Speculation: 2023-24-25 Sharks Roster Discussion

[The McMafia]

This might mean nothing

But if this means something. . .

There may be a reason why the org passed on Buium.

 

[vortexy]

Here’s an article on Macklin that I’m sure you all would love to read. Yeah we are so lucky to have him The Celebrini Effect

 

[tiburon12]

There may be a reason why the org passed on Buium.

I thought the org + every other team passed on Buium because his defensive ability was very suspect

 

[Gecklund]

This might mean nothing

But if this means something. . .

Bader’s charts are fun to look at but they are not good.

 

[Gecklund]

I thought the org + every other team passed on Buium because his defensive ability was very suspect

This is such a bad claim. No he’s not an elite defensively but he’s not “very suspect.” He’s no worse than all the other high level puck moving defensemen in the NHL right now.

 

[weastern bias]

Bader’s charts are fun to look at but they are not good.

All prospect projection is essential visionboard wishcasting, but his Celebrini models are looking pretty spot on right now

 

[mogambomoroo]

I wouldn't be opposed to get them both to help the kids.

 

[JoeThorntonsRooster]

Seems like CBus is accepting offers for Jiricek at this point.

I'm inclined to offer Mukhamadullin+ with the logjam in the pool at LD especially if we end up with Schaefer.

With the way both BDE and Cags are showing out, I think offering Muk might be our best chance at getting that premium RD from a position of strength.

Shakir is in his D+5 and can’t crack the defense of the worst team in the NHL. I don’t think he would or should be seen as much more than a throw in at this point.

 

[one2gamble]

I wouldn't be opposed to get them both to help the kids.

they owe us a freebee if you really want one of them

 

[mogambomoroo]

they owe us a freebee if you really want one of them

1st round pick it is. '25 or '26 without protection.

Trouba (waiving for SJ) and 1st round pick for Ceci, Kostin (they can just waive Kostin) and 7th round pick

Kreider is going to be a harder piece, but I could see him going somewhere else.

 

[Cas]

1st round pick it is. '25 or '26 without protection.

Trouba (waiving for SJ) and 1st round pick for Ceci, Kostin (they can just waive Kostin) and 7th round pick

Kreider is going to be a harder piece, but I could see him going somewhere else.

I wouldn't waste a noxious bowel movement on that Trouba trade. He's not good, plays aggressively in an extremely stupid manner, and trading a high 1st for an aging, mediocre player whom I would hate watching is just anathema.

 

[Stewie Griffin]

I wouldn't waste a noxious bowel movement on that Trouba trade. He's not good, plays aggressively in an extremely stupid manner, and trading a high 1st for an aging, mediocre player whom I would hate watching is just anathema.

We would be acquiring the 1st in that deal

 

[mogambomoroo]

I wouldn't waste a noxious bowel movement on that Trouba trade. He's not good, plays aggressively in an extremely stupid manner, and trading a high 1st for an aging, mediocre player whom I would hate watching is just anathema.

It was Trouba + NYR 1st round pick coming to SJ.

 

[Jargon]

Shakir is in his D+5 and can’t crack the defense of the worst team in the NHL. I don’t think he would or should be seen as much more than a throw in at this point.

To be fair to Shakir, I think he was fully expected to play in the NHL this year until his injury and now they’re trying to gently ease him back. I do get what you’re saying re: trade value though.

I’d do a Musty for Jiricek trade.

 

[mogambomoroo]

To be fair to Shakir, I think he was fully expected to play in the NHL this year until his injury and now they’re trying to gently ease him back. I do get what you’re saying re: trade value though.

I’d do a Musty for Jiricek trade.

I have a bad feeling about trading Musty. Just a feeling that he is going to rocket to the top of the league and become a 1st line forward if we trade him away. But then also, he is for sure going to bust if we keep him. #tealdilemma

 

[Jargon]

I have a bad feeling about trading Musty. Just a feeling that he is going to rocket to the top of the league and become a 1st line forward if we trade him away. But then also, he is for sure going to bust if we keep him. #tealdilemma

I really like him too but boy do we need a young RD..

 

[Cas]

It was Trouba + NYR 1st round pick coming to SJ.

We would be acquiring the 1st in that deal

You're right, I misread because I am extremely tired, but I still don't want Trouba.

 

[Juxtaposer]

I would have a lot of time for Chris Kreider. Too bad there's no way he waives for us.

 

[fasterthanlight]

mukhamadullin and musty for jiricek (e5), lets make it happen

 

[OrrNumber4]

I have a bad feeling about trading Musty. Just a feeling that he is going to rocket to the top of the league and become a 1st line forward if we trade him away. But then also, he is for sure going to bust if we keep him. #tealdilemma

Endowment effect!

Aside from Joshua Norris, Kiprusoff (not exactly a prospect when he was traded) was the last time I could remember this happening. Wishart, Mueller, Sadowy, etc. all crashed and burned. Edstrom is looking solid...

Fundamentally you have to trust the scouting and developmental staff. If they think Musty is the real deal, it'll be difficult to pry him from the Sharks's hands.

 

[timorous me]

I would have a lot of time for Chris Kreider. Too bad there's no way he waives for us.

It would be very weird for the Rangers to trade Kreider. Ideally they would trade Trouba (seems unlikely until next offseason) and just name Kreider captain, as he should've been all along.

Yes, Kreider's line is struggling to some extent this year, but if anything they probably should've just fired Laviolette and hired Montgomery when they had the chance. For a team in their situation right now, it feels like the best thing they can do--at least until the deadline and they might have a bit more flexibility--is to find a way to get more out of the guys they currently have, like that Kreider line and especially their defense, which is more of a mess than it should be.

 

[Star Platinum]

This might mean nothing

But if this means something. . .

 

[Jargon]

Don’t really get wanting to trade Muhk before seeing him in the NHL this year. He got injured, not his fault, and he is one of our few legit defenseman prospects who can be a top 4. I’d much rather trade offense for Jiricek.

 

[Star Platinum]

I thought the org + every other team passed on Buium because his defensive ability was very suspect

I thought it was because everybody was frustrated trying to remember what order all the u's and i's are supposed to be in. Sam and Dickinson is much easier to remember.

 

[TheBeard]

I thought the org + every other team passed on Buium because his defensive ability was very suspect

I also remember a lot of the pundits claiming Yakemchuk would be the last of the big 6 D drafted.