Do you believe Manson to be the second pairing RD?
I think Malinski is firmly ahead of him on the depth chart.
IMO:
Toews - Makar
??? - Malinski
??? - Manson
In the playoffs, I play Manson ahead of Malinski every time.
Manson is built for the playoffs. Malinski's game hasn't shown that.
Regular season, Malinski can play higher in the depth chart if they want, but he needs to be sheltered more in the playoffs, so he doesn't get bad matchups.
They don't really need to do that with Manson, especially if he has a good partner. Manson's only issue is staying healthy.
On a contender, I want my entire top 4, including the 2nd pair, to be solid defensively.
They've tried the other route before pairing Girard with Manson, or Malsinski with Kulak, and it doesn't work, because with Girard and Malinski facing better players on the 2nd pair, they find ways to out muscle them, or exploit their flaws defensively, and their partner can't cover for them all the time.
I want this. They can swap Kulak for Gagne if they can't afford him, and then re-evaluate at the deadline.
Toews - Makar
XX - Manson
Kulak - Malinski