Beauterham
Registered User
- Aug 19, 2018
- 1,718
- 1,557
Pre-Game Talk: 2024 Draft Thread
- Thread starter TK 421
- Start date
- Status
- Jul 4, 2014
- 8,057
- 8,666
Really not a fan of Brandsegg-Nygard from what I saw of him at the U-20, so seeing him at 16 in any mock is concerning to me. I just didn't see anything about his game that gave me confidence that he would ever make it to the NHL.
From what I've read from other posters (thanks, by the way, to everyone who has contributed to the discussion) if we keep the pick, I'd much rather reach for one of the centers like Hage or Boisvert, even if we don't see them as centers at the NHL level. I really don't want anything to do with any of the defensemen projected in our range either.
Personally, I'd love to see an opportunity to package our first (given that it is almost certainly going to be in the 15-18 range with 16 being the most likely) for an ascending young defenseman with a couple of years of team control and is in the NHL or expected to be NHL ready by 2025-2026. Braden Schneider is an example of a guy I would be targeting with that pick (obviously with a +) if the Rags decided they couldn't keep both him and Lindgren.
From what I've read from other posters (thanks, by the way, to everyone who has contributed to the discussion) if we keep the pick, I'd much rather reach for one of the centers like Hage or Boisvert, even if we don't see them as centers at the NHL level. I really don't want anything to do with any of the defensemen projected in our range either.
Personally, I'd love to see an opportunity to package our first (given that it is almost certainly going to be in the 15-18 range with 16 being the most likely) for an ascending young defenseman with a couple of years of team control and is in the NHL or expected to be NHL ready by 2025-2026. Braden Schneider is an example of a guy I would be targeting with that pick (obviously with a +) if the Rags decided they couldn't keep both him and Lindgren.
Memento
Future Authoress.
I have to imagine that Buchnevich (and maybe Faulk/Krug) is dealt during the draft. I know it's controversial, but I want to get as much as I can for him.
Here are my updated rankings. Some really nice wingers should be on board when we pick. Whether there will be a center or defenseman worth the pick is unclear. Feel like there is reasonable chance that Hage or Boisvert are there, even if there isn't a worthy d. Eager to see how the d look at u18s, particularly Freij.
- Celebrini
- Demidov
- Dickinson
- Levshunov
- Silayev
- Helenius
- Lindstrom
- Buium
- Eiserman
- Catton
- Iginla
- Parekh
- Hage
- Greentree
- Yakemchuk
- Boisvert
- Sennecke
- Brandsegg-Nygard
- Chernyshov
- Freij
- Hemming
- Emery
- Surin
- Elick
- Luchenko
- Jiricek
- Parascak
- Mews
- Stiga
- Gill
- Connelly
- Miettinen
- Badinka
- Pulkkinen
- Basha
- O’Reilly
- Stolberg
- Fischer
- Kleber
- Masse
- Brunicke
- Artamonov
- Bednarik
- T Smith
- Beaudoin
- Petterson
- Vanacker
- Ritchie
- Gridin
- LSW
the guys you have 13-16 is who i’ve been researching. Yakemchuk, the one thing i like is several reports say he’s “ mean” and boy we could use that. appreciate all the info you guys bring
the guys you have 13-16 is who i’ve been researching. Yakemchuk, the one thing i like is several reports say he’s “ mean” and boy we could use that. appreciate all the info you guys bring
does yakemchuk have top 4 potential?
He has the size and offensive skills to be 1D. His skating isn’t great and his defensive game is a mess. If he can clean those up he couid be stud. If not, he could still be top 4 guy but one who gives away as much as he creates. Dion Phaneuf has been mentioned as comp, and I don’t know if that is good or bad outcome but I think that is kinda the point.
Memento
Future Authoress.
Honestly looking at John Mustard and Aatos Koivu for one of our second-round picks, even with our need for defensemen.
Mustard is a left wing, but I love his skating, goal-scoring (really good sniper in the USHL; yeah, I'd go USHL with my draft board with Hage and Mustard.), he has good size (6'0" 185 lbs. already), and he's one of the youngest players in this class (won't turn eighteen until August). Really love this kid, and he's rated around where our first second-round pick is.
Koivu is a 200-foot playmaker who will stay at center. He plays a very mature game like his dad (Saku), has eyes all around him like Argus of the Greek myths; really sees the play around him and makes smart plays with the puck, hesitant to shoot but has a very decent shot. Reminds me of Thomas-lite. Possibly could be had with an early third, but I don't even want to risk it; he's going to be a riser.
