2025 NHL Draft: Lose a ton for Porter Martone

[Jargon]

Yep I feel the real contenders we will be battling for the 32/31 spot to guarantee a top 4 pick will be Chicago, Montreal (hopefully when Laine returns they will rise), maybe Columbus/Philly. But if Granlund does get traded, I think that would pretty much guarantee we get that top 4 pick at minimum.

That’s the thing. If we lose Granlund, I think the team will collapse on itself like a black hole. Unless Celebrini cements himself as a 1C by the deadline and Smith becomes a passable 2/3C by then, we’d be pretty certain to pick top 3.

 

[Juxtaposer]

So it's really interesting that Sens fans are finally turning on Brady Tkachuk for constantly cheating for offense, having zero defensive conscience, and overall not playing winning hockey. I've never really cared for him, especially compared to his brother whom I think extremely highly of.

I kinda worry that Martone is that kind of player. I can't shake the Brady Tkachuk comparison.

 

[Crewouse]

So it's really interesting that Sens fans are finally turning on Brady Tkachuk for constantly cheating for offense, having zero defensive conscience, and overall not playing winning hockey. I've never really cared for him, especially compared to his brother whom I think extremely highly of.

I kinda worry that Martone is that kind of player. I can't shake the Brady Tkachuk comparison.

Don't worry, I'm manifesting Schaefer

 

[wickedwitch]

So it's really interesting that Sens fans are finally turning on Brady Tkachuk for constantly cheating for offense, having zero defensive conscience, and overall not playing winning hockey. I've never really cared for him, especially compared to his brother whom I think extremely highly of.

I kinda worry that Martone is that kind of player. I can't shake the Brady Tkachuk comparison.

I'm a little leery of Martone at this point, with the caveat I haven't seen a ton of him. I'd have him 4th out of the top 4. But that aspect of his game is hard to judge, because I don't know to what extent he's getting coached to basically "cheat for offense." It will be useful to see him play at junior worlds where he almost certainly will not be getting instructed to cheat.

 

[Juxtaposer]

I'm a little leery of Martone at this point, with the caveat I haven't seen a ton of him. I'd have him 4th out of the top 4. But that aspect of his game is hard to judge, because I don't know to what extent he's getting coached to basically "cheat for offense." It will be useful to see him play at junior worlds where he almost certainly will not be getting instructed to cheat.

Yeah, I really hope he makes the WJC team so we can see him in a different role and environment. The CHL is not a league wildly concerned with defense.

 

[dmcccdmn]

Who do you think contributing the most to the Sharks' wins/points so far this season? Granlund? Toffoli? Celebrini? I say it's Granlund. I say we put Granlund in as goalie for the rest of the season or until he's traded. What say you?

 

[hotcabbagesoup]

Who do you think contributing the most to the Sharks' wins/points so far this season? Granlund? Toffoli? Celebrini? I say it's Granlund. I say we put Granlund in as goalie for the rest of the season or until he's traded. What say you?

I'm very superstitious so I think that I am the one who's contributing most to our success this season. Last season was the first season that I ever gave up watching the Sharks, around Game 28 or so and lo and behold, First overall pick. This season, I'm here and I'm present. I know I know you think it's ridiculous for thinking it's all me me me. But I don't suppose you think you're the reason for our success, right? That would be even more laughable.

 

[Star Platinum]

I'm very superstitious so I think that I am the one who's contributing most to our success this season. Last season was the first season that I ever gave up watching the Sharks, around Game 28 or so and lo and behold, First overall pick. This season, I'm here and I'm present. I know I know you think it's ridiculous for thinking it's all me me me. But I don't suppose you think you're the reason for our success, right? That would be even more laughable.

Well, we were struggling pretty badly until Celebrini got healthy, so even though I would say that many players have performed well since he got back, I think he probably deserves the most credit.

But I'm willing to give you the second most credit.

 

[wickedwitch]

Well, we were struggling pretty badly until Celebrini got healthy, so even though I would say that many players have performed well since he got back, I think he probably deserves the most credit.

But I'm willing to give you the second most credit.

They actually stopped struggling just before Celebrini got back. I think they had won 3 in a row before he returned.

I'm not trying to discredit Celebrini, but while he's the best player, he isn't carrying this team all alone.

