Tatar Shots
Registered User
- Feb 2, 2014
- 5,875
- 1,962
This site is definitely unique in that regard. I mean you go look at a random prospect's thread who is rated in the teens on the prospect sub and people will say their floor is some all star player and their ceiling is some superstar player. That is one thing people are super out of touch with, the floor of these respective players. Most players that get drafted are not exempt from completely flaming out. There is a wider range of outcomes with prospects than most want to believe, and part of that spectrum includes outright failing.
That said, I think on this sub in particular, outlook is shaped by our situation. We literally have to have our prospects exceed expectations for the rebuild at hand to work. If every player became exactly what was the typical outcome for their draft slot, we would end up a shitty hockey team.... period. So yeah, people are going to have higher expectations for draft picks and probably in some cases just try to focus on the optimistic side of things. And I understand why that might be. But there's also nothing wrong with reminding people of what that draft slot usually yields too. I can see both sides of that.
Even then, most people don’t even know what exceeding expectations looks like. On average, about two players drafted in the second round each year go on to become Top 6 F/ Top 4 D. Yzerman has selected eleven F/D in the second round since becoming GM, if one of those players becomes a Top 6 F/ Top 4 D, we would technically be exceeding expectations. If two players from that group become Top 6 F/ Top 4 D, we’d be smashing expectations. I’d assume most here think getting two Top 6 F/ Top 4 D out of eleven second round draft picks would be a disappointment.