LSCII
Cup driven
It's definitely fair to question why Subban & Zane didn't play better. It sounds like we're going to find out soon enough.
With that said their starts were early in the year when the team was still finding its legs and their callups at the time were pretty unexpected. I think they were thrown to the wolves a bit and overwhelmed but Zane looked decent in his last start and has been the best goalie in the AHL since being sent back down. I'll be pretty surprised if he doesn't play much better assuming he gets some starts in this upcoming stint.
Anyway I think there's two things to debate here. Debating whether or not they have a viable backup in their system is one thing. But what I really took issue with is basically crapping on this move just because it's not the silver bullet that solves all their problems. I just don't like the mentality that only the biggest move matters.
I'm crapping on the move because it doesn't really move the needle. If they want to fix this team, they need to address other areas as well. That's all. I even said earlier, that this move makes no sense unless they do something else. I'm willing to give them time on that, and if they do make additional moves and fix the other areas, I'll gladly give them credit for it. As they haven't yet, all I can do is comment on the moves they have done.
In terms of the rest of your post, I hope you're right that they've tightened up the defensive play, because they're going to run Rask into the ground otherwise.