HF Habs: 2024 NHL Draft Thread

Who do you want at #5?

  • Tij Iginla

    Votes: 209 49.5%
  • Cole Eiserman

    Votes: 14 3.3%
  • Berkly Catton

    Votes: 92 21.8%
  • Konsta Helenius

    Votes: 13 3.1%
  • Beckett Sennecke

    Votes: 75 17.8%
  • Zayne Parekh

    Votes: 19 4.5%

  • Total voters
    422
Status
Not open for further replies.

sheed36

Registered User
Jan 8, 2005
47,684
36,377
No Man's Land
MBN with a goal at the worlds. Realistically, iginla and sennecke will be gone if we want to trade back up to the 12-15 range. MBN would be my personal target at that spot. Love his game
I just can't see the Habs wanting to drop from #5 all the way down to the 12-15th range. I could see them maybe moving down to 7th, or maybe even 8th as the furthest, if a team right behind them is desperate to move up to grab a Dickinson or Buium before a team right ahead of them can.

Although moving down 2-3 spots also runs the risk of another team possibly trading up and taking the player you wanted before you so that's also something else to consider before possibly deciding to move down or not.

I'd rather stay at 5 and just take the player you really want there and not risk moving down and potentially missing out on your player.
 

Runner77

**********************************************
Sponsor
Jun 24, 2012
85,283
156,227
I just can't see the Habs wanting to drop from #5 all the way down to the 12-15th range. I could see them maybe moving down to 7th, or maybe even 8th as the furthest, if a team right behind them is desperate to move up to grab a Dickinson or Buium before a team right ahead of them can.

Although moving down 2-3 spots also runs the risk of another team possibly trading up and taking the player you wanted before you so that's also something else to consider before possibly deciding to move down or not.

I'd rather stay at 5 and just take the player you really want there and not risk moving down and potentially missing out on your player.
If Lindstrom and Demidov are off the table and the Habs were to move back, it better be worth it, otherwise they might lose out on Iginla.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sheed36

skidcells

Registered User
May 11, 2023
391
783
I just can't see the Habs wanting to drop from #5 all the way down to the 12-15th range. I could see them maybe moving down to 7th, or maybe even 8th as the furthest, if a team right behind them is desperate to move up to grab a Dickinson or Buium before a team right ahead of them can.

Although moving down 2-3 spots also runs the risk of another team possibly trading up and taking the player you wanted before you so that's also something else to consider before possibly deciding to move down or not.

I'd rather stay at 5 and just take the player you really want there and not risk moving down and potentially missing out on your player.
Sorry I meant trade up** we are not trading down lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: sheed36

sheed36

Registered User
Jan 8, 2005
47,684
36,377
No Man's Land
Listening to Preds scout Jean-Philippe Glaude who is an 11-year scout with the Preds, he states like many others have, that this draft, there is no consensus after the 1st pick (and sheds some light on Lindstrom and Iginla, among others).


Which makes Iginla a possibility, esp. if Demidov and Lindstrom are off the table at Pick 5.

Some attributes:

- serious, good work ethic
- explosive
- natural goal scorer
- good frame (6’, 186 lbs at age 17)
- disciplined
- has likely mental makeup to play in fishbowl market
- prepped by father in the off season, optimally trained, always looking to improve

I’ve seen him listed as a C/ LW. How comfortable is he as a C?
If both Demidov and Lindstrom are gone before 5 or it's deemed there may be some injury concerns with Lindstrom going forward (if he's still on the board @ 5) I'd just take Iginla at 5 and call it a day.

If Lindstrom as no injury concerns going forward though and is still there at 5 I'd likely take him. Like was mentioned in a post above, the Habs still have lots of work to do since there seems to be many scenarios which could play out during this draft and picking 5th OA.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bsl

Runner77

**********************************************
Sponsor
Jun 24, 2012
85,283
156,227
If both Demidov and Lindstrom are gone before 5 or it's deemed there may be some injury concerns with Lindstrom going forward (if he's still on the board @ 5) I'd just take Iginla at 5 and call it a day.

If Lindstrom as no injury concerns going forward though and is still there at 5 I'd likely take him. Like was mentioned in a post above, the Habs still have lots of work to do since there seems to be many scenarios which could play out during this draft and picking 5th OA.
I too prefer Lindstrom, he’s a power forward who can score but he’s also a center, which fills a need.
 

McGees

Registered User
Jun 15, 2016
13,732
27,272
Listened to the latest Athletic Pod with Peters, Wheeler, and Pronman.

