Alex Nylander

bwana63

carter blanche
Jul 11, 2014
5,477
4,489
Chi western burbs
Inside the Alex Nylander trade: How Anders Sorensen gave the Blackhawks exclusive insight

Nice article about Nylander and Sorensen being an influence in getting him here. Even if he starts in Rockford, seems like he'll be in good hands down there.

Good article, thanks. Had no idea Nylander's ties to Chicago and the Hawks ran so deep. I think he makes the team. If he doesn't, I was afraid he might sulk (beyond initial disappointment), but with Sorenson there, I highly doubt it.

This is the epitome of a change of scenery trade. Really hoping a fresh start does wonders.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Styles

featherhawk

Registered User
Dec 13, 2006
14,429
5,090
sure hope he makes good on this chance.

IMO he is going to be placed in an opportunity to succeed and play with the likes of Toews, Kane, Cat, Strome, and perhaps Dach.

the future looks bright for the hawks and this guy could play a big role in that
 

piteus

Registered User
Dec 20, 2015
12,122
3,367
NYC
Look, there’s always money in the banana stand.
giphy.gif
 

LordKOTL

Abuse of Officials
Aug 15, 2014
3,525
768
Pacific NW
What happened to... players should not get their spots for free without proving themselves.... you know...earning your spot and all.
- I get it that you don't think that, per say, you just say Colliton will probably do this.

Alexander Nylander has not earned a top 6 spot, why should he be automatically put to 1st or 2nd line???.
His AHL performance has been weak so far. Olofsson for example was miles ahead of him in every way last season
and now he (Olofsson looks like a lock for Sabres roster from the get go. - Nylander didn't impress me at the camp either

Alexander Nylander is just not good enough player to play with likes of Toews,Kane,Strome,DeBrincat.

PS. this is not an attack towards Nylander, nor do i hate one of the Hawks players
nor does it make me a not a fan, or some BS like that. - this is my honest (like always) valuation of him as a talent
/ hockey player, for me he just is not good enough, he is like his brother but bigger minus the talent/skill
It tends to go right out the window when you have coach/GM/upper management ego in the way--especially if the player is a gamble like Nylander is. If the coach/GM/Upper management takes a risk on a player who'd not done much, they want them to succeed and they'll give said player every opportunity to succeed. Sometimes, like Strome, it works. Sometimes, like Runblad, it fails epically. The book is out on Nylander since he's played exactly 0 games for the Blackhawks. We. Just. Don't. Know. His AHL/NHL numbers could be what he is, and he could fail. His ceiling could be what he is and the 'hawks could bring it out of him, and he could succeed, but at this point anyone who thinks they have him pegged as a bonafied success or a bonafied failure are deluding themselves.

Besdies, aside from Strome, Debrincat, Toews, and Kane, who last year proved they were de facto top-6? Maybe Saad, but it's a push. Most of the fill-ins that worked just had chemistry and weren't the main drivers that TKDS were. So, if they want to give Nylander a shot, why not? As long as he's not Sikura and a complete offensive black hole there's no reason to not give him a shot. My only worry is that he isn't working that JC/Stan keep him put there past his use-by date--like they did with Sikura.
 

Robsker

Registered User
Nov 8, 2014
1,051
205
Excellent post. I had not viewed it this way. I was thinking of whether he had done anything to earn a shot - relative to other prospects. From that assessment, certainly Kubalik, Saarela, Wedin, Perlini (if on the team), Kurashev, and Dach (maybe even Quinville) are more worthy of an audition on the Hawks. That places him as the 7th or 8th in line. But, perhaps you are right, maybe he gets an audition even though he has not earned one based upon his performance since drafted. Could be. maybe his draft position and the fact that we just traded for him in conjunction with the reality of Strome's emergence having done little prior - perhaps all this points to a forthcoming audition for Nylander - ahead of others who have out-produced him.
 

