NYR Viper
Registered User
The issue here isn't the price paid (Getting Vanek without giving up Strome or Reinhart or Pulock was a great move). It's that:
1)If he doesn't re-sign
2)Isles trade a strength for a strength and don't address their more important needs
3)Vanek is a known band-aid boy
4)Anything at least 1 playoff round win
At what point does Nabokov start to break down again? Not much help in the wings on that front, and they've now expended a valuable asset (1st rounder) in order to fix something that wasn't broke.
He will be a great player for them, but there is a gigantic risk involved here.
I think it's a great deal for both teams. Buffalo got quite the haul for a player who wasn't going to stay and the Islanders get to see if he meshes with Vanek, try and re-sign him for 3 months and if not, flip him elsewhere for more help.