Coming from one of the biggest Roy fans around for multiple years, that scout couldn't be more wrong.
Kyle Woodlief is one of those scouts.
Not saying I agree. I don't watch them enough to form such an opinion.
I will say that of all the d-men in that second tier. (Roy, Chabot, Zboril)
Roy is the only one I hear mention of joining the first tier. (Hanifin, Provorov, Werenski)
And Werenski is the only one I hear mention of dropping to the second tier.
Being the armchair scout I am.
I'm happy with Roy at 16. Happy enough I wouldn't trade up for Werenski.
Hanifin and Provorov are another story though.