With respect, I think it
is crazy.
Every year, people try to tear down the first overall pick and create a 'race.' Well, Laf is so far ahead of everyone else in certainty they can't do that this year. So instead, Byfield is the scapegoat.
I do agree though, and I've said often, that Byfield comes with his own set of questions. But the guy is a young draftee and honestly has a ceiling up there with Lafreniere IMO. I said previously he gives me a wheeler vibe in that he'll take some time to marinate because he's a huge dude with athletic tools that will need to learn to use them and grow into them a bit more but I think people are mistaking 'high ceiling' for 'project'. He's already got speed, hands, size. All you really want is a guy that size to hit/use it more (but he may never be a big hitter--look at Wheeler. Can crush people when he wants, but usually doesn't. But he's physical like Kopitar is) and to see how his IQ stacks up against NHLers.
Pronman puts Lafreniere up on his own, then Byfield on his own tier before everyone else as well. Can I see him dropping to 3? Sure. I could easily see someone having either Stutzle OR Drysdale be "their guy." But if he drops to 4 or 5, someone f***ed up.
Pronman's scouting report: Why Quinton Byfield is a top NHL...