I don't really have time to read every post, but life's very short and I'm rarely serious about anything. My point was not to debate if people were or were not over-reacting, it was to say even if they were, I grasp why.
I realize there's risk signing him long-term, because risk is in inherent in every action and decision we make or avoid. But you work with the data and circumstance before you and try to make the best calculated decision you can. And while I can agree with your assessment on the risk present here, I still fall on the guy's .65 career PPG, his professionalism and work ethic, his never-wavering commitment to the NYR, and his desire to improve and succeed, which is backed by a track record of consistent improvement. For me, that mitigates the potential risks of signing him long-term and to me at least it looks a lot riskier to not lock him up longer.
I rarely jump to rash conclusions, nor do I feel any disdain for the FO. I think things are more done by committee these days, and the results the past few seasons are somewhat hard to argue against. Nonetheless, this actual situation gives me a bad feeling and I simply have a concern, for reasons already stated, that it may well backfire. This could all amount to nothing, but the potential for this to bite the team in the ass is somewhat hard to ignore imo.
well we were all paranoid with Brad Richards getting hurt and them not being able to buy him out but that worked out.
Lets not flip out and worry that Zucc will leave as a Free Agent. If he comes in and does well he will get his extension in January. It wont go to Free Agency