Chicago - a race between Demidov & Levshunov, some have through Silayev, or Lindstrom or Dickinson into that mix. But colleague close to them is Demidov/Levshunov. Pronman thinks when all said is done it's the defenseman, but if you don't think its close then you'll take Demidov.

  1. More Wheeler is leaning more toward Demidov for them the more he's thought about it. Looking at NHL, the teams left are built through duos. So Bedard-Demidov can be that duo for them.
  2. All of Chicago's defenseman are left shot on their team and in their system which is why Silayev isn't the option for them.
  3. People around the league who would take Silayev at 2
  4. Fascinated about what Montreal does at 5 - Hughes vocal at desire at 5. Their mock had Lindstrom at 5. Think Montreal have a lot of work to do.
  5. Talked to scouts about Lindstrom, injury stuff is a concern, a lot talking about it, and that his medicals are important.
  6. Potential for a trade down, with the value of the defenseman, that it could be a lucrative situation for them.
  7. Thinks Anaheim's forward strength makes them unlikely to take a forward.
  8. Luchanko, Iginla, Wetsch and Beaudoin have helped their stock at the U18.
  9. Cole Hutson and EJ Emery on the USA side.
  10. Teddy Stiga improved his stock, he was a driver, pulling everyone into the fight, making that first big play. Little smaller, above average skater and skill, craft and creativity.
  11. Liam Greentree hurt his stock at the tournament. Comparison to Artur Kaliyev there. Not the best skaters, not the highest compete, score in junior, intelligent players. Wonder if Greentree goes into the late 1st round or early 2nd. Thinks of Quentin Musty as well.
  12. Cole Eiserman also hurt his stock at the tournament. Got the goals he needed to get the NTDP goal scoring record. When talking to scouts, he didn't look himself. There's growing concerns about his overall hockey sense in terms of if he's not impacting the game, does he compound that with other mistakes. The one on one skills aren't there, having trouble beating defenses, getting his shot through, all comes back to his hockey sense. Thinks he will get picked by lottery teams but more the back end of it. Tij Iginla, Catton, Helenius have vaulted themselves a fair amount passed him.
  13. Feels like Sennecke has joined that group as well ahead of Eiserman. Pronman very confident Sennecke will go ahead of Eiserman on draft day.
  14. Cole Beaudoin - Pronman had him in 21/22 area, might move him up a spot or two. Going to become an emerging consensus, think he will go 18-25 range. His game is likeable, high work ethic, a little bit of offense, going to become a pro center. Similar players in this draft - Stian Solberg in Norway, making people like him as he's mobile, physical, high motor and going to world championships. Jett Luchanko, compete is really strong and could go mid first now and he feels very confident he's going top 20 in this years draft.
  15. Scott expects 5/6 defenseman will go in the first 8-9 picks
  16. Teams always push defenseman above the forwards.
  17. Wingers who are 5'10-5'11 likely going to drop down a bit
  18. Beckett Sennecke - Don't think he will go top 5 but he's certainly entered the top 10 conversation. Sennecke's rise isn't only because of his playoffs. His size, his shot, the way he's bringing his game in the playoffs is enticing teams. Pronman if he did a mock he wouldnt go top 5 but he would go top 10.
  19. What's the gap between Lindstrom and Catton related to? With those two players, its the size that is a concern with Catton. Everything else in his game is really great. Iginla supposed to be the goal scorer but Catton had more goals than him. Catton does so much at a high level. Lindstrom is an elite athlete, he can fly, super physical. Scout: if you believe he has decent enough hockey sense, then he can be a star. If you don't think he's smart enough, then he's a 2nd liner or a fringey 1st liner. Pronman doesn't buy that they are significantly apart. Does think Lindstrom will go higher though.
  20. Who is the analytics darling of the draft? There are 2-3 names that come to mind, Zayne Parekh. Two kids over in Europe - Demidov is one, his analytics are off the charts. Liiga has been watered down, Helenius as well but he gets bonus marks from any sort of model as it hasn't accounted for the quality drop. Michael Brandsegg-Nygard as well is high on the analytics, was viewed more as a support player but the analytics show that he could have more offensive ability than people think.
  21. Chances of Demidov sliding to 5 to the Habs? It's not out of the question but it's unlikely. A lot of belief that he's a top 3 forward in the draft. Contract in Russia isn't long. If he signs an extension taht would make things scarier. Some interesting things that have learned from european scouts, that most of them feel the russian risk isn't as high with him especially with his representation with Gold Star. If Chicago takes Levshunov, then what does Anaheim do, does the run on defenseman start on 2/3/4? There's always a possibility but unlikely. Demidov hype train has fired back up after his playoffs. Pronman thinks there's opportunity for teams to talk their way out of him in 2/3/4
  22. Who will go way higher than the public thought? Sennecke, Beaudoin, Luchanko, Sam O'Reilly, Letourneau.
They don’t seem to think much of Habs D prospects.
 