Kaners Bald Spot

Registered User
Dec 6, 2011
22,704
10,812
Kane County, IL
Excellent post. I had not viewed it this way. I was thinking of whether he had done anything to earn a shot - relative to other prospects. From that assessment, certainly Kubalik, Saarela, Wedin, Perlini (if on the team), Kurashev, and Dach (maybe even Quinville) are more worthy of an audition on the Hawks. That places him as the 7th or 8th in line. But, perhaps you are right, maybe he gets an audition even though he has not earned one based upon his performance since drafted. Could be. maybe his draft position and the fact that we just traded for him in conjunction with the reality of Strome's emergence having done little prior - perhaps all this points to a forthcoming audition for Nylander - ahead of others who have out-produced him.
Strome had shown a lot more post-draft than Nylander. Strome was around a ppg in the AHL and Nylander hasn't come close to that there.
 

x Tame Impala

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Aug 24, 2011
28,738
13,744
Excellent post. I had not viewed it this way. I was thinking of whether he had done anything to earn a shot - relative to other prospects. From that assessment, certainly Kubalik, Saarela, Wedin, Perlini (if on the team), Kurashev, and Dach (maybe even Quinville) are more worthy of an audition on the Hawks. That places him as the 7th or 8th in line. But, perhaps you are right, maybe he gets an audition even though he has not earned one based upon his performance since drafted. Could be. maybe his draft position and the fact that we just traded for him in conjunction with the reality of Strome's emergence having done little prior - perhaps all this points to a forthcoming audition for Nylander - ahead of others who have out-produced him.

None of those guys except Dach and maybe Kubalik/Kurashev have done anything to distance themselves from each other. Certainly not enough to “deserve it” more than Nylander.

As far as I’m concerned they’re all a part of a big group of kids trying to earn a spot.
 

LordKOTL

Abuse of Officials
Aug 15, 2014
3,525
768
Pacific NW
None of those guys except Dach and maybe Kubalik/Kurashev have done anything to distance themselves from each other. Certainly not enough to “deserve it” more than Nylander.

As far as I’m concerned they’re all a part of a big group of kids trying to earn a spot.
Basically, yeah. No single player should be handed a spot or kept there past their use by date, and no player should be effectively be barred from a slot if they show they can handle it better than anyone else in contention...in a perfect world. Unfortunately the world isn't perfect
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyJet

BobbyJet

The accountability era?
Oct 27, 2010
30,550
10,243
Dundas, Ontario. Can
Basically, yeah. No single player should be handed a spot or kept there past their use by date, and no player should be effectively be barred from a slot if they show they can handle it better than anyone else in contention...in a perfect world. Unfortunately the world isn't perfect

This was one character trait of Q that bothered me: Most of the time he would decide on a player almost immediately, sometimes before he played a game for Hawks. Whether right or wrong in his assessment he would take his sweet time in changing his view, if ever and usually never. Much like BWC. :) Maybe that's the reason he likes Q so much.

Hopefully JC will show more patience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kaners Bald Spot

hawksrule

Lot of brains but no polish
May 18, 2014
21,207
11,095
This was one character trait of Q that bothered me: Most of the time he would decide on a player almost immediately, sometimes before he played a game for Hawks. Whether right or wrong in his assessment he would take his sweet time in changing his view, if ever and usually never. Much like BWC. :) Maybe that's the reason he likes Q so much.

Hopefully JC will show more patience.

Who did Q refuse to give a fair shot?
 

hawksrule

Lot of brains but no polish
May 18, 2014
21,207
11,095
Actually it works both ways: players who Q gave up on pretty much immediately or too quickly and players he insisted on playing way too much (and/or in positions they weren't suited for). I'm not gonna rehash the past though.

On whom did he unfairly give up?
 

LordKOTL

Abuse of Officials
Aug 15, 2014
3,525
768
Pacific NW
This was one character trait of Q that bothered me: Most of the time he would decide on a player almost immediately, sometimes before he played a game for Hawks. Whether right or wrong in his assessment he would take his sweet time in changing his view, if ever and usually never. Much like BWC. :) Maybe that's the reason he likes Q so much.

Hopefully JC will show more patience.
Time will tell. IMHO JC's handing of Sikura makes him a wash so far with Q. JC deserves a ton of credit for getting Gus on the #1 PP unit and Keith out of there, something Q failed at. Flipside: I get the feeling Q wouldn't have left Sikura on the top line well-past his use-by date since I don't think Q would have gotten an unnatural Sikura fetish.

We'll see this coming season. I'm trying to keep my mind open at this point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyJet

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad