Value of: Alex Tuch to Montreal
- Thread starter boyinboyin
- Start date
Lane Hutson might cancel out the cap dump of Josh Anderson.
But then you've offered literally nothing for Tuch
But then you've offered literally nothing for Tuch
Canucks LB
My Favourite, Gone too soon, RIP Luc, We miss you
- Oct 12, 2008
- 78,150
- 32,777
I’m just trying to find out the reasoning?
Montreal waits forever to find a true top end potential prospect, and they trade him away?
Tuch is a great hockey player, established, but I don’t think this makes any sense for either team.
I feel another team could offer something more what buffalo is looking for.
Buffalo defensive is set already
Montreal waits forever to find a true top end potential prospect, and they trade him away?
Tuch is a great hockey player, established, but I don’t think this makes any sense for either team.
I feel another team could offer something more what buffalo is looking for.
Buffalo defensive is set already
Weltschmerz
Front Running Fan
- Apr 22, 2007
- 5,130
- 3,336
Hutson isn’t going anywhere and the Sabres are doing pretty good on defence
Hutson is a superstar… isn’t happening.
CanadienShark
Registered User
- Dec 18, 2012
- 39,489
- 13,893
1. Hutson is not for sale. Absolutely no chance.
2. Sabres love Tuch and I'd be astonished if he's available. They don't need another offensive LHD either.
This deal makes no sense at all.
2. Sabres love Tuch and I'd be astonished if he's available. They don't need another offensive LHD either.
This deal makes no sense at all.
Zman5778
Moderator
I've said it before, and I'll say it again:
If Alex Tuch is traded -- which is highly unlikely but not impossible -- he will not be the best current NHL player in the deal. The best current NHL player will be coming to Buffalo and Alex Tuch would be part of the deal going back.
If Alex Tuch is traded -- which is highly unlikely but not impossible -- he will not be the best current NHL player in the deal. The best current NHL player will be coming to Buffalo and Alex Tuch would be part of the deal going back.
Oh what fresh hell is this? Neither team does this, but it's especially true for Buffalo
pth2
Registered User
- Jan 7, 2018
- 3,431
- 2,723
That's the issue with HF. Every fan wants to upgrade their team by dealing packages, no one wants to give a good player for such a package.
No wonder discussions flounder so often.
-----
This deal just doesn't make sense, regardless. Buffalo wants to exit their rebuild and compete, so they won'tmove a contributing young skater for more youth, Montreal is trying to improve but won't give up unproven high-end talent before giving them a chance.
Fjordy
Registered User
- Jun 20, 2018
- 16,669
- 9,110
HabsAddict
Registered User
Stop making so much sense.
We're going to trade Hutson brfore he even hatches because? He has a high potential to be worth a pile of Tuchs in a few years...yet lets trade him now.
No GM in his right mind makes a trade like this that has so much potential upside unless his name is BargainBin. (See Sergachev.)
Djp
Registered User
Horrendous.
Buffalo does not need LD
Anderson us a cap dump
Clifton is their only RHD under contract.
Who are Montreal lo s 3 best players? What are their top 3 prosprcys.
It will cost you one of each for buffalo to trade Tuch
Buffalo fans have engaged me, as a neutral party, to act in their interest and respond to this offer.
After due consideration, my response, on behalf of the Sabres and
their organization, is; F--k NO!
After due consideration, my response, on behalf of the Sabres and
their organization, is; F--k NO!
tsujimoto74
Moderator
- May 28, 2012
- 30,364
- 23,010
pth2
Registered User
- Jan 7, 2018
- 3,431
- 2,723
Neither is Hutson. It's just a badly designed deal.
Now, if Buffalo had a kid who wasn't getting a chance, and Montreal had a current contributor who could help Buffalo take that next step, then we could talk.
toddkaz
Registered User
- Nov 25, 2022
- 6,096
- 3,745
Can you be a superstar if you only played 2 NHL games?
I knew we could count on you.
completely ridiculous...tuch is already 28 and had an outlier season at 32 goals.
He hasn't scored more than 22 in any other year.
Anderson who everyone seems to hate, has 2, 20 goal years and get this, has the exact same number of career goals (131) as Tuch.
top 3 prospects? lmao.
I actually like Tuch, but if Hutson has a rookie breakout year, no one with an actual brain in their head would trade a young dman for a winger.
you can dislike the proposal,
Let's stop pretending harris and anderson are simply throw ins.
Last edited:
I mean you are right that Anderson isn't a throw in. 20 pts in a full season at his cap hit. Is a major cap dump, not a throw in.
Lol nobody wants anderson it doesn't matter how u dress it up its one of the top 5 worst contract since day 1
he had a shit year. If he bounces back with another 25 goal year, he'll be suddenly good again - especially if habs trade, many of you will magically find his value again.
Regardless, it's too much of a risk to trade Hutson for a winger that doesn't fit into the habs timeline. Clifton also has no place on the habs (he might have value elsewhere)
And at 23, Harris has value as well.
This OP's proposal has 0 thought to it and this has become a pissing contest
ForsbergForever
Registered User
- May 19, 2004
- 3,354
- 2,102
What a bonkers proposal, why would the Habs trade their #1 prospect for a veteran 2nd liner in the middle of a rebuild?
Ad
Latest posts
-
-
-
-
HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #88: 2024 Off-Season Thread
- Latest: Scintillating10
