To me that is just too much to be explained away by scouting. They might have made a reach or two in that time, but for the most part, top-10 picks are easily identifiable and agreed upon by everyone.
There has to be something within the organization to explain how so many highly touted players’ development is stifled until they leave and break out elsewhere. Whether it’s coaching, culture, inertia, outright bad luck, whatever.
Just following on this thread of thought, here are the Sabres’ draft picks in the top 50 since 2012, noting their draft placement and including their career NHL games in parentheses:
1 Rasmus Dahlin (461)
1 Owen Power (194)
2 Jack Eichel (570)
2 Sam Reinhart (727)
7 Dylan Cozens (311)
8 Alex Nylander (126)
8 Casey Mittelstadt (389)
8 Jack Quinn (129)
8 Rasmus Ristolainen (744)
9 Matthew Savoie (1)
12 Mikhail Grigorenko (249)
13 Zach Benson (96)
14 Zemgus Girgensons (716)
14 Konsta Helenius
14 Isak Rosen (8)
16 Noah Ostlund
16 Nikita Zadorov (674)
28 Jiri Kulich (22)
31 Ryan Johnson (44)
31 Brendan Lemieux (307)
32 Mattias Samuelsson (166)
33 Rasmus Asplund (183)
33 Prokhor Poltapov
34 JJ Peterka (190)
35 JT Compher (529)
37 Marcus Davidsson
38 Connor Hurley
39 Anton Wahlberg
41 Topias Lehnonen
42 Adam Kleber
44 Eric Cornel
44 Jake McCabe (603)
45 Maxim Strbak
49 Vaclav Karabacek
Bolded players are still on the roster.
I know the draft gets dicey outside the top-10 or so, that the likelihood of a “hit” falls off fast and becomes almost random. But beyond their 1OA and 2OA picks, that’s a remarkable dearth of quality NHL seasons resulting from over a decade of drafting. They got that one 30-goal year from Cozens, and otherwise it’s is just a bunch of generic roster filler and trade bait/journeymen.
Can we move whatever this stupidity is to some other thread?
A thread other than the one where we discuss other NHL teams?