just countering your terrible defensively take, that’s foolish.
Click to expand...
Stutzle being poor defensively is something non leaf fans discuss as well if your thinking I am biased and hating on him

Marner is a top 5 winger in the league since 2018-2019 (Kuch, Rantanen, Pasta, Panarin)

Stutzle will need to improve to reach that level)
 
hamzarocks said:
Your talking about stutzle right?

His D+3 for sure is better but way better is a bit misleading

Marner had 69 pts in 2018 in a league with 108 pt as the highest scorer

Stutzle had 90 i think with the league leader (same generational guy lol) at 153 pts
Click to expand...

Marner was 38th in league scoring that season while Timmy was 17th this season. That's a big difference.

Assen na yo!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sens With Benefits and Bileur
hamzarocks said:
Stutzle being poor defensively is something non leaf fans discuss as well if your thinking I am biased and hating on him

Marner is a top 5 winger in the league since 2018-2019 (Kuch, Rantanen, Pasta, Panarin)

Stutzle will need to improve to reach that level)
Click to expand...
Stutzle is a center.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OKR
bert said:
There is nothing misleading about it Stutzle, had 39 goals and 90 points in 78 games while Marner had 69 in 82. Even with the GPG conversion he blew Marner away.

Secondly you have have absolutely no clue what you are talking about in regards to the defensive play of Stutzle. Stutzle's compete level is way harder and plays the more important position. At the same age he is a much better player than Marner. He is more explosive and has more upside. Yes he has to continue to progress but if you are actually watching him you know he isnt done.

I saw your posts before the series against the Lightning your expectations were for an easy series win for Toronto. They can clearly win the series especially with Tampas Injuries on defense. But you clearly cant be objective when the leafs are involved.


Marner had a bunch of secondary assists and some brutal turnovers that put them behind early. But this is still probably one of his best post season games he has ever had. I still think the leafs find a way to win this series tampa is so banged up. However it was a pathetic game 1 performance by the leafs big dogs.
Click to expand...
It's amazing how the rules change depending which team's player is involved in these polls. For years in polls with Matthews involved comparing players at the same age is not a good argument. Go back and check the poll against MacKinnon.
 
Joe n said:
It's amazing how the rules change depending which team's player is involved in these polls. For years in polls with Matthews involved comparing players at the same age is not a good argument. Go back and check the poll against MacKinnon.
Click to expand...

Are you saying that different posters can have different ways of looking at things? Maybe even that a random Avalanche fan you argued with years ago may not use the same arguments as bert?
 
Joe n said:
It's amazing how the rules change depending which team's player is involved in these polls. For years in polls with Matthews involved comparing players at the same age is not a good argument. Go back and check the poll against MacKinnon.
Click to expand...
I mean it's not like that wasn't a relevant point even then. And I think the season Matthews put up last year shows why people thought he had potential to meet / exceed MacKinnon.

People who were downplaying age in those Matthews threads probably had a horse in the race.

Stutzle is pretty clearly ahead of where Marner was at the same age. Heck, you could argue he's already the better player considering his position and goal scoring ability. I mean, Stutzle only had 1 less primary point in 2 less games this year playing on an inferior team.
 
hamzarocks said:
Your talking about stutzle right?

His D+3 for sure is better but way better is a bit misleading

Marner had 69 pts in 2018 in a league with 108 pt as the highest scorer

Stutzle had 90 i think with the league leader (same generational guy lol) at 153 pts

Marner his D+4 was 94 pts and 11th in pts and a top 15 producer. Will see if Stutzle is at that level and beyond moving forward

Stutzle is also a terribke defensive player. He will need to clean up on that when it comes the Sens time to be the choking team of Ontario
Click to expand...

That's quite the bad take. You're lucky there's no dislike function
 
lol 33 pages...once again all Sens fans had to look forward too this year is the Leafs losing in the playoffs. Congrats boys.
 
Coaches Coroner said:
lol 33 pages...once again all Sens fans had to look forward too this year is the Leafs losing in the playoffs. Congrats boys.
Click to expand...
I just find it hilarious how leafs fans are all proclaiming golden boy Marner as the best thing since sliced bread ITT and arrogantly suggesting there is no valid debate and that no one would pick Brady over Marner for their team, he's on another level, AINEC and all that BS, and yet Marner just keeps folding like a lawn chair when it matters in the playoffs.

3 pts, -2 in 5 GP in the 2nd round. Goose egg last night in an elimination game at home. Gets bitch slapped by Matthew.

A lot of GMs would pick Brady over Marner to lead their team.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bileur, Sens9292, Koivu11 and 1 other person
The Professional said:
I just find it hilarious how leafs fans are all proclaiming golden boy Marner as the best thing since sliced bread ITT and arrogantly suggesting there is no valid debate and that no one would pick Brady over Marner for their team, he's on another level, AINEC and all that BS, and yet Marner just keeps folding like a lawn chair when it matters in the playoffs.

3 pts, -2 in 5 GP in the 2nd round. Goose egg last night in an elimination game at home. Gets bitch slapped by Matthew.

A lot of GMs would pick Brady over Marner to lead their team.
Click to expand...
A lot of projection; it's been Sen's fans claiming how great of a playoff guy Brady is and getting offended and whining about "arrogance" when it's pointed out Brady hasn't played in the playoffs. Congrats on your owner dying though, that's the biggest W you guys have had to celebrate in the last decade outside of Leafs choke jobs.
 
Coaches Coroner said:
Congrats on your owner dying though, that's the biggest W you guys have had to celebrate in the last decade outside of Leafs choke jobs.
Click to expand...

There was making it to Game 7 double OT against the Penguins in the Eastern Conference Finals in 2017.

That’s as far as Doug Gilmour or Mats Sundin made it with Toronto and they are still heroes for some reason.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TkachukNorris79, asd1, Bileur and 3 others
Coaches Coroner said:
A lot of projection; it's been Sen's fans claiming how great of a playoff guy Brady is and getting offended and whining about "arrogance" when it's pointed out Brady hasn't played in the playoffs. Congrats on your owner dying though, that's the biggest W you guys have had to celebrate in the last decade outside of Leafs choke jobs.
Click to expand...
Lol forgot about losing in double OT in game 7 to go to cup finals, in your decade declaration.
 
NyQuil said:
There was making it to Game 7 double OT against the Penguins in the Eastern Conference Finals in 2017.

That’s as far as Doug Gilmour or Mats Sundin made it with Toronto and they are still heroes for some reason.
Click to expand...
I guess the same reason Sens fans bring up that and the finals loss well before that still when people talk about their lack of playoff appearances and rave about Alfie (in the same span Sens fans constantly chirp about Leaf's round 1 exits).
 
Last edited:
Golden_Jet said:
Lol forgot about losing in double OT in game 7 to go to cup finals, in your decade declaration.
Click to expand...
You guys are as hung up celebrating your semi finals loss as Leaf fans of two different age brackets are about the early 90s and late 90s/early 00's Leafs lol. I don't even argue the Leafs aren't pathetic! I'm simply saying the team you are a fan of and it's fans aren't exactly better in most regards, just fewer of you.
 
Coaches Coroner said:
I guess the same reason Sens fans bring up that and the finals loss well before that still when people talk about their lack of playoff appearances and rave about Alfie (in the same span Sens fans constantly chirp about Leaf's round 1 exits).
Click to expand...

Hopefully you’ll get a chance to see your team in the Finals.

It’s a fun time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SpezDispenser, Sens9292, Sun God Nika and 1 other person
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom