Brady Tkachuk or Matthew Knies

[RedHawkDown]

Fascinating that Knies is simultaneously better than Brady and also not worth more than 6 because he’s a product of Matthews and Marner.

 

[Strangle]

Fascinating that Knies is simultaneously better than Brady and also not worth more than 6 because he’s a product of Matthews and Marner.

He’s worth a lot more than 6. And the kid isn’t a product of anyone. He’s a monster

 

[deca guard]

if you want to get realistic put chucky on leafs with mathews and marner and see how many points he gets , mean while hes carrying the sens

 

[RedHawkDown]

He’s worth a lot more than 6. And the kid isn’t a product of anyone. He’s a monster

Yes, hence why the contract argument is moot. He'll be paid 8 + on anything longer than 6 years. 7 minimum on a bridge.

 

[Strangle]

Yes, hence why the contract argument is moot. He'll be paid 8 + on anything longer than 6 years. 7 minimum on a bridge.

I don’t think you got my joke, or where that came from.

I was sarcastic to sens fans. They understand

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

View attachment 1029429

100% and even if he did make the same money it would still be a better deal because he would take a lower % of the cap then Brady did when he signed his deal.

 

[JungleBeat]

Knies is more skilled and faster but Brady is just too physical and consistent to ignore. Right now it’s Brady.

 

[Fatass]

Knies is really good. But I like that Brady has a long term contract. Not too sure where Knies is going to play next season, with the likelihood of an offer sheet coming?

 

[Bond]

Ah Knies went from underrated to overrated pretty quickly

 

[Stive Morgan]

Habs fan voting Brady

 

[Jack Spider]

Habs fan voting Brady

I'm also voting Brady. Some people say Wilson is a guy you love to have on your team but hate to play against. But that's bs because one has a history of suspension and diving. Knies is good too.

 

[JKG33]

I'd lean Tkachuk, but id take both of these guys over the "core 4" overpaid clowns

 

[Sens9292]

I never know if you guys are being intentionally obtuse or are just clueless.

I think we all know but most likely a mix of both

 

[Captain97]

Knies 100%

Why didn’t we add “contracts included” to this one?

Cause Knies doesn't have a contract after this year?

 

[IPS]

When Knies catches up in experience him AINEC. He's already razor close with Tkachuk and could pass him as soon as next year.

 

[ACC1224]

Knies pretty easily if we're being honest.

 

[1specter]

Love this thread. Just an FYI for the 'neutral' folks, OP even though he hates our team is regularly participating on our boards and will often come in to 'correct' people or argue with them. We have chill mods...

 

[A1LeafNation]

Voted knies bc of butt hurt op

 

[Golden_Jet]

Voted knies bc of butt hurt op

lol, it was 2 leafs posters that challenged me to make a thread, as they said it wasn’t close . Read the OP, they wouldn’t trade Knies for any player on the Senators.

 

[IPS]

lol, it was 2 leafs posters that challenged me to make a thread, as they said it wasn’t close . Read the OP, they wouldn’t trade Knies for any player on the Senators.

Dude stop putting your hatred on display so openly. It works a lot better if it's more subtle.

 

[MCR74]

Dude stop putting your hatred on display so openly. It works a lot better if it's more subtle.

Let him be. He's playing to his strengths.

 

[SeanVT395]

A completely rational leafs vs sens poll that doesn't involve any ulterior motives or hurt feelings... neutral fan here voting Brady. Knies is a beast but come on

 

[Golden_Jet]

Dude stop putting your hatred on display so openly. It works a lot better if it's more subtle.

Reading OP must be hard, blame your fellow leaf fans, if you don’t like it.

 

[IPS]

Reading OP must be hard, blame your fellow leaf fans, if you don’t like it.

So you're just gonna start some polls up just cause you got riled up from some Leafs fans? It's not a big deal, just move on and read something else.

 

[Voodoo Child]

I'd take Tkachuk at 8.5 vs Knies at 8.5 but what if Knies signs a 3 year bridge for like 6?

His ceiling is about what Brady is now, and I don't see Brady levelling up into Matthew. Still a great player though.

Obviously some Sens have more value but from a needs standpoint the only one I'd trade Knies for is Sanderson.

OP has obvious agenda, 'some Leafs fans said...' is 'my dad could beat up your dad' tier, Knies for the lulz.