Fitz was specifically asked about the Mukhamadullin pick at the time and made a comment about sticking to the list. Now it probably was in connection with defenders and didn’t mean he was their next prospect overall.
I must say that our Russian scouts have been our best scouts over the past few years. Our scouts have blown picks from Central Europe (Baumgartner), USHS (Shlaine), Finland (Salminen) and Sweden (Hurtig) -- but our past three years worth of picks from Russia have all looked outstanding (Bardakov, Gritsyuk, Misyul, Sharangovich).
My personal opinion when trying to figure out Fitzgerald's draft strategy, is that he is involved in earlier picks -- I think his fingerprints are on Holtz, Mercer, Mukhamadullin, Luke Hughes and Stillman -- and thereafter he gives picks to scouts without much cohesion. This is all admittedly speculation, of course, but again, it's difficult to figure how the same group of scouts which gave us later round picks of Bratt and Gritsyuk and Sharangovich is now taking guys whose NHL careers are essentially washed out within months of the pick being made, as with Baumgartner and Hurtig.
Still, the two picks out of Russia over the past two years -- Mukhamadullin and Bardakov -- were both very good. I have a lot of faith in our Russian scouting, and hopefully that will wind up with the Devils getting some late round gems like Barabosha and Neuchev in the 2022 draft.
Just for fun, I'm ranking the picks from the two Fitzgerald drafts and listing their leagues, just to give an idea of what I'm getting at. I''m leaving out the goalies, since goalie scouting is often done by a different group of people altogether.
1 LD Luke Hughes USHL (1st)
2 RW Dawson Mercer QMJHL (1st)
3 RW Alex Holtz SHL (1st)
4 LD Shakir Mukhamadullin KHL (1st)
5 RW Chase Stillman OHL (1st)
6 LD Ethan Edwards AJHL (4th)
7 LD Topias Vilen Finland Liiga (5th)
8 F Zakhar Bardakov KHL (7th)
9 C Jaromir Pytlik OHL (4th)
10 LW Samu Salminen Finland Jr. (3rd)
11 C Artem Shlaine USHS (5th)
12 RD Viktor Hurtig Sweden Jr. (6th)
13 C Benjamin Baumgartner Switzerland Elite League (6th)
Strangely, the Devils did not draft out of Western Canada at all in the past two years, but aside from that we've pretty much reached around everywhere. But looking at this list, I'd say the Russian scouting did great, the USHS scouting did very well -- though that's mostly Luke Hughes who was a pretty obvious pick. The QMJHL had one pick and it was awesome -- Dawson Mercer -- but again that was likely a more collaborative pick because it was so early.
Unfortunately, no other scouting group can say they succeeded. It also bears noting that, in a re-draft for 2020 and 2021, a lot of these picks do not hold up well. Here's another list for those who care:
Hughes: earlier
Mercer: earlier
Holtz: slightly later
Mukhamadullin: slightly later
Stillman: much later
Edwards: about the same
Vilen: about the same
Bardakov: a few rounds earlier
Pytlik: a couple rounds later
Salminen: several rounds later
Shlaine: probably doesn't get drafted
Hurtig: definitely doesn't get drafted
Baumgartner: wouldn't get drafted if the draft was 20 rounds instead of 7
Obviously, some improvements are needed in the drafting process for 2022.