lilidk
Registered User
- Mar 4, 2008
- 11,401
- 4,529
Just like all our prospectsPretty good.... at creating concern.
Just like all our prospectsPretty good.... at creating concern.
Our Swedish league draftees get to develop with Kronwall and all do great until they come to NA and turn to shit.Just like all our prospects
I think we have overblown expectations for 8/9 OA picks. A .5 ppg agitating center is a decent outcome for that draft position.If he could finish the year around ~.5 PPG, I would feel a bit better.
Connor Zary had a pretty bleh year in the AHL in his +2 year then had a jump in the AHL in his +3 year and is having an impact for Calgary this year. Would hope Kasper could do something similar.
Yeah, I’ve made multiple posts/threads that say as much. The most likely scenario with this current lottery system is that teams at the bottom will stay stuck there. They had a choice between helping the teams at the bottom or deterring teams from tanking and they pretty firmly planted their flag on the latter. Will imagine they will start to get some pressure to change that system in the near future, at least I can only hope.I think we have overblown expectations for 8/9 OA picks. A .5 ppg agitating center is a decent outcome for that draft position.
It gets even worse at 9OA. Only 31 players drafted 9OA from 1963 to 2022 had more than 200 NHL points.
It's really, really hard to run a rebuild when the best draft position you get when repeatedly finishing bottom 3 in the league is 4OA and you are constantly getting leapfrogged by teams like NJ, CHI, and NYR who have better rosters to begin with.
Someone (Bench?) put together a good chart of this last year. I agree that there is a big difference between a top 3 pick in the first round and everything else in the first round. A lot of expectations, however, are driven by hope and a desire that a player will work out.I think we have overblown expectations for 8/9 OA picks. A .5 ppg agitating center is a decent outcome for that draft position.
It gets even worse at 9OA. Only 31 players drafted 9OA from 1963 to 2022 had more than 200 NHL points.
It's really, really hard to run a rebuild when the best draft position you get when repeatedly finishing bottom 3 in the league is 4OA and you are constantly getting leapfrogged by teams like NJ, CHI, and NYR who have better rosters to begin with.
This is why I keep saying Yzerman needs to start/keep trading firsts for established players. He did it with DeBrincat. You could almost certainly get Hanifin with a first and a mid-tier prospect and he's a top-pair talent in his mid 20s. Just don't make the Ottawa mistake and make sure you can sign him long-term.Yeah, I’ve made multiple posts/threads that say as much. The most likely scenario with this current lottery system is that teams at the bottom will stay stuck there. They had a choice between helping the teams at the bottom or deterring teams from tanking and they pretty firmly planted their flag on the latter. Will imagine they will start to get some pressure to change that system in the near future, at least I can only hope.
I guess my separate thought is if you know the conditions are what they are, I’m a little surprised we aren’t seeing the teams at the bottom being a bit bolder (guess Arizona was in this last draft.)
That’s another route we could go, and it might not be a bad option at this point.This is why I keep saying Yzerman needs to start/keep trading firsts for established players. He did it with DeBrincat. You could almost certainly get Hanifin with a first and a mid-tier prospect and he's a top-pair talent in his mid 20s. Just don't make the Ottawa mistake and make sure you can sign him long-term.
We aren't going to have the cap space to sign Hanifin long term though.This is why I keep saying Yzerman needs to start/keep trading firsts for established players. He did it with DeBrincat. You could almost certainly get Hanifin with a first and a mid-tier prospect and he's a top-pair talent in his mid 20s. Just don't make the Ottawa mistake and make sure you can sign him long-term.
I had a site I used for years that had data on what a draft pick usually produces and all kinds of odds related to that, but it looks like it was taken downSomeone (Bench?) put together a good chart of this last year. I agree that there is a big difference between a top 3 pick in the first round and everything else in the first round. A lot of expectations, however, are driven by hope and a desire that a player will work out.
We aren't going to have the cap space to sign Hanifin long term though.
I don’t know why anyone has a view on our cap situation that’s anything but this.The Wings have so much cap flexibility I don't see how there is any player they could not fit in long term. Perron, Reimer, Sprong, Kane (although I hope he's back) all are off the books.
He was a Walking Hall of Famer in this forum just six months ago. Actually, maybe just six weeks ago.Just like all our prospects
Yeah, with all these marquee players in our system we might be looking at a major cap crunch in 10 years.We aren't going to have the cap space to sign Hanifin long term though.
