Speculation: 2023-24-25 Sharks Roster Discussion

timorous me

Gristled Veteran
Apr 14, 2010
2,180
3,580
Obviously, I’ve stepped on toes here.
I’m not saying Givani needs to be here, just that I get it. This game is what it is. Many value the possibility of a guy who will fight. I didn’t make the rule.

Most fans of the Sharks first season will say their favorite player was Link. He didn’t deserve to be in the league but that doesn’t change what many think.
Beyond the merits of having goons on your team (I don't think Smith even really fits that definition of the term; he's simply a sub-4th line player who's willing to fight, but not some heavyweight), I think you have to also consider the other side of it: a young player with upside who's paid his dues in the minors and has shown growth and seems clearly ready for at least a more extended chance in the NHL.

If you're not going to give him a chance, then what kind of message does that send to all the other not-superstar prospects in the system?
 
  • Like
Reactions: vortexy

Alaskanice

Registered User
Sep 23, 2009
6,787
7,544
1 1/2 hours away
Beyond the merits of having goons on your team (I don't think Smith even really fits that definition of the term; he's simply a sub-4th line player who's willing to fight, but not some heavyweight), I think you have to also consider the other side of it: a young player with upside who's paid his dues in the minors and has shown growth and seems clearly ready for at least a more extended chance in the NHL.

If you're not going to give him a chance, then what kind of message does that send to all the other not-superstar prospects in the system?
That’s beyond my purview. I can rant and rave to what cause? Grier and Wars aren’t calling me for my opinion.
I’ve not said that Danil doesn’t deserve a shot up here. I’ve watched this game long enough to know and to say that waivers and such are more important than what you or I have to say about it.
Would I be surprised to see Goose sent down in favor of Givani? Not at all. I’d think it’s a wrong choice but I’m not going to spout about rioting over it.
 

Le Grand Quebecois

Registered User
Jun 6, 2015
425
345
Oakland, CA
Obviously, I’ve stepped on toes here.
I’m not saying Givani needs to be here, just that I get it. This game is what it is. Many value the possibility of a guy who will fight. I didn’t make the rule.

Most fans of the Sharks first season will say their favorite player was Link. He didn’t deserve to be in the league but that doesn’t change what many think.
The most talented player on the ice for SJ back then was talented at face punching. Nobody was good at hockey.

That’s beyond my purview. I can rant and rave to what cause? Grier and Wars aren’t calling me for my opinion.
I’ve not said that Danil doesn’t deserve a shot up here. I’ve watched this game long enough to know and to say that waivers and such are more important than what you or I have to say about it.
Would I be surprised to see Goose sent down in favor of Givani? Not at all. I’d think it’s a wrong choice but I’m not going to spout about rioting over it.
You're correct that the most likely path the Sharks will take is the one that doesn't risk losing a player. Right or wrong.
 

Anomie2029

Registered User
Oct 10, 2013
3,929
4,188
Melbourne, Australia
Gushchin has earned his NHL spot - sending him to the AHL flies in the face of all talk made before and during preseason about earning spots.

In a game that had 'NHLers' Wennberg, Kostin, Goodrow, Kunin, Smith and Sturm - it was Gushchin that took the lead and drove play.

The club will not improve if they're going to prioritize bad NHLers over young players who outplayed them.
 

Alaskanice

Registered User
Sep 23, 2009
6,787
7,544
1 1/2 hours away
Gushchin has earned his NHL spot - sending him to the AHL flies in the face of all talk made before and during preseason about earning spots.

In a game that had 'NHLers' Wennberg, Kostin, Goodrow, Kunin, Smith and Sturm - it was Gushchin that took the lead and drove play.

The club will not improve if they're going to prioritize bad NHLers over young players who outplayed them.
Kostin took a pass and scored. Kunin caused turnovers and fought in front of the net to deflect for 2 goals. Sturm pulled up and made a pass that led to the winning goal. The others did quite a bit that doesn’t show up on the scorers card or the highlights but they’re crucial as well.
This game needs those “bad” players. They do the banging, fighting for the boards, pressuring the front of the net. Again, they are crucial.
 

Hodge

Registered User
Apr 27, 2021
6,383
7,623
Gushchin has earned his NHL spot - sending him to the AHL flies in the face of all talk made before and during preseason about earning spots.

In a game that had 'NHLers' Wennberg, Kostin, Goodrow, Kunin, Smith and Sturm - it was Gushchin that took the lead and drove play.

The club will not improve if they're going to prioritize bad NHLers over young players who outplayed them.
You mean to tell me a guy fighting for a roster spot performed better in a meaningless exhibition game than the established NHLers on both teams whose main priority was trying not to get injured? Time to induct Gushchin into the HHOF.
 

coooldude

Registered User
Sponsor
Jul 25, 2007
4,195
4,729
It's highly possible that Granlund or some other top 9 isn't ready on Thursday and Goose gets his start and everyone can calm down.
 

Jargon

Registered User
Apr 12, 2011
6,170
10,957
Venice, California
Someone has to be injured, I Believe in Gushchin. Specifically, I think Warsofsky will play guys who earned it.

