le_sean
Registered User
- Oct 21, 2006
- 42,021
- 45,176
Dvorsky is one that comes to mind that is similar. Both bigger centres, solid defensively, mostly contribute on the PP, need to work on skating. I do prefer Dvorsky though.
2023 NHL Entry Draft
- Thread starter montreal
- Start date
- Status
I hate these posts. I get kind of jokingly complaining about moving up in the standings but to be so pissed about it with 20 games left and automatically concluding that we will pass all these teams is ridiculous.
It’s just such an emotional/reactive take.
Then, we lose 2-3 in a row and it’s all positive again. We are going to end up 5-8. Get used to that idea.
Blame the referee
Registered User
Don’t know Jason Bukala, but great list buddy
Sportsnet's 2023 NHL Draft Prospect Rankings: February Edition
In his latest draft rankings, Sam Cosentino starts with a familiar name on top, but there continues to be plenty of movement through the rest of the top 32.www.sportsnet.ca
Scout's Analysis: Top 40 prospects in 2023 and how to build a draft list
Jason Bukala presents his first draft list of the season, a top 40 ranking of players he's scouted, and explains how scouts develop and refine their lists through a season.
Habs RHD prospects depth after Barron: Mailloux, Sobolev, Henrikson, Kostenko, Tourigny.
Sobolev/Henrikson's rights expire this year and aren't that good.
Kostenko isn't that good either.
Mailloux has to be cleared by the NHL to play and his dzone play is so bad that he might not translate to the NHL.
Tourigny is 5'8''.
Savard/Kovac/Wideman are stop gap until prospects take their places, which is currently Barron.
And I'm not saying to not take a forward with the first round picks (go BPA), I'm saying it's wrong to say that high end forwards is the Habs's biggest need. It's not, they have bigger holes elsewhere that will stop them from being a contender on the long term.
Schooner Guy
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2006
- 13,908
- 13,970
He used to be a scout with Florida. He was on the main panel on ESPN/Sportsnet during Round 1 of the draft last summer. He was very good! Much better than Cosentino.
Blame the referee
Registered User
Just use on that list, he seems way better yes!! Thanks
malton
Registered User
- Feb 17, 2009
- 1,922
- 553
RHD is a major need. Next draft there are a ton of high end guys available. Maybe we grab one with Florida's pick as well.
26Mats
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2018
- 33,383
- 25,771
Imo, RHD is much more of a need than LD, but not as much of a need as Goalie, wing and maybe even 1c.
Mailloux, Barron, Kovacevic could potentially man the right side for the next 10 years. And we have too many LD's, some of whom could play the right side - but can't play forward or in goal (Guhle, Xhekaj, Matheson, Harris, Hutson, Engstrom, Struble, Trudeau, Norlinder, Fairbrother, Beaudin).
And Guhle will be back at some point.
I think now is the time to trade Savard. His value will likely never be higher, and he won't be here when it's time to contend. Matheson and Edmundson can play the big brother roles.
Last edited:
Playmaker09
Registered User
- Sep 11, 2008
- 3,531
- 1,823
RHD should be addressed via trade.
If you try to draft a core defenseman next year, when are they going to be ready to play that role? 2029?
Yes unicorns like Makar/Doughty exist, but you're typically looking at ages 22-24 for defensemen to break out.
Team_Spirit
95% Elliotte
- Jul 3, 2002
- 39,750
- 21,992
Yes it's not even close.
5 1st have been traded so far, 2 of them last year. (TB, FLA)
Last year 13 1st pick were traded iirc
le_sean
Registered User
- Oct 21, 2006
- 42,021
- 45,176
Well then we can agree to disagree. I see an organization that is completely inept offensively. They’ve been this way for over 20 years. Four players have hit 70+ points in the last 15 seasons. Only one has hit over 80 points in the last 25 seasons. That is f***ing pathetic. There is no one on the team now that looks to be an 80 point player. There are 34 NHL players that hit that mark last year. The biggest issue is offence and it’s not particularly close.
malton
Registered User
- Feb 17, 2009
- 1,922
- 553
I don't think we're competing until 2026 anyways. you could hope that a player drafted next year breaks the lineup within 2 years, however you're right on the trade front. Acquire a RD via trade that will bridge the gap to whoever you draft this season or next.
DiglettDangles
Registered User
The NHL Tankathon site has updated their mock draft rankings and tbh it makes quite a bit of sense.
From memory -
Notable risers: Reinbacher (not enough?), Cristall, Wood, Brindley, Simashev.
Notable fallers: Barlow, Yager, Stramel, Dower Nilsson.
It has us picking Hrabal (G) in the 2nd which is defendable, although Bjarnason and a few other likeable options are still available: Bonk, Strbak, Brzustewicz.
Seeing this ranking makes me think I'd still be pretty happy if HuGo managed to get an extra 2nd rounder instead of the desired 1st.
www.tankathon.com
From memory -
Notable risers: Reinbacher (not enough?), Cristall, Wood, Brindley, Simashev.
Notable fallers: Barlow, Yager, Stramel, Dower Nilsson.
It has us picking Hrabal (G) in the 2nd which is defendable, although Bjarnason and a few other likeable options are still available: Bonk, Strbak, Brzustewicz.
Seeing this ranking makes me think I'd still be pretty happy if HuGo managed to get an extra 2nd rounder instead of the desired 1st.
2025 NHL Mock Draft with Lottery Simulator | Tankathon
2025 NHL Mock Draft with lottery simulator to see where the top NHL prospects could be drafted. Order updated after every game. Some team needs are factored into each draft simulation result
le_sean
Registered User
- Oct 21, 2006
- 42,021
- 45,176
Simashev is intriguing. I haven’t watched him but the young advanced analytical online scouts absolutely love him. However, we know the NHL. GMs will have Reinbacher really high, higher than online lists.