Mustard is a left wing, but I love his skating, goal-scoring (really good sniper in the USHL; yeah, I'd go USHL with my draft board with Hage and Mustard.), he has good size (6'0" 185 lbs. already), and he's one of the youngest players in this class (won't turn eighteen until August). Really love this kid, and he's rated around where our first second-round pick is.
Koivu is a 200-foot playmaker who will stay at center. He plays a very mature game like his dad (Saku), has eyes all around him like Argus of the Greek myths; really sees the play around him and makes smart plays with the puck, hesitant to shoot but has a very decent shot. Reminds me of Thomas-lite. Possibly could be had with an early third, but I don't even want to risk it; he's going to be a riser.
Last edited:
- Feb 12, 2008
- 19,919
- 9,453
I want a couple mean mofo’s who play a 2 way game with our 2nds. I want some more toughness in the lineup.
we have drafted guys like that recently, just not ready yet. loof, mayich, burns all have mean streak on back end, while peterson, stenberg, pekarcik, and stancl ain't gonna back down from anyone up front. we have pretty nice mix of skill and snarl on the way. need some of the higher skilled guys (dvo and bolduc and lindstein and buchinger, for example) to really hit (or this year's picks could do it too) to give us all of what we need, but our prospect pool is coming along quite nicely. just need to be patient.
bleedblue1223
Registered User
- Jan 21, 2011
- 52,919
- 16,361
And really one of the lessons to learn if Yakemchuk does hit his potential and becomes of Phaneuf or to use a current player, maybe an Evan Bouchard, it's important not to see the offensive numbers, minutes played, and their size and then force them into a #1 D role. Those players are designed to play heavy minutes, but heavy offensive minutes, and have another pair carry the defensive load. That's one of the reasons Phaneuf's reputation went bad because Toronto didn't use him properly.
Yes. He struggled early this year playing against men, and then got hurt missing key development time. He is inconsistent too, showing flashes of brilliance and then complete brain fart. None of which means he can't live up to his potential, which is immense, but the risk with him is I think high. I get David Rundberg vibes with him. So all that went into putting him lower than many have him.
I'm going to divide mine differently. I have them in six different categories but haven't sorted them to a rank yet. I have them in right shot and left shot divided. Then Centers, wingers, and d separate
| Helenius, Konsta | 1 |
| Hage, Michael | 2 |
| Letourneau, Dean | 3 |
| Marques, Miguel | 4 |
| Zether, Simon | 5 |
| O'Reilly, Sam | 6 |
| Romani, Anthony | 7 |
| Koivu, Aatos | 8 |
| Svensson, Joel | 9 |
| Maistrenko, Oleg | 10 |
| Humphreys, Christian | 11 |
| Patterson, Riley | 12 |
| Celebrini, Macklin | 1 |
| Lindstrom, Caden | 2 |
| Catton, Berkly | 3 |
| Boisvert, Sasha | 4 |
| Pettersson, Lucas | 5 |
| Misa, Luke | 6 |
| Surin, Yegor | 7 |
| Ericksson, Linus | 8 |
| Mustard, John | 9 |
| Vuollet, Oskar | 10 |
| Miettinen, Julius | 11 |
| Beaudoin, Cole | 12 |
| Howe, Tanner | 13 |
| Villeneuve, Nathan | 14 |
| Boilard, Raoul | 15 |
| Bednarik, Kamil | 16 |
| Sjodin, Svante | 17 |
| Sikora, Petr | 18 |
| Demidov, Ivan | 1 |
| iginla, Tij | 2 |
| Greentree, Liam | 3 |
| Eiserman, Cole | 4 |
| Connelly, Trevor | 5 |
| Artamonov, Nikita | 6 |
| Vanacker, Marek | 7 |
| Basha, Andrew | 8 |
| Gridin, Matvei | 9 |
| Battaglia, Jacob | 10 |
