don't need McNabb to put up points, need him to be solid defensively and make a good first pass out of the zone.
Calling it now, Lombardi signs Jarret Stoll to a one year deal.
I have a bad feeling the D isn't going to be addressed, but its still early...
McNabb had a fine season when paired with Doughty. Rosen covered it in his evaluation.
http://lakingsinsider.com/2016/06/02/player-evaluation-mcnabb-2/
Easily the most bone-crushing hits for the entire defensemen group. Doughty played well next to him; he played well next to Doughty. The WOWY stats demonstrate this. In the end Sutter didn't trust him enough and played Scuderi, which in my opinion was a huge mistake.
Once McNabb gets more confident he'll put up points. He's where Muzzin was four years ago. Let him play a full season next to Doughty and he'll prove you wrong.
And then gets automatically fired![]()
McNabb is awful. The guy can't skate. He is no where near where Muzzin was. He's a marginal player 6/7 D man tops.
Gonna bookmark this one for future reference because man, that's just wrong. So he's basically not even an NHLer?
McNabb had a fine season when paired with Doughty. Rosen covered it in his evaluation.
http://lakingsinsider.com/2016/06/02/player-evaluation-mcnabb-2/
Easily the most bone-crushing hits for the entire defensemen group. Doughty played well next to him; he played well next to Doughty. The WOWY stats demonstrate this. In the end Sutter didn't trust him enough and played Scuderi, which in my opinion was a huge mistake.
Once McNabb gets more confident he'll put up points. He's where Muzzin was four years ago. Let him play a full season next to Doughty and he'll prove you wrong.
don't need McNabb to put up points, need him to be solid defensively and make a good first pass out of the zone.
McNabb isn't Muzzin. His reads (offensively and defensively) aren't even close to the ones of Muzzin who I defended on this site many times...I'm sure there were a bunch of similar things said about Muzzin before 2014 and we all know what's happened since. Give the kid a chance to learn the game before you throw him into the trash heap.
If you ask me, he is a fine Matt Greene replacement on the bottom pairing. He has some physicality and could learn to pk. It isn't fair to the player to put him in a position he is going to fail in the top4.Gonna bookmark this one for future reference because man, that's just wrong. So he's basically not even an NHLer?
Lombardi needs to find a #1 LW and ideally a #3 dman, those players are out there and you don't have to break the bank. Good teams push players down the depth chart, not up and Lombardi has done a good job of doing that throughout the latter stages of the 5 Year Plan Era up until now. See what he does today, looking forward to the draft and hoping at least one trade is made. For me as a fan I'd like to see Ladd signed, Versteeg re-signed, #3 dman would be a Lombardi surprise and the slower players dispatched like King, Greene, Scuderi, Clifford to make space. That said I'm just a fan of the Kings, I'm not a scout or a GM, I'm not crunching numbers or studying cap space in 2019 to justify my wants.
O'Donnell looked good on Doughty pairing. That has more to do with Doughty quality babysitting rather then the quality of some of his defense partners.
McNabb isn't Muzzin. His reads (offensively and defensively) aren't even close to the ones of Muzzin who I defended on this site many times...
Frankly, it's laughable to compare the two of them...
Explain how Doughty had a better Goals For % and a better Corsi For % with McNabb than without McNabb in 2015-16 if he's just babysitting.
Explain how Doughty managed to win a Norris Trophy babysitting for the majority of the season.
Explain how McNabb managed a 60% Goals For % and 54% Corsi For % with the boat anchor known as Luke Schenn, the only other defenseman he played any substantial minutes with in 2015-16.
Explain how Doughty had a better Goals For % and a better Corsi For % with McNabb than with Muzzin in 2015-16.
McNabb has had a few notable brain cramps that led to skilled forwards blowing past him. That's what happens when you're a defenseman. It happens to almost everyone. It still happens to Jake Muzzin. This board is fond of pointing out every time it happens to Erik Karlsson.
A truer assessment of a defenseman is built over time in his ability to drive play the other direction. McNabb has shown he's able to do that. Doughty is comfortable playing next to him.
Once McNabb figures out his offensive game, the comparisons to Jake Muzzin will be pretty obvious. The guy has a shooting percentage of 2.5% for his career so far. If he gets that to 5%, he'll get 5-10 goals and 20-30 points per season. That's solid for a middle pairing guy.
If you ask me, he is a fine Matt Greene replacement on the bottom pairing. He has some physicality and could learn to pk. It isn't fair to the player to put him in a position he is going to fail in the top4.
Again, think of the time after the trade deadline and in the playoffs...Explain how Doughty had a better Goals For % and a better Corsi For % with McNabb than without McNabb in 2015-16 if he's just babysitting.
Explain how Doughty managed to win a Norris Trophy babysitting for the majority of the season.
Explain how McNabb managed a 60% Goals For % and 54% Corsi For % with the boat anchor known as Luke Schenn, the only other defenseman he played any substantial minutes with in 2015-16.
Explain how Doughty had a better Goals For % and a better Corsi For % with McNabb than with Muzzin in 2015-16.
McNabb has had a few notable brain cramps that led to skilled forwards blowing past him. That's what happens when you're a defenseman. It happens to almost everyone. It still happens to Jake Muzzin. This board is fond of pointing out every time it happens to Erik Karlsson.
A truer assessment of a defenseman is built over time in his ability to drive play the other direction. McNabb has shown he's able to do that. Doughty is comfortable playing next to him.
Once McNabb figures out his offensive game, the comparisons to Jake Muzzin will be pretty obvious. The guy has a shooting percentage of 2.5% for his career so far. If he gets that to 5%, he'll get 5-10 goals and 20-30 points per season. That's solid for a middle pairing guy.
I never said he wasn't an NHL-er. He is a perfect Greene replacement and hopefully with a slightly more flair for puck handling in the offensive zone.WE can agree to disagree where he ends up in the lineup (I think ultimately he's already a top-4 d-man and that's where he should be, #4, unless he can improve his speed, in which case he's a #2), but you're agreeing with me that he's an NHLer. I'm just battling the notion that he doesn't have a spot in an NHL lineup, because that's ridiculous.
I think he's getting Derek Armstrong'ed right now, a lot of people are misinterpreting him being miscast as him being terrible.