Svechhammer
THIS is hockey?
- Jun 8, 2017
- 25,491
- 92,952
Jerkutus of BorgDon't look now, but Willie is likely part of the Borg...
Jerkutus of BorgDon't look now, but Willie is likely part of the Borg...
The Charlotte Checkers just can't quit Jeff Daniels.
I want Scotty Walker to take the Checkers over
I get what Williams brings to the team in leadership, which is always hard to translate to on-ice benefit. But he's no spring chicken, will be another year older, and quite possibly could be a net negative on the ice compared to this past year. If we think the team was going to pay him $3mil for another year, why not pay that to a younger guy like a Boyle, Brassard or Maroon?
If we think the team was going to pay him $3mil for another year, why not pay that to a younger guy like a Boyle, Brassard or Maroon?
I mean, even if Williams drops off at some point, he's still a great fourth liner for the remainder of the season. It's not like he's going to be doing anything but signing one-year deals for as long as he's willing and able.
If his production drops, is he really a typical fourth liner though? He's not fast enough IMO. If he's not on 2nd/3rd line I don't think he has a place.
If his production drops, is he really a typical fourth liner though? He's not fast enough IMO. If he's not on 2nd/3rd line I don't think he has a place.
Obviously time comes for us all (resistance is futile) but Williams stats over the past few years are pretty much the model of consistency:
Justin Williams has plenty left in the tank as an effective hockey player if he chooses to be. But he's a guy with a family and kids who has made plenty of money in his career and already reached the pinnacle of his profession three times considering whether he really wants to dedicate another year of his life to one of the more grueling lifestyles you can find and one that only gets more grueling as you get older.
Sometimes there's no conspiracy. Sometimes you just want to get out of the heat of things, come down off the adrenaline, sleep deprivation and caffeine and hit the beach for a couple weeks before you make a big decision.
You just really don't understand how good Justin Williams is, do you. The fact that you would rather spend $3 million on Patrick Maroon than Justin Williams really says about all you need to say. You've got to do you, but this is a really weird path to take. Justin Williams is really good at hockey. I'm not sure what else to say.
Off the ice - he just built a massive house in McGregor. I would think the thought of “hey, I could play this year and nearly pay for the whole damn thing” has to be a little enticing.Williams has shown he has more than enough left in the tank to play in the NHL. He takes very good care of his body and could easily play a bottom 6 (if not top 6) role with PP time for another 3-4 years if he really wanted to. It's just a question of how much does he really want to when he has done almost everything there is to do in the NHL. I hope he comes back for at least another year or two but I would understand if he wanted to walk away now.
I didn't suggest a $$$ amount for Maroon. If he's going to get $3mil then maybe not. But he doesn't look all that bad, is 6 years younger than Williams, and is about a 40-point player with a decent shooting %age. I don't know about his defensive capabilities, maybe that's where his speed is a liability? But he seems like a decent guy, plays a strong game, and wouldn't be the worst guy to bring on? I agree Williams has been good, I just don't know about paying him $3-$4mil at his age, and watching him make some fairly questionable plays with the puck all year.
Off the ice - he just built a massive house in McGregor. I would think the thought of “hey, I could play this year and nearly pay for the whole damn thing” has to be a little enticing.
Maroon as a 31 year old power forward was 28 point player last year. He had one big year with McDavid as his center, otherwise he’s been a large Brock McGinn.