WeThreeKings
Demidov is a HAB
Another LHD plus Russian. I've barely watched him. Don't feel like we would ever end up with him
On my first try:The NHL Tankathon site has updated their mock draft rankings and tbh it makes quite a bit of sense.
From memory -
Notable risers: Reinbacher (not enough?), Cristall, Wood, Brindley, Simashev.
Notable fallers: Barlow, Yager, Stramel, Dower Nilsson.
It has us picking Hrabal (G) in the 2nd which is defendable, although Bjarnason and a few other likeable options are still available: Bonk, Strbak, Brzustewicz.
Seeing this ranking makes me think I'd still be pretty happy if HuGo managed to get an extra 2nd rounder instead of the desired 1st.
2025 NHL Mock Draft with Lottery Simulator | Tankathon
2025 NHL Mock Draft with lottery simulator to see where the top NHL prospects could be drafted. Order updated after every game. Some team needs are factored into each draft simulation result
Adam Fantilli with Florida first round pick (lol)
Our first round pick going from #7 to 9: Dvorsky
I can live with that.
2025 NHL Mock Draft with Lottery Simulator | Tankathon
2025 NHL Mock Draft with lottery simulator to see where the top NHL prospects could be drafted. Order updated after every game. Some team needs are factored into each draft simulation result
Mrb1p
PRICERSTOPDAPUCK
Hrabal is nice, but if we pass on a skater like Brzustewicz or a guy like Strbak for any goaltender Id be really, really mad. Brz is just a very projectable player and the upside is present.The NHL Tankathon site has updated their mock draft rankings and tbh it makes quite a bit of sense.
From memory -
Notable risers: Reinbacher (not enough?), Cristall, Wood, Brindley, Simashev.
Notable fallers: Barlow, Yager, Stramel, Dower Nilsson.
It has us picking Hrabal (G) in the 2nd which is defendable, although Bjarnason and a few other likeable options are still available: Bonk, Strbak, Brzustewicz.
Seeing this ranking makes me think I'd still be pretty happy if HuGo managed to get an extra 2nd rounder instead of the desired 1st.
2025 NHL Mock Draft with Lottery Simulator | Tankathon
2025 NHL Mock Draft with lottery simulator to see where the top NHL prospects could be drafted. Order updated after every game. Some team needs are factored into each draft simulation result
Happy to see some love for Brz. I thought he was great the times I saw him play this year and you are bang on... So projectable
Happy to see some love for Brz. I thought he was great the times I saw him play this year and you are bang on... So projectable
Ran it onceOn my first try:
Adam Fantilli with Florida first round pick (lol)
Our first round pick going from #7 to 9: Dvorsky
I can live with that.
2025 NHL Mock Draft with Lottery Simulator | Tankathon
2025 NHL Mock Draft with lottery simulator to see where the top NHL prospects could be drafted. Order updated after every game. Some team needs are factored into each draft simulation result
We ended up with Bedard and Yager, quite the haul
GlassesJacketShirt
Registered User
Simashev will likely drop as a Russian. Michkov is the unique player due to his upside, but other Russians will likely be hurt by their national status.
I'd consider Simashev with the Florida pick any day of the week, for the record. 10th overall on my list, rock solid defender who can skate and handle the puck.
Put him on a separate pair from Guhle and you got two future plus d-men who can munch minutes like crazy.
MasterMatt25
Registered User
If we could snag a RD with Florida's pick like Sandin Pellikka or Reinbacher I'd be very content
Vachon23
Registered User
He wasn’t just a scout
He was the Director of scouting for Florida and a 14 yrs scout (5 with NSH and 9 yrs with FLA). Let say he brings a lot of credibility and he was a good one, I would even take him in our amateur scouting staff
- Aug 21, 2016
- 10,239
- 13,525
Just finished watching honzek's last game and I must say Im impressed, he is really tall and uses a long stick displaying his fantatics hands combined to good skating and hard work, what allows him to cover a large part of the ice, retrieving pucks, blocking passing lanes ect. Kid plays smarts and usually makes the right plays, goes in the dirty areas and competes hard for pucks. Kid was listed at 6'1 165 lbs in the import draft about 9 months ago and is now listed at 6'3 186 lbs, what is an impressive spurt growth. He still looks green physically, but there is a good chance he ends up at 200 + lbs when he reaches the NHL. I really like the upside here, once he gains more strength, he will be hard to stop.
Here is an interesting quote from the commentator on Honzek during the game:
"One of the things scouts kind of feel so much about him, he is one of those rare players that has even more talent than you even see. He is just touching the imagination of what kind of skills he really possesses and what he is going to show up in 3-5 yrs from now."
I share the same reasoning, what kid is showing right now is only the tip of the iceberg. He probably ends up top 10 in my final ranking.
Here is an interesting quote from the commentator on Honzek during the game:
"One of the things scouts kind of feel so much about him, he is one of those rare players that has even more talent than you even see. He is just touching the imagination of what kind of skills he really possesses and what he is going to show up in 3-5 yrs from now."
I share the same reasoning, what kid is showing right now is only the tip of the iceberg. He probably ends up top 10 in my final ranking.
Last edited:
Gravity
Generational Poster
I think we draft Bjarnasson with a 3rd 1st or early 2nd round. Reinbacher with Florida's pick. Our pick is a mystery box but hoping elite C. Walk out of the draft with a stud 1C, potential 1D and 1G.
Last edited:
- Status
