The narrative that he "underperformed" is quite interesting...
You do realize that only 4 players from his draft class have played more NHL games than he has so far... And he earned those games on a cup contending & cup winning roster.
Pts-wise, he sits 9th... And again, this is on a cup contender where he was in 3rd line role with minimal pp time. Kakko is the only fwd ahead of him pts-wise who isn't a top 6 regular on their respective team.
So by what standard do you consider him to have "underperformed"? Relative to his draft spot & draft class, he's trending ahead of the curve in pts & NHL time, that would strike me as a net positive
Well the Avs traded him, so I guess by their metrics as the team that drafted, developed and played him, he was a disappointment or they would've kept him. He obviously didn't live up to their expectations so they traded him before he became another Tyson Jost.
So I'll say by the Avs standard.
But I'll also add sports media who call him a reclamation project, Habs management who think he hasn't reached his full potential and by fans.
https://thehockeynews.com/nhl/montr...hes-appears-thrilled-with-his-new-acquisition "
Make no mistake, Alex Newhook is a reclamation project. He was drafted on June 21, 2019 in Vancouver between
Cole Caufield at 15th overall and Sabres forward Peyton Krebs
, drafted by the Vegas Golden Knights at 17th overall, but hasn't shown much of the promise of those two dynamic players.
Hughes is banking on the inspiration of Marty St. Louis to unlock Newhook's full potential.
The Canadiens head coach is confident that a bigger role will help the forward find his game. "[Newhook] will have the opportunity to be in a better chair," St. Louis said. "He's a player that reflects a lot in what we're looking for from a culture point of view, and style of play. He's not the biggest player but he plays heavy.
I think we're able to bring a player into an environment where he can show more."
You can also add to that with the constant comparisons to the Dach move last year where a former high pick hadn't reached their potential and did much better playing for the Habs, which is the hope for Newhook. If he was already performing to his potential and was a finished product, the comparison wouldn't be made and Habs management wouldn't think there was more there for them to bring out but rather to just add him to the fold as a complete player. In addition, I don' think the Habs are giving up a 1st, 2nd and prospect for a 30 point player. That would be VERY disappointing.
So I think it's pretty clear to anyone who's seen, heard or read about this move that Newhook trade was about his potential to do more, and not his current state of play.