Lets put it this way, if the Penguins did the same to Drew O'Connor after scoring 5 goals 46 games in 2022-23, you'd never see the progression he made to score 16 goals this year, because according to Sullivan in this situation - scoring just 6 goals across 78 games is not enough out of him, but you know what, he got a shot anyway, more than Val. To give that opportunity to more outside players than players from within that are showing that potential is ridiculous, especially for a team that should get younger sure, but also should be giving opportunities to players like Puustinen that they've drafted and developed, spent time and money into and then suddenly discard the moment a veteran with some draft pedigree that's failed to live up to it, is brought in.
The irony if Drew getting more rope is that he got 10 games, then 22, and then 46 and was still given opportunities. Across 32 games, he put up 3 goals, then across 46 games in a season he put up 5, then finally in his 4th season he was able to produce 16 goals while getting a lot of top 6 minutes. This progression, is absolutely fine, you expect to see that. But then when it's only this one player that gets this benefit, it's bizarre.
Puustinen got 1 game, wasn't called up for an entire season, then was up for 52 games. On average, his ice time was lower than Noel Acciari and just barely more than Matthew Phillips, a waiver pick-up that was absolutely useless and has scored literally 1 goal in his entire NHL career. The coach seemingly wants to give everyone a better shot than Puustinen and it's bizarre. His scouting on Puustinen was also insanely off.
He claimed Puustinen wasn't quick enough - He was.
He claimed Puustinen's defensive game wasn't there yet - Yet he was better defensively than most of the Pens forwards.
HIs P/60 puts him in a top 6 winger company. So to see a player do all of that and suddenly needs to "earn it" over players that appear to not need to, is pretty shitty. Like I said, all I hoped for is for them to at least give Puustinen the same opportunities they gave Drew, because if they treated Drew the way they treat Val, you'd never see Doc progress into what he did last season, albeit with a ton of opportunity to do it and he frankly should have produced more given that. But the leap from 11pts in 46 games to 33 in 79 is a decent jump even with heavier top 6 minutes.
The comparison here is Drew's 2022-23 season to Puustinen's 2023-24 season and determining if either deserves another longer look - Drew did and he thrived, Puustinen produced more in his 40+ game stint and suddenly deserves less opportunity.