As of TODAY, where is McDavid on the all time list in your opinion?

VistamarCroissants

Registered User
Apr 19, 2024
65
41
Connor McDavid is already in the conversation among the top 25 players of all time—but his story is far from finished.
With years of prime hockey still ahead of him, the potential for more Hart Trophies, Stanley Cups, and Olympic golds looms large.
The true measure of McDavid’s place in history won’t be clear until the final chapter of his career is written, but in five to ten years, we’ll have a much better sense of just how high he can rise in the all-time ranks.
 

jetsforever

Registered User
Dec 14, 2013
28,050
24,548
Connor McDavid is already in the conversation among the top 25 players of all time—but his story is far from finished.
With years of prime hockey still ahead of him, the potential for more Hart Trophies, Stanley Cups, and Olympic golds looms large.
The true measure of McDavid’s place in history won’t be clear until the final chapter of his career is written, but in five to ten years, we’ll have a much better sense of just how high he can rise in the all-time ranks.

Why does this sound like ChatGPT
 

PeE eL DuBoiS

Send ze caviar to mah chambers, peasant
Mar 31, 2022
745
1,490
I did a lot of great research for this profound topic of discussion and have decided that, as of TODAY, he's ranked 99th of all time, give or take exactly 0 spots.

Of course, this is just my opinion and isn't grounded in solid hockey analysis like all of these "he's number 6!" projections from the great hfboards savants.

1000017133.jpg
 

VistamarCroissants

Registered User
Apr 19, 2024
65
41
I did a lot of great research for this profound topic of discussion and have decided that, as of TODAY, he's ranked 99th of all time, give or take exactly 0 spots.

Of course, this is just my opinion and isn't grounded in solid hockey analysis like all of these "he's number 6!" projections from the great hfboards savants.

View attachment 932294
Dale Hunter above LaFontaine. Interesting
 

Midnight Judges

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Feb 10, 2010
14,397
11,338
I differ from most in that I value total career value (total contribution to one's teams) while accounting for the added value of concentrated peak, whereas many people just want to be dazzled, see a cup, and then it doesn't matter what happens after that.

With that said, I don't have McDavid all that high right now but I think he's rapidly climbing and on track to easily surpass Lemieux and Orr, and probably Howe as well - given enough games. I think Gretzky is pretty much out of reach.

I also don't cup count - because that leads to arbitrary and inequitable results. The old timers love it because it objectively biases ~ 500% towards their preferred original 6 heroes. McDavid could never win a cup and it's not going to change my opinion by much, if anything (so long as he performs well).
 
  • Like
Reactions: crowfish

benfranklin

Registered User
Jun 29, 2024
456
356
No, he needs 1 cup, even that can be questioned, these GOATs of all time mainly won their cups when there were 6-22 teams in the league, it is alot harder to win a cup now, if McDavid wins 1 cup and gets 2,000 points he is definitely #2 behind Gretzky, 2000 points and no Cups i'd probably rank him 3, if he retired today I would still say 4-5 or something
So Lemieux, Gretzky, Orr, and then McDavid if he retired today?! Really?!

Crosby, Malkin, Ovechkin, Jagr, Messier, Howe, Hull, Hull, Sakic, Yzerman, Francis, Esposito, Selanne, Kurri, Robitaille, Modano, Beliveau, Shanahan, Mikita, Lafleur, Savard, Kane, Kucherov, Kopitar, Clarke, Fedorov, Forsberg, Stamkos, Hossa, Bossy.

Thats just off the top of my head Cup winners not including D or G. If he retired today, his career is better than those guys?

