Prospect Info: 6 scouts sacked -Gare-MACGREGOR -Davis-Hawley-Samenko-Moores

[Jumptheshark]

will update the OP as information comes out

 

[Del Preston]

 

[ChaoticOrange]

^Stu hasn't been a 'magnificent *astard' for a long time now.

Yep. Sorry if you're director of amateur scouting for seven drafts and utterly fail to produce even average role players out of the first round, you deserve to get canned. Instead we were reduced to trading for guys like Hendricks and Klinkhammer.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Chia is a God. He really isn't messing around.

The man built a cup winner and contender for several years. You don't do that by bending over backwards to keep guys that aren't doing their jobs.

The greatest offseason ever continues.

 

[Jumptheshark]

moray gare's history

ASON TEAM LEAGUE ROLE ON TEAM NOTES 1986-1987 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1987-1988 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1988-1989 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1989-1990 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1990-1991 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1991-1992 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1992-1993 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1993-1994 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1994-1995 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1995-1996 Northern Michigan Univ. NCAAAsst. Coach 1996-1997 Estevan Bruins SJHLHead Coach 1997-1998 Cowichan Valley Capitals BCHLHead Coach Cowichan Valley Capitals BCHLAsst. General Manager 1998-1999 Hamilton Bulldogs AHLAsst. Coach 1999-2000 Hamilton Bulldogs AHLAsst. Coach 2000-2001 Hamilton Bulldogs AHLAsst. Coach 2001-2002 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2002-2003 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2003-2004 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2004-2005 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2005-2006 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2006-2007 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2007-2008 Edmonton Oilers NHLScout Pro Scout 2008-2009 Edmonton Oilers NHLDir. of Professional Scouting 2009-2010 Edmonton Oilers NHLDir. of Professional Scouting 2011-2012 Edmonton Oilers NHLDir. of Professional Scouting 2012-2013 Edmonton Oilers NHLDir. of Professional Scouting 2013-2014 Edmonton Oilers NHLDir. of Professional Scouting 2014-2015 Edmonton Oilers NHLDir. of Professional Scouting - See more at: http://www.eliteprospects.com/player.php?player=154984#sthash.x9uCiNZN.dpuf

 

[Del Preston]

Yep. Sorry if you're director of amateur scouting for seven drafts and utterly fail to produce even average role players out of the first round, you deserve to get canned. Instead we were reduced to trading for guys like Hendricks and Klinkhammer.

"[Gabriel Landeskog's] going to be a third-line player who could be a good second-line player." - Stu MacGregor


v haha, thanks.

 

[Jett Jagaar]

Still love this one.

Del, you are all kinds of awesome.

 

[Took a pill in Sbisa]

Thank god they god rid of their pro scouts.

I'm also not going to miss Stauffer's name dropping Stu as his old coach like 30 years ago

 

[Jett Jagaar]

Yep. Sorry if you're director of amateur scouting for seven drafts and utterly fail to produce even average role players out of the first round, you deserve to get canned. Instead we were reduced to trading for guys like Hendricks and Klinkhammer.

Well, Tobias Rieder turned out pretty good.

 

[Jumptheshark]

interesting that most war rooms are already up and running and the oilers do this. I think Chia-pet did not like how the reports were looking or something

 

[stratedge]

Thank god they god rid of their pro scouts.

I'm also not going to miss Stauffer's name dropping Stu as his old coach like 30 years ago

Head scouts, but this is step one. Before the start of next season, I expect new head scouts to start bringing in their own guys. When none of the pro scouts from the current team are left, I shall rejoice.

 

[OilTastic]

"[Gabriel Landeskog's] going to be a third-line player who could be a good second-line player." - Stu MacGregor

^you mean like Nuge is now, Stu?

 

[Spawn]

This wont be the only change Chiarelli makes to the management/scouting team. I imagine at some point in the next calendar year we'll see some guys from management let go too.

Does this mean we're done drafting overage BCHLers? Oh happy day

 

[McChucky]

interesting that most war rooms are already up and running and the oilers do this. I think Chia-pet did not like how the reports were looking or something

There was a hint before about looking in different places and using different methods for scouting. Foreshadowing I guess. I guess they weren't looking hard enough for Chia's liking.

 

[OilTastic]

Yep. Sorry if you're director of amateur scouting for seven drafts and utterly fail to produce even average role players out of the first round, you deserve to get canned. Instead we were reduced to trading for guys like Hendricks and Klinkhammer.

Well, Tobias Rieder turned out pretty good.

^i'll give him credit for that, and the fact that we have a few potential bottom end forwards and d-men coming up. but he's had since what 2008? when he was hired to find good 2nd, 3rd and 4th liners that can play for this team, and hasn't been able to do it. deserved to be gone sooner actually, as did the rest of them.

 

[Tarus]

This wont be the only change Chiarelli makes to the management/scouting team. I imagine at some point in the next calendar year we'll see some guys from management let go too.

Does this mean we're done drafting overage BCHLers? Oh happy day

Hopefully they are done drafting both BCHLers and overagers.

 

[Giggleplex]

Yep. Sorry if you're director of amateur scouting for seven drafts and utterly fail to produce even average role players out of the first round, you deserve to get canned. Instead we were reduced to trading for guys like Hendricks and Klinkhammer.

What about Anton Lander?

 

[OilTastic]

This wont be the only change Chiarelli makes to the management/scouting team. I imagine at some point in the next calendar year we'll see some guys from management let go too.

Does this mean we're done drafting overage BCHLers? Oh happy day

^oh gawd, Stu and his love of the BCHL !

 

[PuckPoise]

Tyler Dellow will be running the draft.

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Well, Tobias Rieder turned out pretty good.

Wait.



Though, Kessy looked halfway decent in the AHL until he got hurt. Might be an energy 4th liner if we're lucky.

 

[Del Preston]

Chia is a God. He really isn't messing around.

The OBC's idea of fixing the scouting was shuffling a couple people around.

Chiarelli cans four scouts after two months on the job.

 

[DreamTheatre]

Mixed emotions about Stu leaving. I always thought he was a good scout. That Jordan Eberle pick bought him a lot of time, but he hasn’t had a hit in a while. On the other hand, I’m very glad that the pro scouts are getting fired. They have missed a lot.

 

[Rafters]

Not a surprise once bob Green took over as director of player personal and head of all scouting...both have been a part of a decade of suck

 

[ChaoticOrange]

What about Anton Lander?

The blind squirrel found his nut? Even Lander looked more like a rock than a nut until last season.

For every minor success like Lander and Marincin, there's a Moroz, a Pitlick, a Marco Roy, a David Musil, and on and on. Far too many wasted picks, or trying to draft a specific role player. Absolutely no taking BPA when available.

I'd be willing to bet we'd have a better draft record after the first round if we taped player pictures to a dartboard, got MacT good a liquored, and let him throw.

 

[Jumptheshark]

For me i think that part of this is due to the lack of being able to scout D-men properly or goalies