He was fantastic this year. He was one of the main reasons they made the playoffs. Excellent playmaker and an absolute puck hound.
Nobody is denying that he's a legit talent and a very good player. His history of being focused more on himself than on the team, and being unreliable over anything other than short periods of time are what make it ridiculous for him to ask for that kind of contract. 10 years ago he played two consecutive seasons for the Predators. That's his record. Then he left. Then he came back. Played a handful of games, then he left again. Then he came back. His best seasons are 58 and 54 points.
Now he's asking for the kind of money and term that is generally only given to guys who produce at an elite level.
Pick him up at the deadline for a Cup Run? Sure. Pick him up for a contract that likely takes him a year or two past his prime, at $7M per year? That's ****ing nuts, whether we have the space or not. And what happens if we have a big playoff disappointment and the media is on him a little bit, and then he's not happy and wants a trade... and no one wants his remaining 5yr 7M BS?
Pass. Big pass. Our formula for winning has worked just fine without that type of player. No need to start taking that kind of risk now.