"Hey, let's improve the team by putting more of the offense on the guy with the bad back and the guy who shows up when he feels like it!"
If you're trying to spread the wealth around by replacing Marner, you at least need to find one good scorer and one good defensive player, and I'm betting you'll be hard pressed to get both for a combined $11 mil. And then you have to also replace Tavares' PPG totals.
I would take my chances on new players than the core of 1 playoff series win in 9 playoffs(if another first round exits).
Goal is for the Leafs to win the Cup and not have MM, AM, JT, Willie and Reilly win the Cup for the Leafs.
Maybe the players brought in won’t have stats like JT and MM but if they collectively can win the Cup for the Leafs. Who cares if none of them ever score more than 60pts in a season. The point is to replace MM and JT to make a better team with better chance to win the Cup and not replace MM and JT on the team.
Bérubé led a Blues team that didn’t have top end offensive talents like the Leafs to a Cup, whose to say he can’t do that with the Leafs without MM and JT.