 

[timorous me]

So it's really interesting that Sens fans are finally turning on Brady Tkachuk for constantly cheating for offense, having zero defensive conscience, and overall not playing winning hockey. I've never really cared for him, especially compared to his brother whom I think extremely highly of.

I kinda worry that Martone is that kind of player. I can't shake the Brady Tkachuk comparison.

My hope is that Celebrini is the type of leader who others love playing with and he won't allow any of them, at least his more youthful peers, to be passengers on his team.

 

[Friday]

Anyone for Misa yet? Seems like he's really taking off. Scott Wheeler had this little blurb on him -

"He’s also a very smart player who makes his linemates better with his playmaking, his vision and his ability to execute while tightly covered. He’s also willing to track pucks, stick with plays and compete (I’ve seen him sacrifice the body to block shots, etc.)."

Seems like a guy who would thrive on 71's wing

 

[coooldude]

Anyone for Misa yet? Seems like he's really taking off. Scott Wheeler had this little blurb on him -

"He’s also a very smart player who makes his linemates better with his playmaking, his vision and his ability to execute while tightly covered. He’s also willing to track pucks, stick with plays and compete (I’ve seen him sacrifice the body to block shots, etc.)."

Seems like a guy who would thrive on 71's wing

Or possibly center the second line.

 

[anthonyyy]

Gotta watch a lot more, but Misa and Schaefer are my guys this draft right now. Will Smith playing wing with Mack is the best version of him I've ever seen (even if the points haven't come yet) so I'm quite alright drafting another center and letting them fight it out for who plays 2C.

 

[Friday]

Or possibly center the second line.

Can't have too many centers and Ive never thought Smith would land as a true center

 

[sharski]

I feel like the sharks can't really miss as long as they draft top 4

Although right now I feel like Schaefer would fill the biggest need as I think the sharks need more D lottery tickets than forward lottery tickets

 

[Jargon]

Who do you think contributing the most to the Sharks' wins/points so far this season? Granlund? Toffoli? Celebrini? I say it's Granlund. I say we put Granlund in as goalie for the rest of the season or until he's traded. What say you?

I think it’s also Granlund but he might end up being a good goalie too.

 

[Juxtaposer]

I love how everyone is like "Will Smith looks better on Macklin Celebrini's wing than he did centering Barclay Goodrow and Luke Kunin! That definitely proves he's a wing and not a center!"

 

[coooldude]

I love how everyone is like "Will Smith looks better on Macklin Celebrini's wing than he did centering Barclay Goodrow and Luke Kunin! That definitely proves he's a wing and not a center!"

I'm not like that. I think he still looks lost at wing AND center in the NHL despite some exciting flashes.

I'd still like to see them break up the Lund line and put Granlund on his wing, or him on Granlund's, but regardless I'll remain on record saying I expect continued struggles from him this year, 25 points not out of the question and not too too concerning, and next year will be a far more important year to see him step up to, let's say, 40-45pts. Patience is a virtue.

 

[Friday]

I'm not like that. I think he still looks lost at wing AND center in the NHL despite some exciting flashes.

I'd still like to see them break up the Lund line and put Granlund on his wing, or him on Granlund's, but regardless I'll remain on record saying I expect continued struggles from him this year, 25 points not out of the question and not too too concerning, and next year will be a far more important year to see him step up to, let's say, 40-45pts. Patience is a virtue.

Lol its just me, Jux sees red every time I talk about Smith on the wing

 

[Juxtaposer]

Lol its just me, Jux sees red every time I talk about Smith on the wing

I promise, it's really nothing to do with you.

 

[Grinner]

As long as we can land a top 4 pick. We'll be in a great position. If Misa was a RH shot. He'd climb to a toss up with Martone for my #1 choice

 

[dmcccdmn]

As long as we can land a top 4 pick. We'll be in a great position. If Misa was a RH shot. He'd climb to a toss up with Martone for my #1 choice

The only teams that are guaranteed 4th overall pick or better are the worst and second worst teams. That's not happening this season.

 

[Grinner]

The only teams that are guaranteed 4th overall pick or better are the worst and second worst teams. That's not happening this season.

I'll wait and see
Just like everyone else

 

[Shark Finn]

The only teams that are guaranteed 4th overall pick or better are the worst and second worst teams. That's not happening this season.

A quarter of a season has passed. Not three quarters.

 

[coooldude]