Saundies

Fly On The Wall
Jun 8, 2012
3,294
4,826
NB, Canada
My levels draft day levels:

Defaults:

- A forward - HELL YEAH
- A D - Ugh, why?

Players:

Demidov - HELL YEAH + WE GOT DEMIDOV!!!!!
Lindstrom - HELL YEAH + Hell yeah
Young Iggy - HELL YEAH + Little Iggy is going to turn up in MTL
Eiserman - HELL YEAH + Bigger Caufield!
Sennecke - HELL YEAH + Okay let's see what this kid can do

Levshunov/Dickinson - Ugh, why? + I guess we're trading a D at some point.
Silyaev - Ugh, why? + Moar big man + Please become Chara
Biuim/Perekh - Ugh, why? + Cool name at least + At least they're offensive and dynamic
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rozz

dcyhabs

Registered User
May 30, 2008
4,456
2,678
Montreal
I'm pretty sure my reaction will be the same as for most of the picks the last couple of years "I guess I can understand the reasoning but I'm not sure it's a great pick." Most of the picks have turned out better than I expected.
 

WeThreeKings

Demidov is a HAB
Sep 19, 2006
95,548
106,933
Halifax
I didn’t get that from the posted summary. Do you remember what they said specifically?

He probably listened to it.. but essentially like Scott Wheeler still doesn't love Reinbacher (he's a Byron Bader cuck disciple so not surprised he doesn't like a D who defends and doesn't dipsy doodle around the ice like an asshole) and Pronman was just of the mind that you aren't sure that any of Montreal's defenseman are so good that you can't consider any of the D at the top

The Habs brass feel differently though, Hughes comments indicate that and I agree with the Habs brass more than Scott Can't Wheelher.
 

vokiel

#DanzeMolsonMix
Jan 31, 2007
18,666
4,239
Montréal
If Chicago picks Lev, does CLB pick Demidov? I think so.

I think we have a legit chance of Lindstrom to us.
I was thinking... If Columbus is looking for goal scoring, they could pick Eiserman and cause somewhat of a surprise for MacKenzie's readers.
 

DAChampion

Registered User
May 28, 2011
30,203
21,650
Demidov
Iginla
Lindstrom
Catton
Sennecke
Buium
Levshunov

I'll be happy with any of these. Literally impossible to f*** up unless they pass on Demidov, kinda like last year.

You'd be mad about Dickinson or Eiserman?
 

SOLR

Registered User
Jun 4, 2006
13,250
6,808
Toronto / North York
He probably listened to it.. but essentially like Scott Wheeler still doesn't love Reinbacher (he's a Byron Bader cuck disciple so not surprised he doesn't like a D who defends and doesn't dipsy doodle around the ice like an asshole) and Pronman was just of the mind that you aren't sure that any of Montreal's defenseman are so good that you can't consider any of the D at the top

The Habs brass feel differently though, Hughes comments indicate that and I agree with the Habs brass more than Scott Can't Wheelher.

Hilarious thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: WeThreeKings

DramaticGloveSave

Voice of Reason
Apr 17, 2017
14,816
13,739
Everyone has a plan until you get punched in the face!

We'll see how we feel when one of Caufield, Dach, or Guhle goes down for months early in the season.

For me, I don't see this team getting much better unless they actually try to get better this offseason. If they add at least 1 top-6 W and a Vet RHD they should be in decent shape, if they add 2 top-6 W we should be in really good shape.

If we don't add anything it is almost guaranteed to be another top-10 pick
We’re adding Dach, Hutson, maybe Monahan again… Monty and Primeau more established, Slaf and the top line for a full season. If we aren’t pushing for a playoff spot I’ll be very disappointed.
 

WeThreeKings

Demidov is a HAB
Sep 19, 2006
95,548
106,933
Halifax
I was thinking... If Columbus is looking for goal scoring, they could pick Eiserman and cause somewhat of a surprise for MacKenzie's readers.

Eiserman will surprise people.. with how low he goes.

Scouts have soured big time on him and it doesn't seem like he's got any top 7 love anymore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad