Tough to say, I think some companies have better reputations than others so pick and choose the information you see wisely. I'd love to hear who you think should not be on the list vs who should be on the lists, because I can tell you if you have you're own "biases".
I've seen some bad lists this year, but I have seen some good ones.
And I will correct myself of my comment on McArthur above, his final rankings are better than his first one.
But my offer stands - "who you think should not be on the list vs who should be on the lists," and I'll share my opionion with you.