norrisnick
The best...
- Apr 14, 2005
- 30,710
- 15,906
Does it matter more how old a player is for their debut? Or how well they play in their debut?
And this is just based on your guess, right? You didn't bother to look into it?Well he’s only “middle of the pack” for us because we have a bunch of those guys. If you take them out he could be all the way on the end.
Sure, but still not an outlier, which is all I was showing. The number of dmen breaking in at 22 or younger doesn’t change in the sample.Well he’s only “middle of the pack” for us because we have a bunch of those guys. If you take them out he could be all the way on the end.
But what’s his age per 60? Is it good or bad?Does it matter more how old a player is for their debut? Or how well they play in their debut?
. From the post that replied to mine I went back and looked at the 2015(?) draft and I found like 5 guys I would legitimately want on a cup contending team that were drafted after the 50th pick. So, not just good guys or technically NHLers, but ones I'd actually like. Of that 5, four had seen legit NHL ice time in the third season. I know sample size and everything, but it's something that feels right to me.good point about Covid, we're probably still seeing some effects there. Maybe not for AlJo in this particular case, but in general.
But to the bold... if that's the case, then I'm even less worried about AlJo in regards to this age argument. He was ready for at least a cup of coffee last season, and only didn't get that because of the Petry-Holl fiasco effect.
Wrong Gustav...I can’t help but get Gustav Lindstrom II from Johansson
Lindstrom had no transition game at the NHL level, nor any real offensive IQ. Johansson should exceed Lindstrom in both categories. Better skater too.I can’t help but get Gustav Lindstrom II from Johansson
No, it is not and never has been a hard rule, but always extremely unlikely. I mean there are late bloomers, sure, but at 25 aljo will need to burst on to the scene, like the birth of venus. That said, I have always been an aljo advocate (once we didn't take my Russian) but we have sucked for a bit, so why not give out a few cups of coffee once in a while. It actually works in other sports. If we had, this 23yr thing would be a non starter. Because, successful or not, I could point to that 4or6 game trial. Not, the hill I'm willing to die on, but all of his teammates and coaches have declared him the best when asked!! And I'm pretty sure Ed was on the team at the time.. From the post that replied to mine I went back and looked at the 2015(?) draft and I found like 5 guys I would legitimately want on a cup contending team that were drafted after the 50th pick. So, not just good guys or technically NHLers, but ones I'd actually like. Of that 5, four had seen legit NHL ice time in the third season. I know sample size and everything, but it's something that feels right to me.
So, no, I don't think it's a hard and fast rule but I think it's a fair bench mark for when we maybe need to start looking at our expectations for a kid. Having said that, I'm not worried about Albert, either.
Uhmm probably their best d-man, Gustav Forsling, only really became a full-time NHLer at 24.Florida, for example, has 11 defenseman listed on their roster and only 2 irrelevant guys that I don't recognize made it at 23 or later. I didn't find any top 4 D outside of Walman that started this late on the 4 teams that I checked.
Mo has 6 pro seasons by the standards you used for everyone else.Season 2024-25:
Moritz Seider, 23-year-old
- 3 pro seasons
- 3 NHL seasons
Simon Edvinsson, 21-year-old
- 3,5 pro seasons
- 0.5 NHL seasons
Albert Johansson, 23-year-old
- 5 pro seasons
William Wallinder, 21.5-year old
- 3 pro seasons
Axel Sandin Pellikka, 19-year-old
- 1.5 pro seasons
Think we can go on the season with 1-2 NHL rookies on the roster. Ed and Johansson.
Seider has already reached a "vet" status, thanks to his experience and talent level. He is not in his prime yet, but not anyhow a liability.
Signed a new 1 year deal
The first domino...Signed a new 1 year deal
He still has to clear waivers on the 2 wayOh yay. 2 way.
This has me thinking Yzerman is just going to run it back this year instead of making the hard moves and dumping mid vets, and I’m very disappointed.
Don't be too fast to judgeOh yay. 2 way.
This has me thinking Yzerman is just going to run it back this year instead of making the hard moves and dumping mid vets, and I’m very disappointed.
This is the Internet. That's what it's for.Don't be too fast to judge
Literally plays and profiles nothing like Gustav. Very bad comparison.I can’t help but get Gustav Lindstrom II from Johansson