Proposal: Ben Chiarot to NYR

[JustAHabFan]

I’d do Kravtsov and Chytil for Dvorak

I would like to see how Dvorak performed under MSL before trading him. Petry/Suzuki/Caufield/... played much better when the Habs made the coaching change.

 

[UnSandvich]

Bearing in mind that this is Dom Luszczyszyn... (also Paywall)

"Chiarot, by any way that can be measured right now, is a net negative value player. He’s a detriment that is more likely to hurt whatever team he joins by virtue of a limited skill set that will have his team chasing the puck more often than not, and killing any semblance of offence. There’s a chance that he performs better in the right situation — he has some puck-moving ability — but it’s such a small chance that the reward is nowhere near worth the risk and the acquisition cost."

"At best, Chiarot is a third pairing defender masquerading as something more with someone else doing a majority of the work. At best. At worst, he’s an anchor that will sink a contending team’s chances."

The numbers behind the names: Analyzing the Trade Deadline Big Board

 

[Runner77]

It cost the Habs s 1st + 2nd to get Dvorak from Arizona. The Habs may settle for only a 1st to trade Dvorak and this is 'lower'.

If that’s what was meant, it would be a decent recoupment.