Yea, the bullpen has been bad but you don't judge a relief corps by win/loss record.
Wins and losses are a team stat and should not be used to evaluate an individual player or a group of players (in this case, the bullpen)
Exactly. The bullpen has come into a lot of tight games, and when the offense isn't coming through in those situations, the bullpen is likely to get the loss. It's unfortunate that they haven't been able to shut opponents down as often as we would like to see, but the rest of the numbers (the ones that reflect their actual abilities) suggest they've been pretty much average so far this year.
The bullpen is supposed to come in, in a lot of tight games.
Win/loss is a bit more of an individual stat for a pen than it is a starting pitcher, as long as you keep it in context and look at supporting stats, and the why's. It's the same idea that BABIP now automatically = luck, it's not always the case.
As a whole, Cecil has largely been the cause of the pen's terrible win/loss record though (Storen hasn't helped, and Floyed has 2 unfavourable losses). Look at situations Cecil has blown, and the situations he's entered games (info all readily available on BR) -- these were NOT situations you expect the bullpen to fall short. Cecil entered the following games and blew the lead or didn't hold;
April 5 - bottom 8, no runners, 0 out ahead by 1 / exited bottom 8, 1 out down by 1
April 8 - top 7, runners on 1st and 2nd, 1 out, ahead by 1 / exited top 7, 3 out, down by 1
April 12 - top 7, no runners, 9 out, tie / exited top 7, runners on 2nd and 3rd, 2 out down by 1
April 21 - bottom 7, bases loaded 1 out, ahead by 1 / exited bottom 8, end, down 1
Apr 25 - bottom 9 (start of inning - tie) / exited end of 9 loss by 1
I mean, April 5, 12 and 25 were times when Cecil entered a game with a clean inning and flat out couldn't get 3 outs without giving up the lead, in a 1 month span. April 8th and 21st you could make an argument he inherited a ****** situation, but a ground ball double play in either situation would have arguably changed the outcome of the game.
Yeah the offense hasn't done the pen too many favours late in the game, but it's not like the bullpen deserves a winning, or even .500 record at this point either.