Why does this sound like ChatGPT
The Hart Memorial Trophy is awarded annually to the NHL's most valuable player (MVP) during the regular season, and it has been won by defensemen only a few times in its history. Here are the defensemen who have won the Hart Trophy:

  1. Eddie Shore (Boston Bruins) - 1924, 1925
    • Shore was a pioneering defenseman known for his physical style of play and was one of the early stars of the NHL.
  2. Red Kelly (Detroit Red Wings) - 1954
    • Kelly was a versatile player who excelled on both defense and offense, becoming a significant figure in the league during his time.
  3. Bobby Orr (Boston Bruins) - 1969, 1970, 1971
    • Widely regarded as one of the greatest defensemen in NHL history, Orr revolutionized the position with his offensive skills and skating ability. He is the only defenseman to win the Hart Trophy three times.
  4. Larry Robinson (Montreal Canadiens) - 1976
    • Robinson was a key player on some of the Canadiens' championship teams, known for his defensive prowess and leadership.
  5. Chris Pronger (St. Louis Blues) - 2000
    • Pronger was recognized for his dominant two-way play and was instrumental in leading the Blues to success during his time with the team.
  6. Nicklas Lidström (Detroit Red Wings) - 2007
    • Lidström is considered one of the best defensemen ever, known for his intelligence, skill, and consistency. He was a vital part of the Red Wings' success in the late 1990s and early 2000s.
  7. Kris Letang (Pittsburgh Penguins) - 2023
    • Letang, a key player for the Penguins, won the Hart Trophy following an outstanding season, showcasing his importance to the team's success.
These players are notable for not only their defensive skills but also their ability to contribute offensively, which is essential for winning the Hart Trophy as the league's MVP.
 

cowboy82nd

Registered User
Feb 19, 2012
5,295
2,583
Newnan, Georgia
I did a lot of great research for this profound topic of discussion and have decided that, as of TODAY, he's ranked 99th of all time, give or take exactly 0 spots.

Of course, this is just my opinion and isn't grounded in solid hockey analysis like all of these "he's number 6!" projections from the great hfboards savants.

View attachment 932294
So, no goalies above him?
 

Luigi Lemieux

Registered User
Sep 26, 2003
22,158
10,708
No one cares that the greats won their cups when there was 20 teams. It's hardly worth considering even though it's valid. People base legacy and greatness based on how many championships and trophies regardless of how circumstantial that can be at times - plain and simple.

I think he needs a couple cups to be with Lemieux. If he gets one he's right beside Crosby.

The Art Ross trophy is a better way of deciphering a players offensive dominance rather than just looking at point totals. The ebbs and flows of scoring in the NHL varies a lot. 1 more Art Ross and McDavid ties Lemieux and Howe. Lemieux had to play in the same era as Gretzky which suppresses his total in my opinion. But either way, McDavid still has a long ways to go to be with Lemieux and it mostly come down to Stabley Cups - 1 isn't enough.
True Lemieux would have 8 art rosses if you remove Gretzky, even with all the injured seasons. Would add 85-86 and 86-87 to his totals. McDavid isn't going to pass Lemieux or Orr, even if he hits 2000 points. His peak is simply not as high.
 

GMR

Registered User
Jul 27, 2013
6,778
5,818
Parts Unknown
He's a top-10 player and it's really not questionable. He's done things with a consistency that very, very few players have ever matched.

Or to put another way, he is at LEAST wherever Jagr is.
Banging hot 25 year olds in the Czech Republic?

He wishes.
 
Last edited:

notdoneyet

Registered User
Jun 19, 2006
4,413
2,062
Leafland
He is already at the top

I’m 71 years old and have been watching hockey all my life

Look at the goalie equipment now as opposed to years ago. The pads are 6 feet high, the trapper takes up the whole net, the jerseys are size 90 and the goalies themselves are monsters.

In other eras the greats were great but the third and fourth liners were not very skillful. They smoked in the dressing room, drank beer after the game and in the summer they gained 30 pounds and had to have a 2 month training camp. The third and fourth liners today are in shape year round. The average player today is so much better than the average player of yesteryear. They are better because they are in shape year round, skates are lightweight and are far superior to the old skates and even sticks are lighter and have flex.

There is no one in the NHL today that can skate that fast and handle the puck the way mcdavid does.

In every generation great players are great players the difference is the today’s players have so many advantages over previous generations.

Teams today are harder to play against and goalies and equipment are better.