You mean to tell me a guy fighting for a roster spot performed better in a meaningless exhibition game than the established NHLers on both teams whose main priority was trying not to get injured? Time to induct Gushchin into the HHOF.

This is exactly what we’re saying, yes.
 

Hodge

Registered User
Apr 27, 2021
6,383
7,623
This is a really silly response.
What's really silly is acting like preseason games with unbalanced rosters and wildly varying levels of effort among NHL veterans should be used to determine roster spots, as if all of these guys don't have extensive track records in hockey prior to September 2024.

If Gushchin has "earned" anything it's the right to be the first call-up in case of a top six injury which he was probably always going to be anyway. He's not suddenly a better player than Barclay Goodrow or Luke Kunin because he assisted on some goals in preseason.
 

TheBeard

He fixes the cable?
Jul 12, 2019
17,286
19,717
Vegass
What's really silly is acting like preseason games with unbalanced rosters and wildly varying levels of effort among NHL veterans should be used to determine roster spots, as if all of these guys don't have extensive track records in hockey prior to September 2024.

If Gushchin has "earned" anything it's the right to be the first call-up in case of a top six injury which he was probably always going to be anyway. He's not suddenly a better player than Barclay Goodrow or Luke Kunin because he assisted on some goals in preseason.
At this rate, with his year last year and his preseason this year, he's 100% earned the right to start on the big club over other older higher-paid vets, but doesn't mean his leash isn't short.
 

Hodge

Registered User
Apr 27, 2021
6,383
7,623
100% he's not suddenly a better player...he's been for a long time, and he's been making that undisputable.
Better at scoring goals? Maybe. Better at any other aspect of the sport? No. A better fit for 14 minutes of 3rd line + PK ice time than Goodrow or Kunin? Absolutely not.

Gushchin probably should have been playing over the likes of Hoffman and Barabanov last season but now that we have legit bottom six forwards who have played that role on winning NHL teams there's no room for him in a relatively healthy Sharks lineup.
 

weastern bias

worst team in the league
Feb 3, 2012
11,244
7,590
SJ
Weren't rosters supposed to be finalized by 2:00 today? Have we gotten any official word from the Sharks on the last cuts?
 

Jargon

Registered User
Apr 12, 2011
6,170
10,957
Venice, California
What's really silly is acting like preseason games with unbalanced rosters and wildly varying levels of effort among NHL veterans should be used to determine roster spots, as if all of these guys don't have extensive track records in hockey prior to September 2024.

If Gushchin has "earned" anything it's the right to be the first call-up in case of a top six injury which he was probably always going to be anyway. He's not suddenly a better player than Barclay Goodrow or Luke Kunin because he assisted on some goals in preseason.

The thing is, it’s not just preseason and his goals weren’t like some casual random pass that they put in.

He’s done everything that’s been asked of him, was an AHL All-Star, came in stronger, faster and has played tenaciously and aggressively in all 3 zones. He willed the win yesterday and if Warsofsky is running practices so hard that guys are getting hurt trying to win mini-games because “competition”, Gushchin did that against Vegas over anyone else on the team.

Again, if your message is “work your ass off and you’ll make the team,” sending the guy that’s been the most competitive, etc etc in the preseason sends a really bad message. I’m not saying he needs to play the entire season, but I think he needs a few games in the NHL as a reward for doing *exactly* what he’s been asked to do for multiple seasons, and getting consistently better in each.

I’m fairly positive someone is hurt though. I’m hopeful he plays the first game.
 

Erep

Registered User
Jul 17, 2019
1,469
1,662
Also, I am pretty sure, "Opening Day Playing Roster" doesn't mean who is actually playing on opening night, and the Sharks can make transactions after because they don't actually have a game on Tuesday...
 

sampler

Registered User
Aug 3, 2018
545
513
If Gush is sent down, after being Point per game, baraccuda leading scorer, putting up a couple points in his cup of coffee last year, and then being arguably the best sharks player on the ice in the preseason... I would say, there is little more he can do to prove himself.

I also think his style of game, which is high energy, high tempo, wicked shot, quick attack, and speed game is the kind of the game the sharks DESPRATELY need.

On the GWG, most every player on the sharks, other than maybe celly, granlund, and few other top ones , would have dumped that puck deep. The sharks are a team full of deliberate, slow, and easy to predict players. Thats why they have no breakout and no forecheck. Gush plays a completely different game in which its all about quick attack, quick pucks toward the net, puck possession and making plays. He's like a smaller, lesser celebrini. Always moving, great motor, great effort.

The sharks need playmakers who can more than just dump and chase and flip pucks out. We need guys who can carry the puck, hold on the puck, attack the net, outwork... Gush can do all that.

I would also add that if the sharks are a meritocracy, which they need to be to build any kind of hard working legit culture, then Gush>Smith (Either smith). You gotta put ice the best lineup, most NHL ready lineup. Will has definitely not proven to be NHL level. Neither has Graf. Cardwell is getting closer, but not there yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jargon

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad