They qaulified offers to maintain his rights but made the min. offer. Fraser is in a tight spot with guys like Gardiner,Fraser,Gunner,Franson in front of him and Reilly right behind him.He was valuable to us in the reg season and helped enforce that "Not with this group!" atmosphere in To. I like him at 6 but don't see To.ready to pay him(Guarantees) until they know how much they are spending on another Top 2 Dman.
For those who dont like him(I do) odds are he wont be here more than another year(Reilly factor).Holzer was not and is not better(plus/minus) or nearly as tough.And Kostka was one of the worst experiments ever(wow! that was painful to watch).
Phaneuff (Top2 UFA)
Gardiner Franson - (number1 pp unit)
Gunner (Fraser)/ Reilly.
Liles Komi.
i'd like to see this next year:
Phaneuff - Gardiner
Reilly - Franson
Fraser - Gunner
only thing that worries me a bit with this is having Reilly as our second pairing... though i heard the kid was good... i'd like to just throw him in the deep end and see if he can swim.
i'm happy with that defense going forward. i don't think we even really need to sign anyone else. obviously phaneuff is a good number 1 guy to have. i think gardiner is good enough and ready to play on the first pairing. franson is a great second pairing guy. fraser and gunner i think are a great third pairing. only question mark is reilly. there's no doubt that he'll be playing that role in a couple years, though i'm hoping he can play it today.
also.. the cap hit from this defense group is pretty low. Phaneuff makes a lot. Franson was a steal last year... but he'll still be pretty underpaid this year considering his production last year. and all the other guys are cheap. we also don't have much of cap hit from our goalies either.
so this group will give us a lot of cap space to spend on our forwards for the next few years.
if we sign another big name defender, i don't know how much of an improvement it will make cause i think those 6 guys all play their role well... and it just takes away cap space that we could be spending getting elite forwards.
that's why i wouldn't trade gardiner for letang. i still agree that our defense would probably be a bit better with letang over gardiner (though maybe not, gardiner is awesome)... but that could be the difference between having two really good forwards vs. two average forwards.