| Berglund, Jack | 11 |
| Sterner, Karl | 12 |
| josephson, Ollie | 13 |
| Caswell, Clarke | 14 |
| He, Kevin | 15 |
| Fisher, Jake | 16 |
| Kos, Ondrej | 17 |
| Stiga, Teddy | 18 |
| Mateiko, Eriks | 19 |
| Moore, Javon | 20 |
| Brandsegg-Nygard, Michael | 1 |
| Sennecke, Beckett | 2 |
| Chernyshov, Igor | 3 |
| Parascak, Terik | 4 |
| Luchanko, Jett | 5 |
| Ritchie, Ryder | 6 |
| Hemming, Emil | 7 |
| Wetsch, Carson | 8 |
| Traff, Herman | 9 |
| Masse, Maxim | 10 |
| Fernstrom, Melvin | 11 |
| Pikkarainen, Kasper | 12 |
| Pridham, Jack | 13 |
| Ziemer, Brodie | 14 |
| Burrows, Hagen | 15 |
| Danielsson, Liam | 16 |
| Jecho, Adam | 17 |
| Procyszyn, Ethan | 18 |
| Dickinson, Sam | 1 |
| Buium, Zeev | 2 |
| Silayev, Anton | 3 |
| Freij, Alfons | 4 |
| Pulkkinen, Jesse | 5 |
| Shuravin, Matvei | 6 |
| Sahlin Wallenius, Leo | 7 |
| Fischer, Lukas | 8 |
| Smith, Tarin | 9 |
| Skahan, Will | 10 |
| Fransen, Noel | 11 |
| Solberg, Stian | 12 |
| Ustinkov, Daniil | 13 |
| Kol, Timur | 14 |
| Ralph, Colin | 15 |
| Sjoqvist, Gustav | 16 |
| Shokhrin, Roman | 17 |
| Ashton, Luke | 18 |
| Vaisenan, Veeti | 19 |
| Muggli, Leon | 20 |
| Fibigr, Jakub | 21 |
| Uljanskis, Darels | 22 |
| Burger, Eric | 23 |
| Gustafsson, Viggo | 24 |
| Nykyri, Niklas | 25 |
| Levshunov, Artyom | 1 |
| Parekh, Zayne | 2 |
| Yakemchuk, Carter | 3 |
| Badinka, Dominik | 4 |
| Jiricek, Adam | 5 |
| Elick, Charlie | 5 |
| Emery, EJ | 6 |
| Roberts, colton | 7 |
| Marrelli, Luca | 8 |
| Brunicke, Harrison | 9 |
| Gill, Spencer | 10 |
| Danford, Ben | 11 |
| Kleber, Adam | 12 |
| Mews, Henry | 13 |
| Soini, Sebastian | 14 |
| Rep, Ozbej | 15 |
| Bodin, Jack | 16 |
| Alcos, Parker | 17 |
| Pitner, Tory | 18 |
| Von Richter, Parker | 19 |
| McIsaac, William | 20 |
LGB
Registered User
- Feb 4, 2019
- 2,249
- 2,347
I've watched some of Boisvert and Hage recently and right now I'd take Boisvert. Hage has nice tools, but I think Boisvert has a significant edge in hockey sense and physical skills. Will need to watch more of these guys still to fully evaluate. Would be interested in others thoughts on these two as they are both USHL centers so should be a pretty straightforward comparison.
My only problem with Boisvert is he’s an average skater at the USHL level. If he can improve in college, then yes he may have him. Hage is already above average on tools, but smaller overall. Sacha’s shooting tools are better and better using his backhand. Like you said his vision is very good.
LGB
Registered User
- Feb 4, 2019
- 2,249
- 2,347
The skating isn't a strength, but I don't see it as a big hinderance for him either. His top speed is pretty good and he has the size and skill to make it difficult to check him even if a player can outskate him.
Ferrari came out with the new ranking today and central scouting is supposed to come out tomorrow as their final.
Beauterham
Registered User
- Aug 19, 2018
- 1,718
- 1,557
Wait, Central Scouting isn't even waiting before the U18-tournament has even been played?
Ferrari's ranking he released today are wild. Huge discrepancy from most of the others. Doesn't mean he is wrong, but he projects some guys available for us (Helenius, Parekh, Yak, and Eiserman, along with both the USHL centers) that I wouldn't otherwise expect to all be there and would be quite interesting options to consider.
- Status
Ad
Latest posts
-
-
GDT: Game #17: Vegas vs Utah HC - 7:00pm MST - Utah16, Arizona61- Latest: Arizonatah Coyetis
-
GDT: Preds @ South Edmonton 11/15/24 8PM Hey Theres Another Game Tonight Edition- Latest: Bringer of Jollity
-
