Speculation: 2023-24-25-26 Sharks Roster Discussion

[Juxtaposer]

Says that CAR is offering a 1st plus Nikishin for Helly. I suppose that helps estimate his value in terms of what they'd be asking for, but I don't see them as a team looking to collect picks.

I have a hard time believing the team that just won a Cup with Brandon Bussi is in the market for an expensive goaltender.

 

[Hodge]

Says that CAR is offering a 1st plus Nikishin for Helly. I suppose that helps estimate his value in terms of what they'd be asking for, but I don't see them as a team looking to collect picks.

Also mentions the Sharks as a team "positioned" to take a run at Hellebuyck

I'd give up Askarov and a top 10 protected 1st next year if he's willing to come here

I don't think Asky is ever gonna be the guy and Hellebuyck is the perfect bridge to Ravensbergen potentially taking over

 

[STL Shark]

I have a hard time believing the team that just won a Cup with Brandon Bussi is in the market for an expensive goaltender.

For any old goalie, I would agree. That said, they have to have seen Florida load up to beat their tails again next year and realize they need an upgrade somewhere.

Would also probably be good business for them to get their slice of the Team USA brotherhood to try and lure some others (Larkin maybe?) their way.

 

[gaucholoco3]

Says that CAR is offering a 1st plus Nikishin for Helly. I suppose that helps estimate his value in terms of what they'd be asking for, but I don't see them as a team looking to collect picks.

This is such a mistake. Helly is a positional goalie. With Carolina’s system they give up the most high danger chances of contenders. They should go after Bob over Helly.

I would be curious if Florida somehow trades Lundell + for Helly.

 

[Juxtaposer]

For any old goalie, I would agree. That said, they have to have seen Florida load up to beat their tails again next year and realize they need an upgrade somewhere.

Would also probably be good business for them to get their slice of the Team USA brotherhood to try and lure some others (Larkin maybe?) their way.

Hellebuyck consistently shitting the bed in the playoffs makes him “any old goalie” in my book.

 

[OrrNumber4]

Don't see how a trade could work between Sharks and Blues. They have nothing I'd want that they'd be willing to partake with. Maybe if they somehow got the 4th or 5th pick, they could trade up...

Carolina targeting Hellebuyck makes little sense. They just won with average (at best) goaltending.

 

[Surfer Dude]

Don't see how a trade could work between Sharks and Blues. They have nothing I'd want that they'd be willing to partake with. Maybe if they somehow got the 4th or 5th pick, they could trade up...

Carolina targeting Hellebuyck makes little sense. They just won with average (at best) goaltending.

broberg, and paraykho would make me take their call at least

 

[Grinner]

Knies is going to get way too much and isn't in a position we need at all. Save those assets for a D

A true PF is very much a need

 

[Grinner]

That’s pretty wild

Wasn't it an offset to how mush$$$ the athletes were being paid in the other major leagues?

 

[Hodge]

A true PF is very much a need

Cherny is a true PF but we could certainly use another one

 

[themelkman]

A true PF is very much a need

Didn't we just trade for Sherwood? We can also have pure skill guys

 

[Grinner]

Cherny is a true PF but we could certainly use another one

Most definitely

 

[Grinner]

Didn't we just trade for Sherwood? We can also have pure skill guys

He's a 3rd liner

 

[WSS11]

 

[Juxtaposer]

If the Ducks could get Lafreniere or Cuylle straight up for McTavish that would be a win. I also wonder about Gavrikov.

 

[Hodge]

If the Ducks could get Lafreniere or Cuylle straight up for McTavish that would be a win. I also wonder about Gavrikov.

It's probably Schneider

 

[Juxtaposer]

It's probably Schneider

Yeah that actually makes sense. Disappointing middle-six winger for disappointing bottom pairing defenseman, same age range.

 

[Lebanezer]

Ducks are so lucky to get out from that McTavish contract. He’s bad.

 

[Hodge]

Why is Pierre LeBrun saying there's no deadline for the Stars to make a decision on Robertson? He can be offer sheeted in less than a week

 

[STL Shark]

Yeah that actually makes sense. Disappointing middle-six winger for disappointing bottom pairing defenseman, same age range.

Find you someone that loves doing deals as much as Verbeek and Drury. This would be the third pretty sizable deal that they have done in 2 years.

 

[STL Shark]

Why is Pierre LeBrun saying there's no deadline for the Stars to make a decision on Robertson? He can be offer sheeted in less than a week

I think they'd dare someone to trade them 4 unprotected 1st rounders for him. Anyone can fall off for a year as evidenced by Florida this year. If that is the worst outcome, I think Dallas is right to say they have no deadline.

 

[matt trick]

Why is Pierre LeBrun saying there's no deadline for the Stars to make a decision on Robertson? He can be offer sheeted in less than a week

Chicago can continue stockpiling random assets 7x$14M with a max OS.

Robertson-Bedard-Kantserov
Teuvo-Nazar-Frondell
Moore-Donato-Bertuzzi

Byram-Lev
Vlasic-Rinzel
EDM-Kaiser

That team is worlds better and also not particularly interesting.

I do think Dallas get him signed though

 

[Hodge]

I think they'd dare someone to trade them 4 unprotected 1st rounders for him. Anyone can fall off for a year as evidenced by Florida this year. If that is the worst outcome, I think Dallas is right to say they have no deadline.

Even if nobody offer sheets him can't he file for arbitration and get a 1 year award that walks him to UFA?

So I guess the real deadline is his arbitration hearing date

 

[Hodge]

Chicago can continue stockpiling random assets 7x$14M with a max OS.

Robertson-Bedard-Kantserov
Teuvo-Nazar-Frondell
Moore-Donato-Bertuzzi

Byram-Lev
Vlasic-Rinzel
EDM-Kaiser

That team is worlds better and also not particularly interesting.

I do think Dallas get him signed though

I would still be down to send 2OA plus other stuff to Dallas for him

Try to keep 9 and 27 to trade up for a defenseman though

 

[OrrNumber4]

broberg, and paraykho would make me take their call at least

Parayko might have a bounce-back season, and Broberg could hopefully develop further, but neither player is one I trade #2 for straight-up. It would have to be something like #5 + Broberg.

This is the reason why top-5 picks are rarely traded. Too much variability in outcomes.