CNS
A World Alone
- May 24, 2008
- 10,560
- 0
What do we think of Juuse Saros?
I'm not actually sure about him. Talent is there, size isn't. NHL scouts love big goalies nowadays.
What do we think of Juuse Saros?
Thanks for the reply. 1st and 2nd Rounders I'd use on forwards/defensemen. Not to say I wouldn't draft a goalie, but it would have to be one HELL of a prospect. Take a look at all the really successful goalies and where they were drafted. Patrick Roy - round 3. Jonathan Quick - round 3. Ryan Miller - round 5. Henrik Lundqvist - round 7. Pekka Rinne - round 8. Tim Thomas - round 9.
To me, the best forwards and defensemen in the draft are easier to trade than goalies. Look at all the trouble dealing Bernier and he's stellar.
Many of those 1st round goalies haven't amounted to much (yet). Brodeur is obviously quite accomplished. None of the others have done much. Fleury won a cup one but Cloutier could have won with that team.
I never said don't use a 1-4 round pick on a goalie. Where did you see that?
How are you defining "really successful"? And Roy, Quick, Miller, Lundqvist, Rinne, and Thomas, are all the "really successful" goalies in the period stretching back that far? Really? As long as we're being arbitrary we may as well go back another couple years and point out that Grant Fuhr was drafted 8th overall.Take a look at all the really successful goalies and where they were drafted. Patrick Roy - round 3. Jonathan Quick - round 3. Ryan Miller - round 5. Henrik Lundqvist - round 7. Pekka Rinne - round 8. Tim Thomas - round 9.
Well of course they are, teams field a whole lot more defensemen and forwards than goalies, therefore more of them will be drafted, and thus there will be more chances for superstars to arise from the group. You could equally say that there have been a lot more failed forwards and defensemen in the 1st/2nd rounds. Do we really know whether the success/bust proportion is any worse for goalies in early rounds? I don't think we do, and I personally have my doubts that it is statistically much different at all.I think based on the draft, you can say that the most successful players in the 1st/2nd rounds have been forwards/defenseman.
Looks like the Kings will have a 1st round draft pick this year. Who do you guys like?
Wanting to draft a stud defensemen like VV.
For some odd reason im really feeling curtis lazar this year. He's gonna be a sleeper pick and he fits in our model very well. I know we don't need another Centermen but if we get him, it makes a lot of our other players expandable.
Just saying, keep an eye on lazar, he's going to be special.
Looks like the Kings will have a 1st round draft pick this year. Who do you guys like?
Wanting to draft a stud defensemen like VV.
I'll take a stab with the 57th selection to LA.
John Hayden C/RW 6'3 221 going to Yale in the Fall
USU18 National Team
53 gms 17g 17a 80pim
"Compares to Scott Hartnell"
I know he's a C/RW, but the upside is there, and I'm not employed by anything hockey related.
I've got this inkling Dean tries hard to move up to get Jacob de la Rose. He's really a "Dean" kinda guy. Two way player who can score but good defensively and a hell of a hitter. IIRC he's a RWer.
How are you defining "really successful"? And Roy, Quick, Miller, Lundqvist, Rinne, and Thomas, are all the "really successful" goalies in the period stretching back that far? Really? As long as we're being arbitrary we may as well go back another couple years and point out that Grant Fuhr was drafted 8th overall.
Well of course they are, teams field a whole lot more defensemen and forwards than goalies, therefore more of them will be drafted, and thus there will be more chances for superstars to arise from the group. You could equally say that there have been a lot more failed forwards and defensemen in the 1st/2nd rounds. Do we really know whether the success/bust proportion is any worse for goalies in early rounds? I don't think we do, and I personally have my doubts that it is statistically much different at all.
To say Cloutier could have won a cup with that team isn't at all fair. Should we discredit Grant Fuhr for the cups he got in Edmonton because your local peewee goalie could have won games there?
Bottom line is he won a cup, and guided Pittsburgh to another finals appearance. That's something not many have done in back to back years.
What they have done is all relative, but each of those goalies is a starting netminder, and the fact remains that if you want to get a starting netminder in this league, odds are you'll have to pony up a high asset (draft pick wise). Half the leagues starters, and half the netminders period, come from the top three rounds of the draft.
Yes, we could get a Tim Thomas, or a Antti Neimi or a Sergei Bobrovsky, but stats prove, your greatest chance of landing a starting netminder is to draft one, and draft one early. That same statistic plays out for all positions.
I got you and stonehedge mixed up. My bad, I'm sorry for the confusion.
I think if we stay at 56 there are 3 players I see as Futa/Yanetti type picks....
Justin Bailey C Kitchener OHL- 6'3 195lbs
Emile Poirier LW Gatineau QMJHL- 6'0 170lbs same team has Hyka
Zach Nastasiuk, C Owen Sound- 6'1 191lbs
Those 3 I can see being there, for some reason in the past Swede's, Czech's or Finn's aren't on DL's radar.
Really successful, as in winning a Stanley Cup and/or having successful NHL careers. Drafting a goalie seems like much more of a crap shoot than forwards/defense (especially in the 1st round). Remember when we had those 3 picks in 2003? We should have KILLED that draft. Instead, we took Dustin Brown (ok, that's fine) and Tambellini and Boyle? I mean, WTF man.... it doesn't make any sense to draft 'projects' or take unnecessary gambles on draft day. I would always go with best available and use the later picks on guys that have more potential. It seems like Lombardi is great at finding guys in the 2-4 round who have dropped in value (Voynov, Toffoli to name a couple).
Call me crazy but I think Scrivens will do excellent for us. For the money, I like him as a backup. Can't do much better than that for his caphit. Seems like a really good team guy also.