I mean Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen played a solid season!
Yeah, he did... in
Jr.A. Did you really just suggest that a 17-year-old goalie who's got
zero men's games on his belt, some consistency problems even on
U18 level should suddenly become the starter in men's WHC?
Dude, that's... I... I mean... I don't even... let's just say that's not going to happen. Like never.
-Besides, Korpisalo is young too, doubly so for a goalie, and he's got plenty to prove, given he's not an NHL starter yet and is in fact in a race for the backup spot in the Blue Jackets' organization with Anton Forsberg. So he certainly had the motivation to show up and play lights out here, given the shot as a starter.
Julius Honka was a good pick, he is there just to clinch the spot at the Stars' roster and you can see why. But why not add more youth to the team? Urho Vaakanainen and Miro Heiskanen are a first round prospects this years draft, what could be better than showcase themselves at the men's tournament? Also Olli Juolevi continued where he left off with the Knights, the guy can roll the powerplay and look at where Finland suck this tournament... yep.
There was some debate about Juolevi, but I think his chances were ultimately torpedoed by the complete lack of pedigree from men's games. OHL and U20 NT success can rarely be used to meter how ready a player is to take the next step. Heiskanen and Vaakanainen at least have some kind of Liiga records, and they've proven they can hang on in there just fine, so... at least that's got some ground.
Regardless, I don't think that a 17/18-year-old d-men are going to be the impact players you wish them to be. At the very least, I hope you're not suggesting they should've taken all three. One of these may have hung in there if picked, but let's keep in mind that this lot couldn't even help them avoid a disaster in the U20 games.
-Here's a suggestion: If you want to watch a young d-man with lot to prove, besides Honka that is, follow Mikko Lehtonen. Marjamäki took a pretty huge flier on him already.
But still powerplay looks horrible and some skill and willingness is required. Kristian Vesalainen is a very promising goal scorer with Eeli Tolvanen both looking to be first round picks. The Skoda Cup veterans would've been very nice target to be replaced. And why not throw the winning rookie scorer Teemu Turunen there?
Junior achievements aside, Vesalainen wasn't good enough to break an SHL roster in Frölunda, was loaned to HPK where he was a filler player. That's not someone you realistically expect having an impact in men's WHC.
On Tolvanen's case any sensible coach will wait and see if he can take his USHL scoring stats and translate them to the next level. They're not just gonna hope that happens because of... youth enthusiasm or something.
Turunen's point totals give him the 48th seed in this year's Liiga scoring table. If seeds #2 and #3 on that table haven't done much impact here, I think it's a bit too much to expect from someone nearly 50 spots down the list.
-Besides Aho and Rantanen, don't we have Pulju too? And how has he done? I bet if he was left outside the squad, people would now be talking how he could've made all the difference.
I mean many teams have done this now for years. Team USA does this all the time by sending college players and prospects. I think that this tournament is ideal for that, the scouts are there but they aren't looking for seasoned players whose NHL train went 10 years ago.
Sorry, you're plain out to sea here. No team takes a bunch of 17/18-year-olds with little to no pedigree from men. USA has three college players in this squad, but even the youngest of them is a '97-born, same age as our Aho. Oldest saw the light of this world in '95, same as Honka. They very much wait 'til those players are out of the junior age and physically mature enough to take the step for this level.
Additionally, they don't count anything on 'em. If they can show they should be out there when the game is on the line, it's a bonus for the USA. But if they can't, they can always bury them to the bottom of the roster and let other guys handle the load - guys who happen to be career NHLers. And even if those guys fail too, it's water off the duck's back for them, because no one back home will care. There's gonna be no raving mob waiting to lynch them when get back home if they don't get a medal.
Finland, obviously, has none of these luxuries.