2023-24 Hart Memorial Trophy finalists: Nikita Kucherov, Nathan MacKinnon, Connor McDavid | Winner: Nathan MacKinnon
- Thread starter Koivu11
- Start date
- Jun 17, 2009
- 10,426
- 6,582
It was obvious MacKinnon was going to win it, and he deserves it.
Dead Coyote
Registered User
- Oct 10, 2017
- 2,802
- 3,355
Bizarre that Matthews and Panarin both had more 1st place votes than McDavid. Honestly think it should have been Kucherov's but definitely can't be sad about Mackinnon. Feel like these awards should have something that included playoffs or just be changed to include playoffs, because it still feels bizarre that McDavid doesn't win with his playoff + regular season performance.
Kinda hard to argue that the guy that won the Lindsay shouldn’t have won the Hart.
Congrats MacK!
Always the bridesmaid, never the bride until today. Fully deserved. Definitely a nice burnish to a HoF resume still on the build.
Kucherov had a great case…but so did MacK the year that Hall won it so…sometimes the end and flow just runs your way a smidge more.
Always the bridesmaid, never the bride until today. Fully deserved. Definitely a nice burnish to a HoF resume still on the build.
Kucherov had a great case…but so did MacK the year that Hall won it so…sometimes the end and flow just runs your way a smidge more.
- Oct 9, 2012
- 32,373
- 31,298
GhostfaceWu
Shi Shaw
- Feb 11, 2015
- 11,234
- 11,730
- Oct 9, 2012
- 32,373
- 31,298
robertmac43
Forever 43!
- Mar 31, 2015
- 24,964
- 17,170
GreatGonzo
Registered User
Matthews and Panarin having more first place votes than McDavid is an absolute joke. Voter fatigue is a real thing.
That is like saying its kind of hard to believe that the most popular guy at your workplace doesn't receive the most praise for their work. People just continue to put way too much stock in the Lindsay.
Honestly there really wasn't a clear front runner, and so doesn't bother me that MacKinnon won it. By far the weakest win in recent memory though, can't remember the last time someone didn't lead in goals, assists, or points won the Hart.
MacK finished 5th in points that year and had Rantanen pacing with him in points nearly the entire way. Hall might have been an 'undeserving' winner to you, but MacKinnon had a joke of a 'case' that year, and I don't know why it gets brought up on these boards by his groupies.
If both the players AND the media gave him the MVP, then you’re the fringe opinion. Not the rest of us.
Take a deep breathe and reread my post. Did I say Hall was undeserving?
Save your ammo, bud.
My opinion was that he was a deserving winner, and I stated as much pretty clearly in the post. I assume you can read, and you saw that. So you must disagree with the other opinion I expressed about this being a rather weak Hart win? If that is the case, I don't see how that is reflected by the voters. Did they write a note next to their vote saying that it was dominant Hart win? I must be missing something.
Close doesn’t mean weak. Mac killed it this year. Not his fault others did too.
Foppberg
Registered User
Linds
Makalder
- Jun 20, 2016
- 1,397
- 1,333
No you didn't, I speculated with the word 'might' due to your wild assertion that MacKinnon had a legit case for the Hart that year. Kucherov had just of a 'case' for the Hart that year, guess we could say he was robbed that year as well by the Canadian media.
Close doesn't mean weak. I called it weak based on his not winning in any major statistical category of points, assists, goals. I suppose you disagree, but I am not on an island with this opinion.
