2025 Summer Transfer Rumors and Discussion Closed Window | Page 35 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League
Toggle sidebar

2025 Summer Transfer Rumors and Discussion Closed Window

JoVel said:
I don't get the deal with Cherki. He hasn't been reported as a 50M player, more like half of that. Feels to me that everyone should've been after him at that price, but reportedly there have only been some half-assed attempts by BVB and PSG.

Is he just that fat?
Click to expand...
He's not fat at all.
People have used the "character" word or "lazy" word which don't fit his behavior on the pitch at all.

I think Lyon has been a mess and some people had other interests in mind and hyped other players to start because of personnal interest. Lyon tried to push him out last summer for small numbers to get some money back but he refused to leave and even extended a year to make sure his childhood team gets some money out of it but after he had proven what he could do.
He was totally right and he exploded to MVP contender and Lyon will get at least 10m more out of it but he had an agreement for a 35M max fee. Smart move by him and the club (somewhat).

His only drawback is his lack of finishing skills. He's always been a passer first. Arguably one of the best passers in the world.
He does an adequate job on pressing and defensive coverage. He's no star in that department but he's not one to walk either.

Lyon is desparate for money but has an agreement for 35M with the player. He'll get to choose his next team. I hope he stays in L1 and signs with PSG.
 
Evilo said:
It really isn't.
Cherki has played well and lots of minutes since finally being out as the leader of the team.
Cherki is incredible and IMO not inferior to Wirtz down the line. He just needed a bit more time to explode.
Click to expand...
Trust me. I would not say no to Cherki
 
Incubajerks said:
Do you really think that Wirtz and Cherki are two equal players?
Click to expand...





Even if you are ignorant of Cherki, this season, there's a real argument they're equal. Cherki having some EL records over the X number of year in goal involvements and assists (can't remember if it's both or one of them) is another proof.
Wirtz was way more impressive than Cherki until this season, no doubt. Cherki this year? Few players IN EUROPE had a better year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheGreatPandasage
Evilo said:





Even if you are ignorant of Cherki, this season, there's a real argument they're equal. Cherki having some EL records over the X number of year in goal involvements and assists (can't remember if it's both or one of them) is another proof.
Wirtz was way more impressive than Cherki until this season, no doubt. Cherki this year? Few players IN EUROPE had a better year.
Click to expand...


Homer is not a matter of being ignorant, I wrote this on November 4th:

Cherki is a one-dimensional player, tell us about the boy's non-possession phase, because I personally saw him grazing on the pitch several times. In my opinion he is a good player, but I wouldn't be surprised if he goes to play in Arabia in 5 years. Technically he is super gifted, a beautiful shot, but there are some flags that are too scary. Let's see what he does, he could be a bargain at the right price, he's clearly not one to build around.


Still valid to this day, Let's see when and if he will come out of the L1 for a more structured championship and how he will behave.
 
Incubajerks said:
Homer is not a matter of being ignorant, I wrote this on November 4th:

Cherki is a one-dimensional player, tell us about the boy's non-possession phase, because I personally saw him grazing on the pitch several times. In my opinion he is a good player, but I wouldn't be surprised if he goes to play in Arabia in 5 years. Technically he is super gifted, a beautiful shot, but there are some flags that are too scary. Let's see what he does, he could be a bargain at the right price, he's clearly not one to build around.


Still valid to this day, Let's see when and if he will come out of the L1 for a more structured championship and how he will behave.
Click to expand...
Totally not valid.
How is there homerism since he's among the MVP finalists in L1, EL top assist man (record), etc...?

Or your "analysis" of him is simply dumb. Since you give "red flags" without naming them except "I saw him grazing on the pitch several times". Wow. Talk about "some red flags".
Since november, Cherki has established himself as one of the best young players in the game.
Sorry you didn't follow.

As for L1, your "bias" is well known, and L1 has really been rather strong overall in Europe this year. Again, our players have no trouble shining elsewhere when italian players usually suck outside their comfort zone.
I have zero fear of Cherki shining elsewhere. He will.
 
Last edited:
  • Haha
Reactions: Incubajerks
I'd love to hear your reasonning as to why season stats that all prove Cherki is equal to Wirtz this season don't matter because you felt he has some red flags you can't even define back in november.
 
Wirtz offers clearly more in terms of defensive help

Cherki:
1747738244762.png


Wirtz:
1747738285317.png
 
Evilo said:
They don't even play the same position. Moot point.
Click to expand...
Good thing these stats take into account all attacking midfielders or wingers. But if stats aren't your thing you can just watch the games, their hustle levels are completely opposite. They're not 100 mil away but Wirtz is the slightly better player overall.
 
luiginb said:
Good thing these stats take into account all attacking midfielders or wingers. But if stats aren't your thing you can just watch the games, their hustle levels are completely opposite. They're not 100 mil away but Wirtz is the slightly better player overall.
Click to expand...
I have no problem if you feel like Wirtz is "slightly" better overall. No issue here.
As for hustle, Cherki has hustle. He's also more creative than Wirtz. Lesser scorer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: luiginb
Evilo said:
I have no problem if you feel like Wirtz is "slightly" better overall. No issue here.
As for hustle, Cherki has hustle. He's also more creative than Wirtz. Lesser scorer.
Click to expand...
In reality your are banging on more promise and less certainty if you go with Cherki. While Wirtz is more of a certainty. However, is that worth the 100M not for me not at all.
 
Wirtz has a really strong press game which Slot wants in his 10. Can't say I've watched Cherki other than highlights but I doubt it's the same from everything I've heard...

Feels like the mentality of the two players are on different levels.

FWIW - "Vegas" odds are 2-1 Bayern and 4-1 Liverpool, which are a hell of a lot closer than anytime over the past week.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Total: 13 (members: 2, guests: 11)

    Latest posts

    Ad

    Ad

    Top Bottom