If he keeps up getting 150 points a year he will be the GOAT
 

Video Nasty

Registered User
Mar 12, 2017
5,695
9,933
It 100% is, ChatGPT loves to hyphen and double hyphen words. Even if it is the proper way to write in english, nobody does it because it takes way-to-much—time. Easiest giveaway that something is written by GPT

Plenty of people use hyphens and em dashes. As a writer, they take no time at all to use because reading and writing is a way of life. Nothing wrong with elegant prose, even on these forums.

That said—you’re correct about that post.
 

Daximus

Wow, what a terrific audience.
Sponsor
Oct 11, 2014
39,874
26,863
Five Hills
Plenty of people use hyphens and em dashes. As a writer, they take no time at all to use because reading and writing is a way of life. Nothing wrong with elegant prose, even on these forums.

That said—you’re correct about that post.

Oh I get it many great writers actually know how to use them. It's just that the vast majority of people don't and when they get used on a message board it's even more of a telltale sign that someone is just plugging in some prompt to get a response to post here. I feel like it's kind of a fruitless endeavour because most people with any kind of internet literacy can spot it from a mile away. It doesn't make people look smart, just lazy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Video Nasty

benfranklin

Registered User
Jun 29, 2024
456
356
He's a top-10 player and it's really not questionable. He's done things with a consistency that very, very few players have ever matched.

Or to put another way, he is at LEAST wherever Jagr is.
Math guy here questioning it. You really have to stretch the value of Hart's to even remotely make an argument for McDavid being equal to Jagr currently. "At LEAST", no, not even close.

1921 points > 1003 points
2 Cups > 0 Cups
5 Art Ross = 5 Art Ross
1 Hart < 3 Hart
3 Lindsay/Pearson < 4 Lindsay/Pearson
0 Conn Smythe < 1 Conn Smythe
 

TheDawnOfANewTage

Dahlin, it’ll all be fine
Dec 17, 2018
12,995
19,187
#1 most skilled. Somewhere in 5-10 for effect in NHL. Going off cups is fundamentally unfair, but such is life, so he’s behind Crosby and Ovi until somethin changes.
 

nowhereman

Registered User
Jan 24, 2010
9,464
8,094
Los Angeles
Top 15-ish

He has enough hardware to be knocking on the door of top 10 but he lacks the career numbers and, as far as the "legacy" cherry on top, a Cup. If everything goes right on the back half of his career, he could make the Big 4 a Big 5. But he still has a ways to go there.
 

Grifter3511

Registered User
Nov 3, 2009
2,555
2,797
Math guy here questioning it. You really have to stretch the value of Hart's to even remotely make an argument for McDavid being equal to Jagr currently. "At LEAST", no, not even close.

1921 points > 1003 points
2 Cups > 0 Cups
5 Art Ross = 5 Art Ross
1 Hart < 3 Hart
3 Lindsay/Pearson < 4 Lindsay/Pearson
0 Conn Smythe < 1 Conn Smythe
Weird take. I'm a bigger jagr than mcdavid fan. But in significantly less time McDavid has won more individual accolades. All Jagr really has going for him here is length of tenure and the team award (SC).

I'd say it's much closer than you seem to think.
 

winnipegger

Registered User
Dec 17, 2013
8,538
7,585
At this rate he will be right beside Lemieux. But in order to achieve that status he has to win a couple cups. It's a big ask for the inept organization he plays for.

Why do people keep saying this when the oilers were 2 goals away from a cup last year. Clearly they can put a good team together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sanscosm

strattonius

Registered User
Jul 4, 2011
4,666
5,403
Surrey, BC
Why do people keep saying this when the oilers were 2 goals away from a cup last year. Clearly they can put a good team together.

Management in Edmonton has failed to insulate two of the best forwards of this generation. With a good management team, the McDavid/Draisaitl duo would have 2 cups by now. Do you even grasp how good these two players are? McDavid and Draisaitl dragged that mediocre roster to game 7 with absolutely historic playoff performances.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: sanscosm

Ad

Ad

Ad