Our Swedish league draftees get to develop with Kronwall and all do great until they come to NA and turn to shit.
Our NA drafting and development is absolute ass and Yzerman needs to rebuild the whole structure from Draper down.
That side of the org is a lot of Holland-era holdovers and it really shows. We can't keep drafting Kris Draper clones.
I mean, most scouts said he was a projected 3rd line center with limited offensive upside and he’s turning out to for that bill perfectly, yet there were guys ranked much better than Kasper and yet we still seemed okay with a middle of the lineup grinder. In other words, we had our chance to make a better pick and didn’t want to.I think we have overblown expectations for 8/9 OA picks. A .5 ppg agitating center is a decent outcome for that draft position.
It gets even worse at 9OA. Only 31 players drafted 9OA from 1963 to 2022 had more than 200 NHL points.
It's really, really hard to run a rebuild when the best draft position you get when repeatedly finishing bottom 3 in the league is 4OA and you are constantly getting leapfrogged by teams like NJ, CHI, and NYR who have better rosters to begin with.
Chicago will probably make the playoffs before us after they get 1OA this year. With the way the draft is now structured, if all the lottery picks go to teams higher than 11OA Chicago can still get 1OA. The only competition they have for bottom in the league is SJ. The NHL has a ridiculous hard-on for Chicago, so I could see that happening.
It is hard, but there's something wrong with Detroit's ability to scout forwards. Their two best picks are looking like Mo and Ed, so their ability to assess d-men seems good, but given the fact that there's a lot of hold over between Kenny and Stevie in the scouting and player development department, there are clear problems in assessing forwards.I had a site I used for years that had data on what a draft pick usually produces and all kinds of odds related to that, but it looks like it was taken down
I could find some of my old posts that referenced it if need be.
And now we couldn't trade him for Zadina.He was a Walking Hall of Famer in this forum just six months ago. Actually, maybe just six weeks ago.
For a guy who pretty much had his ass saved by hitting on Kucherov and Point in the later rounds, it continues to mystify me that Yzerman does not take more shots on high upside forwards with the amount of picks we have had.It is hard, but there's something wrong with Detroit's ability to scout forwards. Their two best picks are looking like Mo and Ed, so their ability to assess d-men seems good, but given the fact that there's a lot of hold over between Kenny and Stevie in the scouting and player development department, there are clear problems in assessing forwards.
dont want to turn this into a lottery ball discussion, but why don't they just put the logo of the team on the ping pong balls and show their weight to the camera for every ball and make sure they are the same. Then, whatever gets pulled would literally be random and it would be a lot easier for the people viewing it to see who wins.I think we have overblown expectations for 8/9 OA picks. A .5 ppg agitating center is a decent outcome for that draft position.
It gets even worse at 9OA. Only 31 players drafted 9OA from 1963 to 2022 had more than 200 NHL points.
It's really, really hard to run a rebuild when the best draft position you get when repeatedly finishing bottom 3 in the league is 4OA and you are constantly getting leapfrogged by teams like NJ, CHI, and NYR who have better rosters to begin with.
Chicago will probably make the playoffs before us after they get 1OA this year. With the way the draft is now structured, if all the lottery picks go to teams higher than 11OA Chicago can still get 1OA. The only competition they have for bottom in the league is SJ. The NHL has a ridiculous hard-on for Chicago, so I could see that happening.
For a guy who pretty much had his ass saved by hitting on Kucherov and Point in the later rounds, it continues to mystify me that Yzerman does not take more shots on high upside forwards with the amount of picks we have had.
Yeah and then you look at them drafting ASP this year too. I mean for the most part the picks that either have worked or seem to be working best are all defenseman.It is hard, but there's something wrong with Detroit's ability to scout forwards. Their two best picks are looking like Mo and Ed, so their ability to assess d-men seems good, but given the fact that there's a lot of hold over between Kenny and Stevie in the scouting and player development department, there are clear problems in assessing forwards.
Maybe the team should just stick with what it does best, draft more defensemen and then trade them for forwards. Stevie is realgud at trading.Yeah and then you look at them drafting ASP this year too. I mean for the most part the picks that either have worked or seem to be working best are all defenseman.
I don't know if we are going to course correct here, or what.
It's kind of funny because that first draft of his I really liked the strategy as far as the forwards drafted - Mastrosimone, Phillips, Soderblom, Tyut. Even though the first two didn't work out, those are more of the kinds of forwards I would like to see us pick.