3rd Annual Ranger Elimination Game

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Nash wasn't clutch last season and his PO was bad so I think it's right. Step deserves to be there 100%. Best skater in the regular season, second best in the playoff, our present and future 1C. McDonagh speaks for himself. Staal is a meh for me. I love the player but I'm not sure why he's still alive.

Staal is going win this thing of pity, that's why.
 
he like only scored in the 3rd period. thats pretty clutch

in the beginning yes but some of those 3rd period goals were useless: goal against Lindback, Vokukn, and a few other pointless goals. CBJ fans have been saying since the trade that Nash is great at scoring pointless goals because of presumably his ability and skill set to be able to take advantage of a less focused group of defenders/goalie.

Gabby had better PO with us than Nash did so......
 
Last edited:
Since I'm also entitled to a double vote.

Derek Stepan (6) + (2) + (2) = (10)
Ryan McDonagh (16)
Marc Staal (18) - (2) - (2) = (14)
 
Derek Stepan (12) +2= (14)
Ryan McDonagh (16) - 2= (14)
Marc Staal (12)

I want a DStep-McTruck Final!
Derek Stepan (14) +1= (15)
Ryan McDonagh (14) +1= (15)
Marc Staal (12)-2=(10)
tumblr_static_tumblr_mf5sibfq9v1rznl8do1_400.gif
 
Nash wasn't clutch last season and his PO was bad so I think it's right. Step deserves to be there 100%. Best skater in the regular season, second best in the playoff, our present and future 1C. McDonagh speaks for himself. Staal is a meh for me. I love the player but I'm not sure why he's still alive.

Agree with most of this. I think Step has the potential to be a very good thing for NYR, but I'm hesitant to say he is far and away guaranteed to be a 1C based on one great half season which also happened to be a contract year. If he replicates it this season, great, I'll buy in.

Don't agree with the idea that Gabby was better in the POs than Nash though. He was just along for the ride on a lot of his points in the ECF run. Nash absolutely needs to be better, but he actually made a lot of plays happen during the POs. Whereas unless Gabby was scoring (which he didn't do enough of), he was invisible - and yes I know Gabby was injured; don't care. Overall they were both bleh.

Derek Stepan (18)
Ryan McDonagh (16)
Marc Staal (6)

Derek Stepan (18) -2 = (16)
Ryan McDonagh (16) +2 = (18)
Marc Staal (6)
 
Derek Stepan (15) +1 (16)
Ryan McDonagh (15) +1 (16)
Marc Staal (10) -2 (8)

Derek Stepan (15) (+1) (16)
Ryan McDonagh (15) (+1) (16)
Marc Staal (10) (-2) (8)

Derek Stepan (18)
Ryan McDonagh (16)
Marc Staal *(6)

Derek Stepan (18) -2 = (16)
Ryan McDonagh (16) +2 = (18)
Marc Staal (6)

Editing because Off Sides and haomaru voted simultaneously
Derek Stepan (17)
Ryan McDonagh (19)
Marc Staal (4)
 
Stepan (9) -2 (7)
McDonagh (31) +2 (33)

Steps needs to sign... only then can he hope to make a comeback.

Someone should tweet him that if he signs a 3 year $9.6M ($3.2M AAV) contract he'll win the HFNYR player poll in a landslide. He'll sign it immediately for sure!!!
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad