I guess your perspective on your AHL farm team really depends on what you define as success.
Sure it would be nice if your AHL farm marched through to the Calder Cup Finals every year like the Hershey Bears. Problem is, they're a veteran AHL team that generates almost 'zero talent' for their NHL affiliate, the Washington Capitals.
Seems to me Abbotsford has the best of two possible worlds. They're competitive every year, winning 40 games in each of the past two seasons. But more importantly, they've done with one of the younger rosters in the AHL.
There are lots of veterans to support the kids in Abbotsford this year. Guys like Wolanin, Brisebois, Friedman, Stevens, Kambeitz, Blais and Twarynski are all veteran players. Problem is they have too many veterans, and can't play them all every night.
And they have a lot of 'young veterans' like Sasson, Karlsson, Nielsen, Woo, Wouters, Smith and Bains (when he returns) all of whom are in at least their third AHL seasons. Even their goaltenders are in their mid-20's with a lot of pro experience.
And these veterans will help the likes of Pettersson, Kudryavtsev, Lekkerimki, Klimovich, McWard and maybe even Tom Wilander by the end of the season. And it's possible that even kids like Mynio and Arliksson make an appearance as well, since they're already signed.
IMO Ryan Johnston and Canucks have a fine job with the Abbotsford Canucks on and off the ice. Rutherford's stated goal is to turn the Abbotsford Canucks into a 'model AHL franchise'. I think they're well on their way to that goal.
You suggest that Washington should be criticize Washington for not developing player at the expense of playing veterans . In fact, Washington has in Miroshnichenko, Cristall, Leonard, Iorio, Parascak, McMicheal much better prospect than we have. Winning the Calder Cup doesn't mean you don't have develop prospects. Indeed the opposite is more likely true. And if you are going to critcize a team for not developing prospects then shouldn't Abby be included. This season has revealed that none of the supposed prospects in Abby are close to helping Vancouver. Development-wise Abbotsford is black hole.
Also, you suggest that Washington had a veteran laded team while we were more concerned with developing young vets. But as you point out yourself you can only play a limited number of vets so you can't stack a team in the AHL with vets while somehow others don't. . Suggesting that Hershey won b/c of this is untrue. They could only play the same number of vets as we did..
The difference is that, like other good teams at this level, Hershey had excellent vets while we have very mediocre ones. Only Wolanin on you list is an upper level vet. The rest are very ordinary and some just bottom enders. Fact is the number of good vets has diminished steadily since the first year in
Abbotsford. In the end, one of the main difference between us and a team like Hershey and other top tier AHL teams, is that their management as been able to bring in good veteran players while we clearly have not . And whose to blame for that?
Not only that, Abbotsford has not brought in veteran toughness, like every other AHL team does (like Hershey has Mclrath +others) which I believe was a key factor in the number of key injuries the team suffered last year. This had an obvious negative effect on the development of players. So why has the team not done at least something to protect the younger players and whose to blame for that?
Saying people like Karlsson, Sassons etc will help the young players is speculation at best. What you need is true veterans with lots of AHL experience . Guys you mention are still trying to find thier way. Throwing the burden on them to lead the young players is asking way too much and is simply foolish in my opinion. You need seasoned vets. That should be Johnson job and you look at the lineup and he has clearly failed in that aspect.
Saying that the Canucks have a bunch of drafted players that are in, or may come into the lineup, this season is irrelevant. Johnson was not responible for any of those players and fact some are playing or maybe playing in Abbotsford is not a criteria for assessing the job done by Johnson. And my fear is that these younger players will not develop in the atmosphere created by Johnson. And in that belief, history is on my side.
To me, you are drinking the Cool-aid. Having this nice, rosy picture of the success Johnson and his successes may allow you sleep better at night but ignores some of the realities of what is actually going on. Having a goal of having a successful farm team is not the same as achieveing it. Success is actually achieveing something, not dreaming about it happening.
I