Alex Ovechkin vs Evgeni Malkin

[Gorskyontario]

You should check your information before you spout false data.

2009
Malkin: 36
Crosby: 31

2016
Malkin: 18(in 1 less game)
Crosby: 19

2017
Malkin: 28
Crosby: 27

You're right, Crosby had a 1 point lead when having an additional game in 2016, Malkin still carried him.

Ovechkin has two more Hart trophies and 355 more goals...and he didn't have the elite talent around him that Malkin did

Ovechkin played on an offensively elite team nearly his entire career.

 

[daver]

2009
Malkin: 36
Crosby: 31

2016
Malkin: 18(in 1 less game)
Crosby: 19

2017
Malkin: 28
Crosby: 27

You're right, Crosby had a 1 point lead when having an additional game in 2016, Malkin still carried him.

If Malkin "carried" Crosby in 2016 (he didn't) then Crosby carried Malkin in 2017 (he didn't).

And Crosby carried Malkin to the SCF in 2009 if we use your definition.

 

[Conspiracy Theorist]

Ovechkin is ranked higher all time. Gretzky is also greater than Mario but not necessarily better player.

 

[Professor What]

If Malkin "carried" Crosby in 2016 (he didn't) then Crosby carried Malkin in 2017 (he didn't).

And Crosby carried Malkin to the SCF in 2009 if we use your definition.

Don't waste your time. The goal posts are going to constantly move. I regret having engaged myself.

 

[Gorskyontario]

If Malkin "carried" Crosby in 2016 (he didn't) then Crosby carried Malkin in 2017 (he didn't).

And Crosby carried Malkin to the SCF in 2009 if we use your definition.

Malkin was the better playoff performer in all their stanley cup runs(except 2008 when they lost).

Crosby had 2 or 3 points in the 2009 finals.

 

[Nathaniel Skywalker]

2009
Malkin: 36
Crosby: 31

2016
Malkin: 18(in 1 less game)
Crosby: 19

2017
Malkin: 28
Crosby: 27

You're right, Crosby had a 1 point lead when having an additional game in 2016, Malkin still carried him.



Ovechkin played on an offensively elite team nearly his entire career.

Lol you left out the fact that Malkin had 1 more point in with having an additional game in 2017. All in all crosby scored 77 points in the 3 cup wins and Malkin scored 82. This is with crosby taking the number 1 defensive units and being far better in the dot etc.

Malkin was the better playoff performer in all their stanley cup runs(except 2008 when they lost).

Crosby had 2 or 3 points in the 2009 finals.

Crosby also led the 2017 finals in scoring. Fun fact crosby had more points in 3/4 finals

 

[Gorskyontario]

Lol you left out the fact that Malkin had 1 more point in with having an additional game in 2017. All in all crosby scored 77 points in the 3 cup wins and Malkin scored 82. This is with crosby taking the number 1 defensive units and being far better in the dot etc.

In 2017 I distinctly remember Crosby matching up(and to his credit, dominating) an old Joe Thoenton. Not exactly the 'hardest match up'.