Olerud would've been my second guess. Figured Delgado would have a higher OBP since power hitters usually get pitched around quite a bit and Olerud wasn't known for his power.
stupid Baggies! or whatever they have out there.
Olerud
Delgado
McGriff (looking at the list, the trade with San Diego was an enormous risk, McGriff and Fernandez were both offensive machines - Carter was not (in terms of OBP) and Alomar was a young guy)
Bautista
It's amazing how you knowledge and understanding of baseball stats changes and evolves over time.
A few years ago, if you had of asked me who the most disappointing Jay of all time was I would have said Olerud. He had just one year in Toronto when he hit over .300. But my opinion, then, was based on incomplete knowledge of how baseball offenses really function.